15:00:25 <kumarmn> #startmeeting trove
15:00:25 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Nov  1 15:00:25 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is kumarmn. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:26 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:28 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'trove'
15:01:09 <kumarmn> pinging smatzek lukebrowning johnma slicknick amrith
15:01:57 <kumarmn> pinging lukebrowning_
15:02:40 <kumarmn> #topic announcements
15:03:13 <kumarmn> No meeting next week, as I suspect most key people will be at the summit.
15:05:37 <vserrao> ok
15:06:17 <kumarmn> smatzek informed me that he will miss today's meeting as he has a school event to attend.
15:07:21 <kumarmn> #topic tagging queens releases
15:08:11 <kumarmn> I realized that I was a bit late in tagging queens-1.
15:08:23 <kumarmn> Finally pushed a change yesterday: https://review.openstack.org/516797
15:09:02 <kumarmn> I used smatzek's drop from mid-october for trove, and the latest versions of trove-dashboard and python-troveclient.
15:10:31 <kumarmn> Will try and stay on top of the rest of the milestones.
15:10:34 <kumarmn> https://releases.openstack.org/queens/schedule.html
15:12:30 <kumarmn> #topic gate
15:13:24 <kumarmn> Any issues seen? I have seen a few changes merged. So I suspect it is relatively healthy.
15:13:40 <kumarmn> Better chances of passing on the weekends.
15:14:03 <kumarmn> I know smatzek has ideas on how to improve. We will pick those back up when he is on.
15:14:20 <lukebrowning_> Hi Kumar, I am still working on postgresql restore problem.   Do you know if postgresql is tested in the gate
15:15:11 <kumarmn> non-voting, but yes tested.
15:15:28 <lukebrowning_> The problem that I am looking at is the new instance is started without any backup data.
15:17:02 <kumarmn> perhaps there are no restore tests. Does the postgresql problem exist in master also, or only in stable/pike, stable/ocata?
15:21:30 <kumarmn> #topic technical-debt
15:21:48 <lukebrowning_> I am currently testing it on newton but I don't see any code differences in master that would make it work.  This is a silent error.  The database is started without the backed up databases and users
15:23:22 <kumarmn> Once you resolve it, perhaps we need to add the restore tests to the gate. Especially if they exist for mysql etc.
15:25:05 <kumarmn> I know many of you are tackling defects, Any that you would like to highlight?
15:26:50 <vserrao> i'm currently working on Bug #1718338....however, the scenario is not getting reproduced
15:26:52 <openstack> bug 1718338 in OpenStack DBaaS (Trove) "Trove dashboard does not show 'Quota exceeded' when no quota" [Low,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1718338 - Assigned to Valencia Edna Serrao (vserrao)
15:28:31 <vserrao> i temporarily reduced the RAM and Instance limit to lower values...but still its not reproducible
15:29:42 <vserrao> any hints on reproducing it would be great
15:33:41 <kumarmn> vserrao: You could try python-troveclient (CLI) to create a bunch of trove instances till you hit the instance limit.
15:34:37 <kumarmn> Just put it in a loop until you hit the limit. If you see an error on the CLI, then try the dashboard.
15:35:08 <vserrao> ok...sure...will do that
15:41:06 <kumarmn> #topic blueprints
15:41:37 <kumarmn> Now that fanzhang has joined, would like to have a discussion on the blueprint he has put out: https://blueprints.launchpad.net/trove/+spec/root-enable-in-redis
15:41:55 <fanzhang> hi, i am here.
15:42:34 <kumarmn> Was going to ask the others if they had a chance to review your blueprint. If so to have the discussion here.
15:44:04 <fanzhang> Samuel has reviewed this bp before.
15:44:18 <fanzhang> but just few grammar mistakes I think
15:45:21 <kumarmn> Same comment here. I am fine with cleaning up the grammar/language a bit.
15:46:22 <fanzhang> I have implemented that function based on Newton, I am going to make it done based on Ocata
15:47:17 <kumarmn> I would like to see it pushed to master. smatzek is our stable branch liaison. Not sure that he would pull something like this into stable.
15:47:36 <fanzhang> I think implementing root-enable in redis is useful because just like what we do in mysql
15:47:54 <fanzhang> we can easily enable authentication for redis
15:49:06 <kumarmn_> Not sure what happened there, but I got bumped off temporarily.
15:49:11 <fanzhang> the design has been committed to trove-spec https://review.openstack.org/#/c/514940/ you all can get what I want to implement that bp and how to do that
15:50:17 <kumarmn_> Looks good to me with some language clean-up.
15:50:25 <kumarmn_> Any questions on this lukebrowning_?
15:50:39 <lukebrowning_> I haven
15:50:52 <lukebrowning_> reviewed the design
15:51:11 <lukebrowning_> I will do that today.
15:51:20 <fanzhang> we can discuss about this bp whenever you finish reviewing
15:51:45 <fanzhang> thanks so much
15:51:47 <kumarmn_> ok. I have marked it 'Pending Approval'. Will revisit after lukebrowning_ gets a chance to reiew.
15:51:55 <kumarmn_> review
15:52:35 <fanzhang> ok, that sounds great. and i will continue to transfer my code from Newton to Ocata
15:54:14 <kumarmn_> If it is easier, I would recommend to merge to master first and then cherry-pick to stable/ocata.
15:55:06 <fanzhang> I just tested locally, should I commit some unit tests as well?
15:55:21 <kumarmn_> yes, please.
15:56:29 <kumarmn_> #topic open-floor
15:56:44 <kumarmn_> We are getting to the end of our hour. Any other topics?
15:57:23 <kumarmn_> fanzhang: No meeting next week, summit conflict.
15:57:27 <fanzhang> no.. but thanks again about reviewing this bp
15:57:39 <kumarmn_> Does this time work for the weekly meeting for you fanzhang?
15:58:08 <fanzhang> yes, it's about 00:00 but it's fine
15:59:01 <kumarmn_> wow, appreciate that.
15:59:23 <kumarmn_> #endmeeting
15:59:24 <fanzhang> just finishing bathing.. LOL
15:59:34 <fanzhang> bye kumarmn_
16:00:39 <Sukhdev> Hi ML2 guys -
16:00:52 <rkukura> hi Sukhdev
16:01:18 <Sukhdev> rkukura : I put together a quick agenda - did you see it?
16:01:32 <rkukura> looks good to me
16:03:28 <rkukura> Sukhdev: Assuming we get a few more people, are you able to chair today?
16:03:53 <Sukhdev> I am in the middle of eating breakfast, but, yes I can :-)
16:04:33 <Sukhdev> I have been reading up on the placement API and added a link to the discussion on the agenda -
16:06:51 <Sukhdev> anybody else for ML2 meeting today?
16:06:54 <rkukura> Sukhdev: I have not done my homework, and also didn’t have the links from the non-meeting a couple weeks back
16:07:47 <Sukhdev> rkukura : I did not follow those links either - I have been searching the stuff :-)
16:08:57 <Sukhdev> i think have the links that sadasu shared
16:09:18 <rkukura> Sukhdev: If you get a moment, can you add those to the agenda as well?
16:09:42 <rkukura> looking like another non-meeting today, so maybe change that agenda to after the summit
16:09:55 <Sukhdev> doing it now - give me a few
16:10:15 <rkukura> I expect there will be some discussion on that during the summit
16:10:23 <rkukura> no rush
16:13:24 <Sukhdev> rkukura : done
16:13:50 <rkukura> Sukhdev: Have a great summit!
16:14:09 <Sukhdev> rkukura : Thanks
16:14:35 <Sukhdev> rkukura : looks like no body is here -
16:14:41 <Sukhdev> shall we cancel?
16:15:30 <rkukura> Sukhdev: guess so
16:16:41 <Sukhdev> rkukura  have a good day - will see you in two week here
16:20:01 <rkukura> Sukhdev: thanks - you too
21:46:38 <efried> kumarmn I think you forgot to #endmeeting
15:01:03 <openstack> bswartz: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress.  Use #endmeeting first.
15:01:11 <tbarron> hi
15:01:16 <bswartz> hello all
15:01:20 <ganso> hello
15:01:21 <zhongjun> hi
15:01:54 <bswartz> courtesy ping: cknight vponomaryov markstur gouthamr toabctl xyang
15:02:03 <tbarron> 17:47 yesterday: <efried> kumarmn I think you forgot to #endmeeting
15:02:03 <ganso> someone did not end the previous meeting :\
15:02:04 <markstur> hi
15:02:10 <bswartz> doh
15:02:12 <bswartz> #endmeeting