14:00:23 #startmeeting tripleo 14:00:24 Meeting started Tue May 30 14:00:23 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is EmilienM. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:00:25 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 14:00:27 The meeting name has been set to 'tripleo' 14:00:27 #topic agenda 14:00:33 o/ 14:00:33 * review past action items 14:00:36 * one off agenda items 14:00:38 * bugs 14:00:40 * Projects releases or stable backports 14:00:40 o/ 14:00:41 o/ 14:00:42 * CI 14:00:44 * Specs 14:00:44 o/ 14:00:45 \o 14:00:46 * open discussion 14:00:48 Anyone can use the #link, #action and #info commands, not just the moderatorǃ 14:00:50 Hi everyone! who is around today? 14:00:52 o/ 14:00:54 o/ 14:00:55 o/ 14:01:04 0/ 14:01:05 o/ 14:01:08 o/ 14:01:11 o/ 14:01:27 what a nice crowd 14:01:31 let's start 14:01:33 #topic review past action items 14:01:39 ccamacho to propose undercloud backup/restore blueprint on ML: done 14:01:43 panda to remind oooq featureset policy / etherpad on ML: done 14:01:56 rasca follow up tripleo-quickstart-utils discussion on ML 14:02:05 rasca: I'm not sure you've followed-up, or I missed it 14:02:26 EmilienM, not yet, no 14:02:37 #action (postponed) rasca follow up tripleo-quickstart-utils discussion on ML 14:02:43 rasca: I won't forget you :-P 14:02:45 matbu + marios to share all upgrade-related blueprints on the ML thread 14:02:53 matbu, marios ^ same thing here I think 14:03:09 EmilienM, I count on that 14:03:34 I'll followup with marios & matbu 14:03:42 sshnaidm to ask bandini and his team to look at pingtest HA failures: https://bugs.launchpad.net/tripleo/+bug/1680195 14:03:44 Launchpad bug 1680195 in tripleo "Random ovb-ha ping test failures" [Critical,In progress] - Assigned to John Trowbridge (trown) 14:03:46 I think we have made progress 14:04:06 I still see some HA failures but not sure they are related to the same problems from last week. We have been hitting a bunch of problems lately 14:04:17 i'll also follow up with this topic this week and make sure we're good on HA 14:04:25 anything before we move on? 14:04:37 ya recent ha failures seem to be more related to libguestfs but we can talk about it in CI section 14:04:45 trown: sounds like a plan 14:04:48 let's move on then 14:04:50 #topic one off agenda items 14:04:55 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tripleo-meeting-items 14:05:00 ccamacho: floor is yours 14:05:06 EmilienM thanks 14:05:11 just FYI I got progress here https://review.openstack.org/#/c/466213/ it works for me locally but ill to ask based on bnemec feedback if this is the correct place for this code. Also in my tests im mocking some calls with sudo aaand they are breaking with http://logs.openstack.org/13/466213/18/check/gate-python-tripleoclient-python35/259e2c0/console.html#_2017-05-29_16_30_43_156203 any idea about it? 14:05:52 for the tests, we can discuss it in Gerrit. For the code itself, I've looked at it and I was looking at MySQL-python library and it doesn't seem to fit with our use case 14:06:17 ccamacho: I would check with bnemec (not present here) which library we could use. Also which repo we could put this code 14:06:27 oki thanks! 14:06:45 I was also curious to investigate Mistral Workflows maybe 14:06:57 driven by tripleoclient 14:07:01 but it's maybe overkill 14:07:27 actually, it depends on what we want to backup. If it requires some API calls, Mistral could be useful maybe. 14:08:02 EmilienM I was thinking about improving it with a Mistral workflow, but its a filesystem backup.. So.. Maybe in a second iteration we can extend it 14:08:16 I agree with that aproach 14:08:39 ccamacho: please keep discussion going on Gerrit, and maybe involve Mistral folks and also Ben about the code itself 14:08:51 EmilienM sure thing, thanks! 14:08:54 cool 14:09:04 do we have any off-item this week? 14:09:29 #topic bugs 14:09:33 #link https://launchpad.net/tripleo/+milestone/pike-2 14:09:45 quick info, pike-2 is next week 14:09:55 please start targetting new bugs to pike-3 from now, unless they are mega super very critical 14:10:09 o/ 14:10:22 I'll run the script that moves pike-2 bugs to pike-3 next week 14:10:29 do we have any outstanding tripleo bug to discuss this week? 14:11:01 sounds like we can move on 14:11:04 #topic projects releases or stable backports 14:11:10 #link https://releases.openstack.org/pike/schedule.html 14:11:39 so like I said, we have pike-2 next week, I'll take care of the release. 14:11:49 we also documented the process here: http://tripleo.org/developer/release.html 14:12:00 yeah was just going to say, would be good to have observers? 14:12:02 if there is anyone willing to learn how it works, and help, please let me know I'll coordinate the work 14:12:21 the whole process should not take more than 2 hours 14:12:27 Are we aiming for Thursday? 14:12:27 I can even record my terminal or something 14:12:32 jpich: good question 14:13:05 jpich: if CI is green, and we don't have critical bugs blocking something we might do it earlier 14:13:10 but again, any feedback is welcome 14:13:16 we can postpone it if needed, just let us know 14:13:40 jpich: i'll announce it 24h before on ML 14:13:44 Ok, thank you! 14:13:46 to give a chance to disagree 14:13:49 cool 14:13:56 jrist: can I count on you then? 14:14:16 to observe? :) 14:14:21 probably. depends on the day. 14:14:21 jrist: hopefully we can improve the doc 14:14:23 yeah 14:14:29 jrist: let's sync later on the day and such 14:14:34 aye 14:14:36 jrist: observe with actions :P 14:14:51 any question about release management and backports? 14:15:09 moving on 14:15:11 #topic CI 14:15:25 we don't need to say the last weeks were terrible in our CI :-) 14:15:32 but things are making progress 14:15:39 AFIK the last 2 big things are : 14:15:48 https://bugs.launchpad.net/tripleo/+bug/1694431 14:15:49 Launchpad bug 1694431 in tripleo "python2-ryu-4.13-1breaks ovb-ha-oooq on master" [Critical,In progress] - Assigned to Alfredo Moralejo (amoralej) 14:15:56 and https://bugs.launchpad.net/tripleo/+bug/1694280 14:15:57 Launchpad bug 1694280 in tripleo "Repositories setup inside the image in TripleO CI by quickstart may take 50 min" [Critical,Triaged] - Assigned to John Trowbridge (trown) 14:16:14 once both are resolved, we should have some idea if pingtest works fine in HA 14:16:45 please do not recheck patches until 1694431 is closed 14:16:51 it makes all ovb-ha jobs failing 14:16:53 ya I am a bit skeptical about the second one, because we libguestfs is used also in multinode patches 14:17:19 but cant really gather much data until 1694431 is resolved 14:17:54 AFIK Alfredo is working hard on it right now 14:18:18 is there anything CI related to discuss? 14:18:34 sshnaidm has a patch to allow doing image modification in the old way (convert to raw and mount), and if that helps we can merge it... however that is pretty gross and libguesfts should be preferable if we dont need to do the conversion shenanigans 14:19:19 why do we need to use libguestfs in multinode jobs? 14:19:41 anywhere we modify images we use it 14:19:58 I guess we dont use it in multinode actually 14:20:01 we don't use images in multinode 14:20:13 why do we modify images in multinode jobs? :) 14:20:29 right... saying that made me realize we dont :P 14:20:54 one part of the mystery solved then 14:20:57 :) 14:21:46 sounds like we can have the discussion on libguestfs vs ... in Gerrit or later in the ML 14:22:22 yep 14:22:34 anything else about CI before we move on? 14:22:59 #topic specs 14:23:03 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/tripleo-specs+status:open 14:23:26 do we have specs that we want to discuss now? 14:23:59 moving on 14:24:00 #topic open discussion 14:24:11 so there is a thread on openstack-dev about dib security bug 14:24:21 and one of the outputs was about creating a security group in launchpad for tripleo 14:24:27 I went ahead and created https://launchpad.net/~tripleo-coresec 14:24:52 with 3 tripleo folks (one on major timezones) and one from VMT (fungi) 14:25:03 I haven't figured yet how we can use this group, tbh 14:25:13 if anyone is familiar with Launchpad groups, please ping me 14:25:18 otherwise I'll find out 14:25:54 any thoughts? or questions / feedback to give? 14:26:23 sounds good to have a limited, specialised coresec group 14:26:27 * beagles nods 14:26:56 cool 14:27:23 sounds like it's over, thanks everyone for your time && have fun 14:27:35 #endmeeting