08:00:16 <ifat_afek> #startmeeting vitrage
08:00:17 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Sep 27 08:00:16 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is ifat_afek. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:00:18 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
08:00:20 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'vitrage'
08:00:25 <ifat_afek> Hi everyone!
08:00:27 <eyalb> \o/
08:00:39 <annarez> Hi
08:01:02 <usman> hi
08:02:36 <danoffek> Hi
08:02:45 <najjar> hey hey
08:02:51 <nivolas> hello
08:02:57 <ifat_afek> Today’s agenda (at bit long):
08:03:03 <ifat_afek> •	Denver PTG
08:03:09 <ifat_afek> •	Vitrage Virtual PTG
08:03:09 <ifat_afek> •	Sydney Summit
08:03:10 <ifat_afek> •	Status and Updates
08:03:11 <ifat_afek> •	Open Discussion
08:03:16 <ifat_afek> #topic Denver PTG
08:03:34 <ifat_afek> Two weeks ago I attended the PTG in Denver. It was very productive. A very short recap:
08:03:46 <ifat_afek> I got technical help from the QA and infra teams and regarding the Queens goals – move the tempest tests to a separate repository, and support policy in code.
08:03:55 <ifat_afek> #link https://governance.openstack.org/tc/goals/queens/index.html
08:04:08 <ifat_afek> I participated in a self-healing meeting
08:04:16 <ifat_afek> The purpose of this meeting was to suggest self-healing use cases and architecture that involves several OpenStack projects like: Vitrage, Mistral, Ceilometer/Aodh/Gnocchi, Heat, Monasca, Congress, Masakari, Freezer, Senlin, Watcher…
08:04:27 <ifat_afek> The decision was to create a SIG (Special Interest Group) and continue the discussions via IRC and in Sydney summit.
08:04:33 <ifat_afek> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/self-healing-queens-ptg
08:04:39 <ifat_afek> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/self-healing-rocky-forum
08:04:58 <ifat_afek> Other than that – I had a meeting with Congress team: Eric Kao and Masahito Muri. We discussed a possible integration of Vitrage and Congress.
08:05:11 <ifat_afek> It can be done, but it is less trivial than I expected (requires changes in Congress), and I’m not sure if it’s the highest priority of any of our projects.
08:05:26 <ifat_afek> Last thing – I had an interview about Vitrage. I talked about Pike features and Queens plans. I don’t know if it was published already.
08:05:47 <ifat_afek> Any questions/comments?
08:07:03 <ifat_afek> #topic Vitrage Virtual PTG
08:07:17 <ifat_afek> We will hold the Vitrage virtual PTG on Tue-Wed October 17-18, and optionally (probably?) continue on the 19th.
08:07:26 <ifat_afek> The current list of topics is in the etherpad:
08:07:32 <ifat_afek> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/vitrage-ptg-queens
08:07:40 <ifat_afek> You are welcome to suggest new topics, or to write +1 on topics that you are interested in.
08:09:03 <ifat_afek> I’ll try to go over the etherpad later today and suggest a schedule. I’ll send it over the email
08:10:33 <ifat_afek> BTW, an important note - the next *two* IRC meetings will be canceled due to the holidays in Israel. So we actually won’t meet again until the virtual PTG…
08:10:42 <yujunz> OK...
08:10:49 <ifat_afek> We can, if you want, schedule an alternative meeting on our own IRC channel
08:11:49 <ifat_afek> yujunz: We are going to work next week on October 1-3, and some of us will also work on October 8-10. Our holidays will end at October 15
08:12:17 <yujunz> OK, we have holidays on Oct 1-8
08:12:47 <ifat_afek> So we can have a meeting on October 9/10 (with very few participants)
08:13:08 <ifat_afek> I forgot to mention that we have a day-out at work on October 16 ;-)
08:13:33 <yujunz> Happy outing. Where do you plan to go?
08:13:34 <ifat_afek> And I think we need to close the virtual PTG schedule by tomorrow
08:13:41 <ifat_afek> Not sure. danoffek?
08:13:55 <danoffek> About the plan :
08:14:03 <danoffek> You can join us if you're here
08:14:25 <danoffek> We are going to the north of the country, to a trip to Dvora waterfall
08:14:40 <yujunz> Thanks for the invitation. I should book a flight ticket right now :-)
08:14:49 <danoffek> But will stop before that to take a dive in a small, cold water gathering
08:14:53 <danoffek> With alcohol
08:15:05 <danoffek> And afterwards, we are going Kayaking in the north
08:15:30 <danoffek> Tell me if you need help with the tickets
08:15:47 <ifat_afek> I need help with a visa to Australia. Do you handle this too? ;-)
08:15:57 <danoffek> For a small fee...
08:16:09 <danoffek> For Yujun it's free
08:16:31 <ifat_afek> :-)
08:17:00 <yujunz> I'm so flattered, danoffek
08:17:11 <danoffek> :)
08:17:15 <ifat_afek> So yujunz, do you want to work on the PTG schedule now, or offline? I think offline might be easier. We can discuss the schedule via email
08:17:30 <yujunz> I prefer offiline
08:17:37 <ifat_afek> Ok, so let’s move on
08:17:43 <ifat_afek> #topic Sydney Summit
08:18:09 <ifat_afek> eyalb and I are supposed to attend the Sydney summit. Anyone else?
08:18:21 <ifat_afek> We are going to have two sessions about Vitrage:
08:18:29 <ifat_afek> #link https://www.openstack.org/summit/sydney-2017/summit-schedule/events/19508/advanced-fault-management-with-vitrage-and-mistral
08:18:35 <ifat_afek> #link https://www.openstack.org/summit/sydney-2017/summit-schedule/events/19473/vitrage-project-updates
08:18:47 <ifat_afek> Regarding the session with Mistral – I am looking for cool use cases, so let me know if you have any
08:19:22 <ifat_afek> Besides that, we can suggest topics for Forum sessions. But if it’s just eyalb and me, I don’t see a point in doing so.
08:19:37 <ifat_afek> Anything else regarding Sydney?
08:20:10 <ifat_afek> #topic Status and Updates
08:20:41 <ifat_afek> I’ll start with the great news - the ‘single-vendor’ flag was removed from Vitrage :-)
08:20:55 <ifat_afek> Thanks to ZTE involvement, and mostly thanks to Yujun
08:21:06 <eyalb> +2
08:21:36 <yujunz> Glad to hear that :-)
08:21:40 <ifat_afek> I have no other updates. I spent most of my time preparing to summits and trying to get a visa to Australia
08:21:44 <annarez> it's great!!
08:22:00 <najjar> i will update
08:22:15 <najjar> about the HA & History feature...
08:22:21 <najjar> #link https://docs.openstack.org/vitrage/latest/contributor/vitrage-ha-and-history-vision.html
08:22:30 <najjar> we had a meeting in last Monday about clarifying what is the vision in Vitrage and should be done.
08:22:44 <najjar> me and Idan (idan_hefetz) seat and plan what are the future tasks.
08:22:55 <najjar> we decided to start with implementing the persistor
08:23:04 <najjar> (listen to the events from the controller and push them to the DB)
08:23:23 <najjar> that's it... thanks :)
08:23:35 <ifat_afek> najjar: Great, thanks
08:25:10 <annarez> I'll update
08:25:50 <annarez> my vitrage id change is finally merged
08:26:30 <annarez> now the logic of vitrage id is in the transformer instead of the processor and graph
08:26:44 <ifat_afek> Much better
08:27:05 <idan_hefetz> my update
08:27:17 <idan_hefetz> sqlalchemy infrastructure is merged
08:27:23 <idan_hefetz> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/504917/
08:28:02 <idan_hefetz> This will allow for a few new features, including the persistor and template crud and a few more
08:29:06 <idan_hefetz> Also regarding the networkx 2 version, we should figure out how and if at all this requires support for queens
08:29:39 <idan_hefetz> in pike it is not supported and we should add <2 to the requires.txt
08:30:07 <idan_hefetz> that it, thanks :)
08:30:55 <nivolas> Another update,
08:31:27 <nivolas> i have added the support to include definition templates within templates, to avoid repetition of definitions
08:32:00 <nivolas> these definitions can then be used to create new scenarios
08:32:30 <ifat_afek> nivolas: Thanks. It can save some copy-paste in the templates
08:33:03 <ifat_afek> BTW, one question that was raised was if and how it is related to the entity equivalence feature
08:33:10 <ifat_afek> yujunz: Do you have any insights?
08:33:26 <ifat_afek> My initial thought were that it’s not related, but now I’m not sure
08:33:39 <yujunz> I haven't think it over yet
08:34:15 <ifat_afek> Ok. I don’t think that there is a conflict; but maybe some things can be common, or related somehow
08:35:16 <yujunz> I may consider it when I design the validator for these templates
08:35:46 <ifat_afek> The validator for the equivalence templates? nivolas already implemented the validator for the definition templates
08:36:10 <yujunz> Yes, for equivalence
08:36:17 <ifat_afek> Ok, makes sense
08:36:49 <ifat_afek> I notice that you also added this issue to the PTG etherpad
08:37:28 <ifat_afek> Anyone else wants to update?
08:38:03 <yujunz> I don't have updates this week, was busy with OPNFV releasing.
08:38:56 <ifat_afek> Was it a final release of the E-release?
08:39:34 <yujunz> First release on Oct 6
08:39:45 <ifat_afek> Thanks
08:39:48 <ifat_afek> #topic Open Discussion
08:39:56 <ifat_afek> Any other issue you would like to discuss?
08:43:03 <usman> Ifat I want to work on Sensu datasource blueprint
08:43:14 <ifat_afek> Sounds great
08:43:30 <usman> In case I require some assistance to whom I need to reach?
08:43:57 <usman> Because I don't have any prior experience of contributing
08:44:19 <ifat_afek> You can send an email to openstack-dev with [vitrage] tag, you can contact us on #openstack-vitrage, or you can email me
08:44:29 <ifat_afek> What ever is more convinient
08:44:36 <ifat_afek> And we will all be happy to help
08:45:02 <usman> okay thanks. I will try to start working on it.
08:45:24 <ifat_afek> Are you using Sensu?
08:45:55 <usman> No. I am not using Sensu but I can test in our testbed
08:46:36 <ifat_afek> Ok. We thought of supporting it a while ago, but didn’t get to it. It will be great if you add this datasource
08:47:13 <usman> Ok I will try to contribute on Sensu Datasource
08:47:19 <ifat_afek> Great
08:47:26 <ifat_afek> Any other issue, anyone?
08:49:06 <eyalb> (ό‿ὸ)ﾉ
08:49:14 <ifat_afek> Nice!!
08:49:25 <ifat_afek> Bye :-)
08:49:59 <ifat_afek> #endmeeting