Wednesday, 2018-04-18

*** sar has quit IRC05:35
*** sar has joined #openstack-cyborg08:45
openstackgerritwangqi proposed openstack/cyborg master: Drop py33 target in tox.ini
*** zhipeng has joined #openstack-cyborg10:27
*** zhipeng has quit IRC11:08
*** sar has quit IRC11:15
*** sar has joined #openstack-cyborg11:21
*** zhipeng has joined #openstack-cyborg11:27
*** Kevin_Zheng has quit IRC11:30
*** zhipeng has quit IRC11:34
*** edleafe has quit IRC12:35
*** edleafe has joined #openstack-cyborg12:35
*** zhipeng has joined #openstack-cyborg12:48
*** sar has quit IRC13:39
*** Li_Liu has joined #openstack-cyborg13:39
*** Kevin_Zheng has joined #openstack-cyborg13:45
*** Helloway has joined #openstack-cyborg13:56
zhipeng#startmeeting openstack-cyborg14:00
openstackMeeting started Wed Apr 18 14:00:33 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is zhipeng. Information about MeetBot at
openstackUseful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.14:00
*** openstack changes topic to " (Meeting topic: openstack-cyborg)"14:00
openstackThe meeting name has been set to 'openstack_cyborg'14:00
zhipeng#topic Roll Call14:00
*** openstack changes topic to "Roll Call (Meeting topic: openstack-cyborg)"14:00
zhipeng#info Howard14:01
*** Melissa_S has joined #openstack-cyborg14:01
Li_Liu#info Li_Liu14:01
*** shaohe_feng_ has joined #openstack-cyborg14:01
Melissa_S#info Melissa Sussmann14:02
Helloway#info Helloway14:02
edleafe#info Ed Leafe14:03
*** dolpher has joined #openstack-cyborg14:04
shaohe_feng_#info shaohe14:04
shaohe_feng_hi all14:04
zhipenghi shaohe :)14:05
*** Chuck__ has joined #openstack-cyborg14:06
*** sar has joined #openstack-cyborg14:06
zhipengokey guys let's get into business14:07
zhipeng#topic MS1 preparation14:07
*** openstack changes topic to "MS1 preparation (Meeting topic: openstack-cyborg)"14:07
zhipengplease be aware that this week is the MS1 freeze14:08
zhipengwhich means after this week we will not review any more proposals14:09
zhipengthere is another target for MS1 which is the community wide goal14:09
*** ted_ has joined #openstack-cyborg14:10
*** chucksong has joined #openstack-cyborg14:10
zhipengwe've already land a patch on mutable configuration enablement14:10
zhipengbut I'm not sure about the mox/mox3 removal14:10
zhipenganyone volunteer to take a look ?14:10
*** Chuck__ has quit IRC14:10
*** Melissa_S has quit IRC14:11
zhipengnova seems to be the only project working on that14:12
shaohe_feng_Does cyborg  use mox?14:12
zhipengi'm not sure14:12
*** Melissa has joined #openstack-cyborg14:12
shaohe_feng_let me check it.14:12
*** Melissa is now known as Guest1870514:13
zhipengthx shaohe_feng_14:13
zhipengcheck our test files14:13
Guest18705#info Melissa - sorry I disconnected14:13
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: no mox found14:13
zhipengno worries melissa :)14:13
zhipengshaohe_feng_ oh great then :)14:14
zhipengwe've accomplished the community goal then14:14
*** jiapei has joined #openstack-cyborg14:14
zhipeng#info this week is MS1 freeze for all spec proposal14:14
zhipeng#info should try to land those already heavily discussed patches14:15
zhipeng#topic bug report on storyboard14:17
*** openstack changes topic to "bug report on storyboard (Meeting topic: openstack-cyborg)"14:17
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: just spec ready this week? no need for patches?14:18
zhipengshaohe_feng_ yes, we should try to land as many mature specs as possible this week14:19
jiapeido we have a link of spec?14:19
zhipengokey coming back to the bug report14:20
zhipengthe first one14:20
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: still can not work?14:22
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: how to reproduce it?14:22
zhipengi'm asking the author to join irc right now :)14:23
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: OK, mutil-host14:23
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: we does not try multi-host.14:23
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: got it.14:24
shaohe_feng_more details more easy to fix it.14:24
zhipengyes I was just saying that to the author14:26
*** shashaguo has joined #openstack-cyborg14:26
zhipengok I just reviewed kosamara's bug report14:27
zhipengi think it is related14:27
zhipengmaybe we should not have a enable_service cyborg14:27
zhipengsince there is no cyborg service14:27
*** Rahul has joined #openstack-cyborg14:27
zhipenglet me re-paste kosamara's report14:27
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: enable cyborg plugin?14:28
*** Rahul is now known as Guest5267814:28
zhipengh[m]Hi! I was trying cyborg in devstack again. At some point devstack is checking if every service is running and 2 things related to cyborg occur:14:28
* zhipengh[m] sent a long message: zhipengh[m]_2018-04-18_14:29:28.txt <>14:29
zhipengGuest52678 we are reviewing another bug report14:30
zhipengwhich might be related to yours14:30
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: does the author enable cyborg plugin?14:30
zhipengshaohe_feng_ i don't think so14:30
shaohe_feng_zhipeng:!/story/2001827 the link just enable service.14:31
Li_LiuI remember Jinghan or someone provided a localrc file or something like that before14:31
Guest52678Hi .. Yes i have enabled cyborg services14:31
Guest52678But still it was failing14:31
shaohe_feng_it should enable both service and plugin14:32
zhipengI think another reason is my enable mutable config patch14:32
zhipengERROR cyborg TypeError: launch_service() got an unexpected keyword argument 'restart_method'14:32
Guest52678Hi Zhipeng, i got the same type of error msg14:32
zhipengi will take a look into that14:32
Guest52678like the link you provided14:33
zhipengGuest52678 yeah I probably know what triggers it lol14:33
zhipengGuest52678 the solution is three fold I guess: (1)remove cyborg from enable_service(2)add cyborg plugin in the enable_service(3) wait for my patch on the restart_method error14:35
zhipengthx for the bug report :)14:36
zhipengI would otherwise has no clue about the problem I introduced14:36
zhipengokey let's move on14:37
zhipeng#topic Rocky Critical Spec Review14:37
*** openstack changes topic to "Rocky Critical Spec Review (Meeting topic: openstack-cyborg)"14:37
zhipengnow let's start from the mature ones14:37
zhipeng#info Sundar's sched spec14:38
zhipengshaohe_feng_ Li_Liu looks good to you guys ?14:38
zhipengedleafe sorry14:38
Li_LiuOverall looks good to me. But I think Jay's most recently comment still needs to be addressed14:40
Li_Liushouldn't be a big change14:41
zhipeng#info programming spec14:42
edleafezhipeng: sorry, on a call14:42
edleafezhipeng: I'll review it today14:42
zhipengedleafe no problem :) thx man14:42
zhipengGuest18705 are you around ?14:43
*** joe___ has joined #openstack-cyborg14:44
zhipengI think you or chuck should help review the programming spec14:44
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: looks good to me.14:44
zhipengaltho Li_Liu should have more than enough exprience on Xilinx FPGA :)14:44
zhipengokey next14:46
zhipeng#info bitstream metadata standardization14:46
Li_Liuzhipeng: about the fpga reconfigure spec, should we put that in for R? or we wait for future?14:46
Li_LiuI mentioned in the community email last week14:46
zhipengLi_Liu I doubt we have enough bandwidth on that14:46
Li_Liuok, great14:46
zhipengdon't forget to reply to Jay's comment :)14:47
Li_LiuSure, but hope Sundar can provide some insights as well14:47
Li_Liufor Jay's comment I mean14:47
zhipengof course14:47
chucksongok, I will take a look at the programming spec14:48
zhipengI guess metadata still needs Sundar's further review14:48
zhipenghey thx chucksong14:48
zhipengalso the metadata one I just mentioned :)14:48
zhipeng#info quota spec still needs more work14:49
zhipeng#info will need Sundar to present on the new agent-driver api spec14:49
zhipengokey I think that was we could do for today14:49
zhipeng#topic other open patches14:50
*** openstack changes topic to "other open patches (Meeting topic: openstack-cyborg)"14:50
zhipeng#info object/api implementation for vf/pf14:50
zhipengI think this looks great now14:50
zhipengshaohe_feng_ could you help workflow+1 it ?14:51
Li_Liugood to see this patch can be merged. Will have another follow up patch14:51
zhipengLi_Liu lol14:51
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: yes14:51
Li_Liushaohe_feng_ could you try the patch after it merged?14:51
shaohe_feng_Li_Liu: yes.14:52
shaohe_feng_will try14:53
zhipengokey gr8t14:53
zhipeng#topic AoB14:53
*** openstack changes topic to "AoB (Meeting topic: openstack-cyborg)"14:53
zhipengany other business ?14:53
shaohe_feng_what is AoB?14:54
Cocosame question for me14:54
zhipengany other business14:55
zhipengany other topics14:55
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: client?
zhipengLi_Liu just workflow+1 it :)14:56
Li_Liuthanks a lot :)14:56
zhipengi mean plz workflow+1 that patch14:57
zhipengnot just cr+2 :P14:57
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: will add openstackclient plugin and httpclient code later.14:57
zhipengsounds great shaohe14:57
Li_Liujust did14:57
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: maybe a example cmd. such as: cyborg accelerator list14:58
zhipengoh yes exactly14:59
zhipengbtw the first week of may I will be traveling to KubeCon EU15:03
zhipengand will socialize cyborg with the k8s community15:03
zhipengif you guys have any design ideas, plz feel free to share it15:03
zhipengat the moment I only had discussion with Sundar15:03
zhipengand looks like a CRD controller might be the patch15:04
shaohe_feng_EU, which country?15:04
Li_Liuinterested to see their reactions on Cyborg15:04
zhipengyes if we were to propose an incubation project something like kube-cyborg15:04
zhipengwould be a very intersting idea :P15:05
zhipenganyways, still two weeks away, feel free to chime in15:05
shaohe_feng_zhipeng: sounds good15:05
zhipengokey if no AoB15:06
zhipenglet's conclude the meeting todday15:06
zhipengthx everyone for participating15:06
*** openstack changes topic to "OpenStack Cyborg Project Discussion"15:07
openstackMeeting ended Wed Apr 18 15:07:05 2018 UTC.  Information about MeetBot at . (v 0.1.4)15:07
openstackMinutes (text):
openstackgerritMerged openstack/python-cyborgclient master: Initialize cyborgclient repository
*** chucksong has quit IRC15:11
*** jiapei has quit IRC15:19
*** zhipeng has quit IRC15:19
*** Helloway has quit IRC15:21
*** joe___ has quit IRC15:40
*** wangzhh has quit IRC16:26
*** Guest18705 has quit IRC17:01
*** shashaguo has quit IRC17:16
*** Kevin_Zheng has quit IRC17:34
*** Coco has quit IRC19:30
*** sar has quit IRC20:34
*** Li_Liu has quit IRC21:17
*** dolpher has quit IRC21:25

Generated by 2.15.3 by Marius Gedminas - find it at!