14:00:33 <zhipeng> #startmeeting openstack-cyborg
14:00:33 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Apr 18 14:00:33 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is zhipeng. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:34 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:37 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'openstack_cyborg'
14:00:56 <zhipeng> #topic Roll Call
14:01:01 <zhipeng> #info Howard
14:01:18 <Li_Liu> #info Li_Liu
14:02:01 <Melissa_S> #info Melissa Sussmann
14:02:05 <Helloway> #info Helloway
14:03:18 <edleafe> #info Ed Leafe
14:04:34 <shaohe_feng_> #info shaohe
14:04:39 <shaohe_feng_> hi all
14:05:18 <zhipeng> hi shaohe :)
14:07:52 <zhipeng> okey guys let's get into business
14:07:58 <zhipeng> #topic MS1 preparation
14:08:18 <zhipeng> please be aware that this week is the MS1 freeze
14:09:01 <zhipeng> which means after this week we will not review any more proposals
14:09:49 <zhipeng> there is another target for MS1 which is the community wide goal
14:09:59 <zhipeng> #link https://governance.openstack.org/tc/goals/rocky/index.html
14:10:27 <zhipeng> we've already land a patch on mutable configuration enablement
14:10:41 <zhipeng> but I'm not sure about the mox/mox3 removal
14:10:48 <zhipeng> anyone volunteer to take a look ?
14:12:01 <zhipeng> nova seems to be the only project working on that
14:12:31 <shaohe_feng_> Does cyborg  use mox?
14:12:38 <zhipeng> i'm not sure
14:12:50 <shaohe_feng_> let me check it.
14:13:26 <zhipeng> thx shaohe_feng_
14:13:37 <zhipeng> check our test files
14:13:38 <Guest18705> #info Melissa - sorry I disconnected
14:13:43 <zhipeng> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:bp/mox-removal+(status:open+OR+status:merged
14:13:46 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: no mox found
14:13:51 <zhipeng> no worries melissa :)
14:14:00 <zhipeng> shaohe_feng_ oh great then :)
14:14:16 <zhipeng> we've accomplished the community goal then
14:14:58 <zhipeng> #info this week is MS1 freeze for all spec proposal
14:15:32 <zhipeng> #info should try to land those already heavily discussed patches
14:17:30 <zhipeng> #topic bug report on storyboard
14:17:53 <zhipeng> #link https://storyboard.openstack.org/#!/project_group/77
14:18:23 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: just spec ready this week? no need for patches?
14:19:02 <zhipeng> shaohe_feng_ yes, we should try to land as many mature specs as possible this week
14:19:24 <jiapei> do we have a link of spec?
14:19:45 <Li_Liu> https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/cyborg
14:20:23 <zhipeng> okey coming back to the bug report
14:20:29 <zhipeng> the first one
14:20:36 <zhipeng> #link https://storyboard.openstack.org/#!/story/2001827
14:22:13 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: still can not work?
14:22:21 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: how to reproduce it?
14:23:00 <zhipeng> i'm asking the author to join irc right now :)
14:23:01 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: OK, mutil-host
14:23:17 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: we does not try multi-host.
14:23:36 <zhipeng> MULTI_HOST=False
14:24:18 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: got it.
14:24:36 <shaohe_feng_> more details more easy to fix it.
14:26:18 <zhipeng> yes I was just saying that to the author
14:27:06 <zhipeng> ok I just reviewed kosamara's bug report
14:27:09 <zhipeng> i think it is related
14:27:23 <zhipeng> maybe we should not have a enable_service cyborg
14:27:32 <zhipeng> since there is no cyborg service
14:27:56 <zhipeng> let me re-paste kosamara's report
14:28:12 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: enable cyborg plugin?
14:28:22 <zhipengh[m]> Hi! I was trying cyborg in devstack again. At some point devstack is checking if every service is running and 2 things related to cyborg occur:
14:29:28 * zhipengh[m] sent a long message: zhipengh[m]_2018-04-18_14:29:28.txt <https://matrix.org/_matrix/media/v1/download/matrix.org/ausGkEZFQPdCotjzerLIvGDq>
14:30:02 <zhipeng> ....
14:30:25 <zhipeng> Guest52678 we are reviewing another bug report
14:30:31 <zhipeng> which might be related to yours
14:30:39 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: does the author enable cyborg plugin?
14:30:53 <zhipeng> shaohe_feng_ i don't think so
14:31:16 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: https://storyboard.openstack.org/#!/story/2001827 the link just enable service.
14:31:31 <Li_Liu> I remember Jinghan or someone provided a localrc file or something like that before
14:31:38 <Guest52678> Hi .. Yes i have enabled cyborg services
14:31:51 <Guest52678> But still it was failing
14:32:02 <zhipeng> #link http://paste.openstack.org/show/ym8eEtMcHQjEWeLSkT0F/
14:32:07 <shaohe_feng_> it should enable both service and plugin
14:32:24 <zhipeng> I think another reason is my enable mutable config patch
14:32:49 <zhipeng> ERROR cyborg TypeError: launch_service() got an unexpected keyword argument 'restart_method'
14:32:55 <Guest52678> Hi Zhipeng, i got the same type of error msg
14:32:58 <zhipeng> i will take a look into that
14:33:02 <Guest52678> like the link you provided
14:33:21 <zhipeng> Guest52678 yeah I probably know what triggers it lol
14:33:44 <shaohe_feng_> good
14:33:53 <zhipeng> #link https://review.openstack.org/559303
14:35:02 <zhipeng> Guest52678 the solution is three fold I guess: (1)remove cyborg from enable_service(2)add cyborg plugin in the enable_service(3) wait for my patch on the restart_method error
14:36:15 <Guest52678> ok
14:36:38 <zhipeng> thx for the bug report :)
14:36:54 <zhipeng> I would otherwise has no clue about the problem I introduced
14:37:33 <zhipeng> okey let's move on
14:37:44 <zhipeng> #topic Rocky Critical Spec Review
14:37:59 <zhipeng> now let's start from the mature ones
14:38:15 <zhipeng> #info Sundar's sched spec
14:38:18 <zhipeng> #link https://review.openstack.org/554717
14:38:30 <zhipeng> shaohe_feng_ Li_Liu looks good to you guys ?
14:38:35 <zhipeng> edleaf
14:38:50 <zhipeng> edleafe sorry
14:40:54 <Li_Liu> Overall looks good to me. But I think Jay's most recently comment still needs to be addressed
14:41:01 <zhipeng> okey
14:41:30 <Li_Liu> shouldn't be a big change
14:42:21 <zhipeng> #info programming spec
14:42:27 <zhipeng> #link https://review.openstack.org/559395
14:42:33 <edleafe> zhipeng: sorry, on a call
14:42:42 <edleafe> zhipeng: I'll review it today
14:42:47 <zhipeng> edleafe no problem :) thx man
14:43:51 <zhipeng> Guest18705 are you around ?
14:44:06 <zhipeng> I think you or chuck should help review the programming spec
14:44:13 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: looks good to me.
14:44:34 <zhipeng> altho Li_Liu should have more than enough exprience on Xilinx FPGA :)
14:46:14 <zhipeng> okey next
14:46:25 <zhipeng> #info bitstream metadata standardization
14:46:27 <zhipeng> #link https://review.openstack.org/558265
14:46:28 <Li_Liu> zhipeng: about the fpga reconfigure spec, should we put that in for R? or we wait for future?
14:46:41 <Li_Liu> I mentioned in the community email last week
14:46:48 <zhipeng> Li_Liu I doubt we have enough bandwidth on that
14:46:57 <Li_Liu> ok, great
14:47:00 <zhipeng> don't forget to reply to Jay's comment :)
14:47:30 <Li_Liu> Sure, but hope Sundar can provide some insights as well
14:47:39 <Li_Liu> for Jay's comment I mean
14:47:39 <zhipeng> of course
14:48:21 <chucksong> ok, I will take a look at the programming spec
14:48:22 <zhipeng> I guess metadata still needs Sundar's further review
14:48:31 <zhipeng> hey thx chucksong
14:48:38 <zhipeng> also the metadata one I just mentioned :)
14:49:17 <chucksong> sure
14:49:24 <zhipeng> #info quota spec still needs more work
14:49:38 <zhipeng> #info will need Sundar to present on the new agent-driver api spec
14:49:52 <zhipeng> okey I think that was we could do for today
14:50:13 <zhipeng> #topic other open patches
14:50:31 <zhipeng> #info object/api implementation for vf/pf
14:50:41 <zhipeng> #link https://review.openstack.org/552734
14:50:47 <zhipeng> I think this looks great now
14:51:09 <zhipeng> shaohe_feng_ could you help workflow+1 it ?
14:51:11 <Li_Liu> good to see this patch can be merged. Will have another follow up patch
14:51:26 <zhipeng> Li_Liu lol
14:51:33 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: yes
14:51:41 <Li_Liu> shaohe_feng_ could you try the patch after it merged?
14:52:55 <shaohe_feng_> Li_Liu: yes.
14:53:02 <shaohe_feng_> will try
14:53:16 <zhipeng> okey gr8t
14:53:35 <zhipeng> #topic AoB
14:53:45 <zhipeng> any other business ?
14:54:03 <shaohe_feng_> what is AoB?
14:54:40 <Coco> same question for me
14:55:00 <zhipeng> any other business
14:55:04 <zhipeng> any other topics
14:55:07 <zhipeng> :)
14:55:55 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: client? https://review.openstack.org/#/c/560400/
14:56:47 <zhipeng> Li_Liu just workflow+1 it :)
14:56:54 <Li_Liu> thanks a lot :)
14:57:06 <zhipeng> i mean plz workflow+1 that patch
14:57:16 <zhipeng> not just cr+2 :P
14:57:24 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: will add openstackclient plugin and httpclient code later.
14:57:42 <zhipeng> sounds great shaohe
14:57:45 <Li_Liu> just did
14:58:19 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: maybe a example cmd. such as: cyborg accelerator list
14:59:14 <zhipeng> oh yes exactly
15:03:14 <zhipeng> btw the first week of may I will be traveling to KubeCon EU
15:03:25 <zhipeng> and will socialize cyborg with the k8s community
15:03:37 <Li_Liu> g8t
15:03:38 <zhipeng> if you guys have any design ideas, plz feel free to share it
15:03:50 <zhipeng> at the moment I only had discussion with Sundar
15:04:03 <zhipeng> and looks like a CRD controller might be the patch
15:04:06 <shaohe_feng_> EU, which country?
15:04:07 <zhipeng> path...
15:04:11 <zhipeng> Danmark
15:04:32 <Li_Liu> interested to see their reactions on Cyborg
15:04:55 <zhipeng> yes if we were to propose an incubation project something like kube-cyborg
15:05:06 <zhipeng> would be a very intersting idea :P
15:05:33 <zhipeng> anyways, still two weeks away, feel free to chime in
15:05:55 <shaohe_feng_> zhipeng: sounds good
15:06:42 <zhipeng> okey if no AoB
15:06:48 <zhipeng> let's conclude the meeting todday
15:06:50 <zhipeng> today
15:06:54 <Coco> ok
15:06:58 <zhipeng> thx everyone for participating
15:07:05 <zhipeng> #endmeeting