15:00:18 <anteaya> #startmeeting third-party
15:00:18 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Aug 29 15:00:18 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is anteaya. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:19 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:21 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'third_party'
15:00:31 <lennyb> hi
15:00:34 <wznoinsk> hi
15:00:49 <anteaya> hello
15:01:00 <anteaya> lennyb, wznoinsk how are you today?
15:01:22 <mmedvede> o/
15:01:27 <anteaya> hello mmedvede
15:01:28 <eantyshev> o/
15:01:32 <anteaya> and eantyshev
15:01:33 <lennyb> back from vacation ( pool, beer and kids :) )
15:01:41 <anteaya> lennyb: congratulations
15:01:44 <anteaya> and welcome back
15:01:51 <anteaya> hope you had a nice vacation :)
15:02:09 <lennyb> thanks. it's a definitely less noisy here :)
15:02:14 <anteaya> ha ha ha
15:02:17 <wznoinsk> busy here, getting ready to create an ironic-based CI for SRIOV and PCI passthru
15:02:24 <anteaya> wznoinsk: nice
15:02:32 <lennyb> wznoinsk, great
15:02:36 <anteaya> wznoinsk: did you want to talk about that a little bit?
15:02:55 <wznoinsk> I figure out things as I go along, no questions atm
15:03:01 <anteaya> and do others have topics they want to discuss today after wznoinsk talks about the ironic ci?
15:03:24 <wznoinsk> would infra look at baremetal based CI/container maybe?
15:03:26 <anteaya> wznoinsk: okay great, do you feel comfortable if we tell other ironic ci operators to ping you?
15:03:26 <eantyshev> I have one question on Gearman plugin for Jenkins
15:03:38 <anteaya> wznoinsk: infra will look at anything
15:03:47 <eantyshev> it doesn't register jobs for new slaves
15:03:55 <anteaya> the issue with baremetal is that infra has no access to the machines
15:04:21 <anteaya> wznoinsk: but if you want to raise a discussion the best is to include a topic on the infra meeting agenda
15:04:38 <anteaya> eantyshev: great thank you, you can be up next
15:05:10 <wznoinsk> anteaya: ok, would containers from cloud providers be any option do you think? I guess these containers will be still inside more beefy VMs so may not be a good choice
15:05:10 <anteaya> wznoinsk: if you do so tomorrow you can evaluate if there is enough interest to have a discussion at the summit about it
15:05:24 <anteaya> wznoinsk: it depends on the implimentation
15:05:49 <anteaya> so once we get past the fanfare of containers we have to look at access and build requirements and so on
15:06:33 <wznoinsk> anteaya: sure, would OSIC be any better in access to baremetal than other lcoud providers?
15:06:48 <anteaya> I have no idea
15:07:15 <wznoinsk> I'll talk to infra guys on meeting then
15:07:16 <wznoinsk> thanks
15:07:17 <anteaya> I would suggest adding an item to tomorrow's infra meeting
15:07:26 <anteaya> well people
15:07:56 <anteaya> as I consider myself part of the infra team as well
15:07:58 <asselin_> o/
15:08:06 <anteaya> hello asselin_
15:08:29 <anteaya> so anymore on wznoinsk's topics, ironic ci and baremetal/containers in infra?
15:09:00 <anteaya> or shall we move on to eantyshev's topic, gearman plugin failing to register jobs
15:09:06 <anteaya> eantyshev: looks like you are up
15:09:09 <eantyshev> my first guess is that gearman plugin version, zuul and nodepool and jjb versions (gearman 0.1.1, nodepool 0.3.0, zuul 2.5.1, jjb 1.6.1)
15:09:36 <eantyshev> is anything wrong with them?
15:09:59 <asselin_> which version of jenkins?
15:10:19 <eantyshev> asselin_: 2.7.2
15:11:24 <asselin_> that's probably the problem... 1.651.1
15:11:25 <asselin_> is the last one known to work.
15:11:57 <eantyshev> asselin_: I wonder how I got 2.7.2 while using puppets
15:12:11 <anteaya> well infra isn't using jenkins anymore
15:12:19 <anteaya> and the puppets probably pull in latest
15:12:25 <anteaya> unless told not to
15:12:30 <asselin_> eantyshev, puppet installs the latest....
15:12:44 <anteaya> so infra wouldn't have caught this issue
15:13:22 <asselin_> eantyshev, there's a need to update openstack-infra/puppet-jenkins to allow pinning to a version. I don't think there's a patch proposed to do that.
15:13:47 <anteaya> I think a patch would be welcome
15:13:55 <eantyshev> asselin_: afraid so, I'll dig into this
15:14:09 <anteaya> also if you want to post to the infra mailing list about it, so other folks using jenkins can be aware
15:14:20 <anteaya> and reminded that infra isn't using jenkins anymore
15:14:30 <anteaya> we want folks to be able to use the puppet module
15:14:37 <anteaya> we just aren't anymore
15:15:10 <anteaya> any more discussion on this topic?
15:15:23 <eantyshev> anteaya: but 3rd party CIs have no other options?
15:15:42 <anteaya> eantyshev: well they have other options, but many will still be using jenkins
15:15:54 <asselin_> actually, looks like something merged: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/354086/
15:16:00 <anteaya> so having a puppet module third party cis can use is of interest to infra, yes
15:16:06 <anteaya> oh thank you asselin_
15:16:35 <eantyshev> asselin_: thanks a lot!
15:16:41 <anteaya> wonderful
15:16:50 <asselin_> with that we can update puppet-openstackci to pin it. eantyshev want to propose that?
15:17:05 <eantyshev> asselin_: I'll do
15:17:25 <anteaya> thank you
15:17:35 <eantyshev> just check in my environment how this works
15:18:35 <anteaya> any more here?
15:18:42 <eantyshev> nope
15:18:54 <anteaya> thank you for bringing up the topic, eantyshev
15:19:25 <anteaya> does anyone have any other topic they wish to discuss?
15:20:18 <anteaya> does anyone have any objection to me closing the meeting?
15:20:52 <anteaya> thank you all for your kind attendance and participation
15:20:55 <asselin_> no objectins
15:21:00 <anteaya> enjoy the rest of your day/evening
15:21:03 <anteaya> thanks asselin_
15:21:09 <anteaya> see you all next week
15:21:13 <anteaya> #endmeeting