13:01:16 #startmeeting watcher 13:01:17 Meeting started Wed Feb 15 13:01:16 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is acabot. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 13:01:19 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 13:01:21 o/ 13:01:21 The meeting name has been set to 'watcher' 13:01:29 o/ 13:01:31 hi 13:01:32 o/ 13:01:34 hello 13:01:35 hi 13:01:59 agenda for today #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Watcher_Meeting_Agenda#02.2F15.2F2016 13:02:42 #topic Announcements 13:02:53 #info PTG is in 1 week, etherpad is open and a 1st draft of agenda is available / no projector in the room 13:03:04 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/pike-watcher-ptg 13:03:26 I have a couple of new topics to add since last meeting 13:03:35 hi 13:03:47 hi 13:04:05 I plan to finalize the agenda on Friday so please add any topic that needs to be discussed 13:04:51 as our new PTL will be in remote, I'd like to have a clear agenda before we start 13:05:19 acabot: i will add more detail. 13:05:31 #info Prudhvi Rao Shedimbi (pshedimb) has been nominated to Watcher Core 13:05:40 #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2017-February/112114.html 13:05:46 please vote on the ML 13:06:08 +1 13:06:31 I'd like to have our new cores on board before the PTG 13:06:39 +1 13:06:43 #info licanwei has been nominated to Watcher Core 13:06:51 #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2017-February/112116.html 13:06:58 please vote also for licanwei 13:07:01 +1 13:07:28 thank you acabot, vincent,sballe 13:07:37 alexchadin : I think if we have enough +1 by next Monday, we can add them in core group 13:07:48 acabot: +1 13:07:52 acabot: +1 13:08:03 acabot: +1 13:08:04 thanka acabot vincentfrancoise alexchadin 13:08:07 acabot: vote is only by core, right? 13:08:23 hidekazu_ : no no anyone can vote on the ML 13:08:38 hidekazu_: feel free to give your vote :) 13:08:38 acabot: i see. 13:08:40 hidekazu_ : most +1 we have, better it is 13:08:54 acabot: +1 13:08:54 acabot: totally agree! 13:09:20 #info no meeting next week as we will be in Atlanta for the most part 13:09:58 acabot: seems that it is your last meeting as PTL 13:10:10 I was also thinking about nominating hidekazu_ as core BTW 13:10:11 alexchadin : :-) yes, 13:10:15 acabot: thanks for a great job as PTL! 13:10:24 sballe_ : thx 13:10:27 You have done a fantastic job 13:10:31 acabot: Thank you for your great work! 13:10:33 great work acabot :) 13:10:56 thank you alexchadin pshedimb 13:10:59 acabot: good job boss :) 13:11:11 lol 13:11:15 vincentfrancoise : thx (not your boss anymore ;-)) 13:11:17 great work for watcher 13:11:27 vincentfrancoise: ah, you again used this word! :D 13:11:43 alexchadin: hahaha did it on purpose :D 13:11:56 hidekazu_ : what do you think about becoming watcher core ? 13:12:08 #link http://stackalytics.com/report/contribution/watcher/90 13:12:26 acabot: yes, i will do my best. 13:12:57 acabot: +1 13:13:07 acabot: i will be more involved in watcher in pike cycle. 13:13:08 I'll send an email on the ML for you hidekazu_ then ;) 13:13:11 hidekazu_: you've made good progress and your reviews is helpfull 13:13:22 +1 for nominating hidekazu_ 13:13:29 +1 13:13:32 vincentfrancoise: alexchadin: thanks. 13:13:56 #action vincentfrancoise nominate hidekazu_ as core on the ML 13:14:10 please all vote on the ML for hidekazu_ 13:14:13 +1 13:14:27 +1 13:14:44 #info next meeting will be chaired by alexchadin ;-) 13:14:56 acabot: I'll do my best 13:15:01 a quick work about the track chair process 13:15:21 our talks are moving from categories 13:15:39 no pb for now as they all stay in different categories 13:15:55 sballe_ : your talk is still a lightning talk (I don't know why) 13:16:15 I don;t understand it either. it is setup as a presentation 13:16:22 can you change it? 13:16:27 and the foundation should annonce a dedicated slot for each project to give a status update at the summit 13:16:51 even if the Watcher presentation is not selected, we should have a slot 13:17:03 sballe_ : no I can't 13:17:09 anythign I can do? 13:17:19 other than what I alreayd did 13:17:20 sballe_ : I don't think so 13:17:54 any other announcement ? 13:18:16 * acabot thinking its the last time he is asking this stupid question :-) 13:18:29 #topic Review Action Items 13:18:40 Watcher specs 13:18:53 we still have specs targeted for ocata that needs to be moved 13:18:59 before being reviewed 13:19:14 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398162/ 13:19:36 acabot, I will move noisy neigbor to Pike. Totally missed it. 13:19:55 #action pshedimb move https://review.openstack.org/#/c/398162/ to pike 13:20:12 #action hvprash move https://review.openstack.org/#/c/391374/ to Pike 13:20:35 #action vincentfrancoise move https://review.openstack.org/#/c/420612/ to Pike 13:20:46 acabot: ok 13:20:51 Suspended audit state needs a gate fix 13:20:57 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/434144/ 13:21:08 acabot: yes, i will fix. 13:21:21 #action hidekazu_ fix gate for https://review.openstack.org/#/c/434144/ 13:21:28 specs for blueprint cancel action plan needs a new PS 13:21:35 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432264/ 13:23:01 hidekazu_ : do you know the nickname of Aditi ? 13:23:12 adisky_ 13:23:19 thx 13:23:43 #action adisky_ add a new PS answering comments on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432264/ 13:23:52 Define when an action plan is stale/invalid needs reviews 13:23:58 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432193/ 13:24:17 who wants to review ? 13:24:52 acabot: i will 13:25:02 #action acabot hidekazu_ review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/432193/ 13:25:10 Support Description For Dynamic Action needs final reviews from core 13:25:18 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/401111/ 13:26:01 #action sballe_ acabot hvprash alexchadin review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/401111/ 13:26:18 Moving to Watcher 13:26:28 workload-balance-tempest needs core final reviews 13:26:35 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/watcher+branch:master+topic:detached/workload-balance-tempest 13:27:05 alexchadin : could you have a look at it ? 13:27:42 acabot: I will take workload_stabilization, I'm not familiar with workload-balance strategy 13:28:20 #action alexchadin review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/393355/ 13:28:34 I think we will have to wait for our new cores :-) 13:28:40 acabot: the other one cannot be finished because it doesn't support the absence of metrics 13:28:58 vincentfrancoise : ok could you W-1 ? 13:29:05 acabot: ok 13:29:15 Add Action Notification needs core final reviews 13:29:22 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/427646/ 13:29:34 #action dtardivel review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/427646/ 13:29:54 Reactivate watcher dashboard plugin in devstack/local.conf.controller needs core final reviews 13:30:02 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/429256/ 13:30:21 W+1 13:30:43 alexchadin : what do you mean ? 13:30:55 acabot: I'm ready to W+1 it 13:31:09 ok vincentfrancoise can you +2 ? 13:31:27 vincentfrancoise : or you need to do more testes 13:31:35 s/testes/tests 13:31:55 acabot: I want to have it enabled in the tempest tests as well so we know if it breaks again 13:32:40 vincentfrancoise : ok so should we add a wishlist bug in this case ? 13:32:42 but I don't want to block it just for that as well, that's why I didn't +1 or -1'd it 13:33:24 acabot: we can do that yes 13:33:38 #action vincentfrancoise submit a bug to have tempest tests for watcher dashboard 13:34:09 #action vincentfrancoise alexchadin review & merge https://review.openstack.org/#/c/429256/ 13:34:17 dynamic-action-description needs a new PS 13:34:24 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/watcher+branch:master+topic:bp/dynamic-action-description 13:34:44 is yumeng here ? 13:35:15 #action hanrong add a PS for https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/watcher+branch:master+topic:bp/dynamic-action-description 13:35:24 #topic Blueprint/Bug Review and Discussion 13:35:44 #info Bug fixing in progress for Ocata-rcfinal targeted for February 16th 13:35:51 #link https://launchpad.net/watcher/+milestone/ocata-rc-final 13:37:12 we need reviews on bug fixing before tomorrow so that we can release Watcher in v1.0.1 13:37:23 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/429995/ 13:37:30 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/422295/ 13:37:37 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/430521/ 13:38:13 Will review them 13:38:49 #action alexchadin vincentfrancoise review and merge (if possible) https://review.openstack.org/#/c/429995/ https://review.openstack.org/#/c/422295/ & https://review.openstack.org/#/c/430521/ 13:39:24 acabot: will do 13:39:32 thx 13:39:49 #info We will release a v1.0.1 on February 16th due to #1662810 13:39:57 #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/watcher/+bug/1662810 13:39:57 Launchpad bug 1662810 in watcher "model_root.get_node_instances(node) returns none instances" [Medium,Fix released] - Assigned to licanwei (li-canwei2) 13:40:00 acabot https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/watcher+branch:master+topic:bp/dynamic-action-description W-1 by vincent 13:40:26 licanwei : yes because spec has been updated 13:40:41 since hanrong implementation 13:40:59 licanwei : was it your question ? 13:41:11 acabot no question:) 13:41:26 licanwei : ok 13:41:51 so we are waiting for a new PS from hanrong based on updated spec 13:42:07 ok 13:42:17 #info dont forget that all fixed bugs should be backported to stable/ocata branch 13:43:07 #topic Open discussions 13:43:14 15 minutes left ! 13:43:23 #info Ceilometer API is now deprecated and not supported anymore in devstack 13:43:50 yeah I wanted to talk about this as well 13:43:52 so our existing strategies don't work any more in devstack 13:44:05 we have to rely on Gnocchi now 13:44:18 yes 13:44:20 can we go directly to Monasca? 13:44:42 Gnocchi doesn't sounds like the rigth choice. Not sure anybody is using it 13:44:56 sballe_ : no because Monasca is too heavy to be integrated with devstack 13:45:23 sballe_ : we don't really care about who is using it, we need to stick to devstack 13:45:23 it is proposed as official API replacement 13:45:26 so we end up doing extra busy work that doesn't really benefit anybody 13:45:26 sballe_: ^ 13:45:43 ok 13:45:47 alexchadin: ok 13:45:48 I've started to work on using gnocchi api for Watcher, but sanfern (right?) take this BP 13:45:52 sballe_ : no no we talk about devstack only (not a real env) 13:46:05 I've installed gnocchi, it works not bad at all 13:46:11 redhat support gnocchi. 13:46:15 alexchadin : good to hear 13:46:51 maybe we could have a quick sync with jdanjou next week in Atlanta 13:47:19 he is Telemetry PTL 13:47:24 Monasca is even too hard to install it, there are big technology stack 13:47:33 gnocchi is more lightweight 13:47:49 and it has good sync with ceilometer publishers 13:48:20 santhosh.fernandes took this BP a week ago but anyone discussed with him since ? 13:48:39 I wanted to speak with him, but he wasn't online 13:48:50 Actually, I'd like to complete my work here 13:48:53 I'm not sure he's really working on it 13:49:06 I've missed talks about taking this BP 13:49:24 acabot: he's pksingh's colleague so you can talk to him to know about it 13:50:05 vincentfrancoise : ok 13:50:40 acabot, alexchadin I have one thing to add 13:50:50 I think there needs to be change in new devstack local.conf, with placement-api mandatory now 13:51:00 To the one given in watcher docs 13:51:00 #action alexchadin sync with pksingh & santhosh64 to know the status of https://blueprints.launchpad.net/watcher/+spec/gnocchi-watcher 13:51:37 pshedimb: what commit are you talking about? 13:52:27 alexchadin, the new devstack needs placement-api in nova.conf of compute node. 13:52:34 Which was not required previously. 13:53:15 pshedimb: let's discuss it in openstack-watcher channel 13:53:25 alexchadin, okay. 13:54:00 I forgot to mention that we have our official Watcher logo !! 13:54:03 #link https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B_h5gjY7WQPMOWJUMlVhOG9rWGM 13:54:24 #info Watcher logo is now official #link at we have our offi 13:54:35 #undo 13:54:36 Removing item from minutes: #info Watcher logo is now official #link at we have our offi 13:54:41 #info Watcher logo is now official #link https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B_h5gjY7WQPMOWJUMlVhOG9rWGM 13:55:11 cool! 13:55:28 looks good :) 13:55:46 #info At the PTG, we�ll have stickers for your team of the mascot, plus signage on your room. 13:56:18 we will all be jellyfished !!! thx to jwcroppe :-D 13:56:19 seems that next summit will be filled with new logo merchandise :) 13:56:21 cool! Can somebody take a couple of stickers for me 13:56:35 sballe_ : sure I will 13:56:37 sballe_: +1 13:56:38 sballe_, I surely can 13:56:52 thx 13:57:39 its time for me to end my last meeting ! 13:58:05 thank you all for having Watcher been a great openstack project ! 13:58:11 bye thx! 13:58:12 thank you acabot 13:58:25 bye all! 13:58:27 thank you, acabot 13:58:28 acabot: thank you 13:58:31 and I'm sure that it will be even greater with alex ;-) 13:58:43 thanks acabot 13:58:53 see you in Atlanta ! 13:59:03 acabot: hope to see you in Summit :) 13:59:17 alexchadin : yes I hope so 13:59:24 bye 13:59:28 bye 13:59:31 bye 13:59:38 #endmeeting