14:06:05 <mpiwowarczy> #startmeeting trove
14:06:06 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Nov 28 14:06:05 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is mpiwowarczy. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:06:08 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:06:10 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'trove'
14:06:13 <mpiwowarczy> #topic roll call
14:07:17 <mpiwowarczy> lets wait for rest of the team
14:07:17 <pgodek> Hi All
14:07:28 <mpiwowarczy> pgodek: o/
14:08:00 <mpiwowarczy> czukowki: are you there? :)
14:08:13 <cezary_zukowski> mpiwowarczy: yes :)
14:08:30 <mpiwowarczy> dkrol: and you?
14:09:32 <dkrol_> Hello
14:09:47 <mpiwowarczy> dkrol_: o/
14:11:07 <mpiwowarczy> I think we can start
14:11:10 <mpiwowarczy> #topic Python 3 first support
14:11:26 <dkrol_> Great
14:11:48 <dkrol_> Do we have any progress since our last meeting?
14:12:07 <mpiwowarczy> don't think so
14:12:13 <mpiwowarczy> im still waiting for https://review.openstack.org/#/c/604816/
14:12:30 <mpiwowarczy> can anyone review this change?
14:12:54 <dkrol_> Ok, I will check it till the end of this week
14:12:56 <mpiwowarczy> it is last change for trove python3-first goals
14:13:27 <dkrol_> I see
14:13:33 <mpiwowarczy> dkrol: great
14:13:40 <mpiwowarczy> I hold you for a word :)
14:13:56 <dkrol_> No problem :)
14:14:00 <pgodek> @mpiwowarczy - i assumed that it is not ready yet because only you are reviewers
14:15:04 <dkrol_> Let's move forward
14:15:44 <mpiwowarczy> pgodek: we need approve from two core members
14:16:06 <mpiwowarczy> #topic Documentation
14:16:15 <cezary_zukowski> mpiwowarczy: do they need to be from different co?
14:17:01 <mpiwowarczy> cezary_zukowski: it should be :)
14:17:36 <cezary_zukowski> hmm, in terms of documentation, I have made notes (a generic guide) on how to install 1) devstack 2) generate trove image with trovestack 3) use image in trove (simple write/read) tests
14:17:39 <cezary_zukowski> https://docs.google.com/document/d/1eBmIe224yNfq65IoFq_dBRO-vdstInhx9BH2wft5saE/edit?usp=sharing
14:18:01 <mpiwowarczy> IMHO I think we can loosen these rules as your community is a little bit small :)
14:18:03 <cezary_zukowski> this was possible due to @mpiwowarczy help (his Vagrant installation)
14:18:26 <cezary_zukowski> mpiwowarczy: that's better
14:19:16 <dkrol_> Nice work
14:19:23 <mpiwowarczy> cezary_zukowski: let me know if you need any more help :)
14:19:25 <cezary_zukowski> they problem with using trove on laptop is amount of RAM :)
14:19:53 <dkrol_> Did you think about upstream ing vagrantfile?
14:20:05 <cezary_zukowski> dkrol_: thanks, your work with building image in devstack is also great, I have to delve into it
14:20:33 <cezary_zukowski> dkrol_: I may provide a generic quide and mpiwowarczy can submit his Vagrant, I think
14:20:34 <mpiwowarczy> cezary_zukowski: can we move this documentation into etherpad?
14:20:55 <cezary_zukowski> mpiwowarczy: ok, I will try tomorrow, since almost done with trove doctor
14:21:06 <dkrol_> Once I finish working on trovestack we will need to update this guide
14:21:38 <mpiwowarczy> dkrol_: lets talk about trovestack in separate topic :)
14:21:58 <bzurkowski> trovestack is a hot topic today :D
14:22:05 <dkrol_> mpiwowarczy: how about vagrantfile? :)
14:22:07 <bzurkowski> not without reason
14:22:25 <mpiwowarczy> this is why it last one - like topic of the night :D
14:23:42 <dkrol_> Regarding documentation, could you add TOC for it?
14:23:44 <mpiwowarczy> ok, any more things about documentation?
14:24:07 <dkrol_> And some initial description
14:24:35 <dkrol_> To have it more easy to follow
14:24:56 <cezary_zukowski> dkrol_: you mean: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/trove-docs ?
14:25:10 <dkrol_> I think we should push it as fast as possible
14:25:44 <mpiwowarczy> I agree
14:25:46 <dkrol_> Maybe something more :)
14:26:06 <mpiwowarczy> It is very important part of knowagle for newcomers
14:26:18 <dkrol_> Community is waiting for a good start guide for trove
14:26:59 <bzurkowski> some communities use Google Docs for this kind of stuff
14:27:06 <dkrol_> Also we should have add slides from trove onboarding and project update from the recent summit
14:28:00 <bzurkowski> dkrol: I already sent slides to OpenStack Summit operators
14:28:30 <bzurkowski> After they publish them along with other sessions and videos we can add links to our wiki
14:28:41 <dkrol_> I mean we should include them somewhere in the documentation
14:29:08 <bzurkowski> I see
14:29:12 <dkrol_> Sure, I'm just worried we forget
14:29:31 <dkrol_> And potential users are waiting :)
14:30:42 <bzurkowski> By the way
14:30:50 <bzurkowski> We could publish doc prepared by Cezary on our wiki as well
14:31:01 <bzurkowski> And colaborate there, in the public
14:31:06 <dkrol_> Totally agree
14:31:15 <bzurkowski> I observed similar approaches on other wikis
14:31:32 <bzurkowski> No sense to keep it internally until its perfect
14:31:37 <mpiwowarczy> first it need to be moved to rst I guess
14:32:23 <cezary_zukowski> ok, os rst first
14:32:27 <cezary_zukowski> so*
14:32:27 <dkrol_> Let's check how to do it
14:33:11 <mpiwowarczy> #action research how to update trove wiki page
14:33:26 <bzurkowski> Hmm
14:33:50 <dkrol_> Let's move on
14:33:59 <bzurkowski> What I meant was to publish link to GD first, review, collaborate and eventually rewrite to RST at some point
14:35:30 <mpiwowarczy> ok, I hink we can stop here and back to documentation in next week
14:35:38 <bzurkowski> Yes, let's move on
14:35:54 <bzurkowski> Documentation is boring
14:36:01 <mpiwowarczy> #topic Trovestack redesign
14:36:03 <cezary_zukowski> bzurkowski: exactly :)
14:36:26 <mpiwowarczy> dkrol: you probably want to say us something :)
14:36:44 <dkrol_> Did you have time to check it?
14:37:22 <dkrol_> I must say that trovestack tests are not exactly deterministic
14:37:33 <mpiwowarczy> I will try take it to my wall in end of the week
14:37:56 <dkrol_> And I don't understand how gtid in mysql is used
14:37:57 <mpiwowarczy> dkrol_: only Non Voting jobs or all of them?
14:37:59 <cezary_zukowski> dkrol_: because they downloading many things during the tests?
14:38:21 <dkrol_> All of them
14:38:49 <dkrol_> I'm not sure if this related to downloading
14:38:53 <mpiwowarczy> this is something what should be addressed
14:39:08 <mpiwowarczy> some changes need to be rechecked over and over
14:39:36 <dkrol_> Anyway now a mysql is built by default during trove installation in devstack plugin
14:39:39 <cezary_zukowski> dkrol_: when I was testing, network conditions was the case
14:39:40 <bzurkowski> mpiwowarczy: Who will check? Zuul was killed by Zuul hunter :)
14:40:31 <cezary_zukowski> dkrol_: I only have a look, I saw you included cloud.init support, and was wondering why you need to modify "trovestack" script
14:40:33 <dkrol_> So trove functional, mysql sing and mysql multi use this image
14:41:00 <mpiwowarczy> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/606960/
14:41:15 <dkrol_> For some reason there was an issue with checking mysql replication by issue ing ssh command
14:41:38 <dkrol_> I couldn't ssh in tests to vm
14:42:26 <cezary_zukowski> ok, good to know
14:42:55 <mpiwowarczy> most important is, it already works :)
14:43:02 <cezary_zukowski> yeah :D
14:43:45 <cezary_zukowski> grand work :)
14:44:04 <mpiwowarczy> dkrol_: how do you feel? are there any ad hoc or ducktaped pieces?
14:44:31 <dkrol_> Hmm
14:44:55 <dkrol_> Cloudinit was nacessery
14:45:17 <dkrol_> And default values for the image
14:46:04 <mpiwowarczy> I see
14:46:56 <dkrol_> Probably there is some space for improvements :)
14:47:30 <dkrol_> Let's try to merge it as soon as possible
14:47:45 <dkrol_> To have some progress finally
14:47:51 <mpiwowarczy> ok, I will try review this change once I will find more time slots
14:48:18 <mpiwowarczy> ok guys, any out of agenda topics?
14:48:50 <dkrol_> Not from my side
14:49:22 <cezary_zukowski> it's fine
14:49:29 <mpiwowarczy> thanks for participating
14:49:39 <mpiwowarczy> see you next week
14:49:41 <cezary_zukowski> o/
14:49:46 <dkrol_> Thanks and see you next week
14:49:46 <bzurkowski> Thanks, take care
14:49:53 <mpiwowarczy> bye
14:49:57 <mpiwowarczy> #endmeeting