17:03:43 <asselin> #startmeeting third-party
17:03:44 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Jan 26 17:03:43 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is asselin. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:03:45 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:03:48 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'third_party'
17:04:12 <mmedvede> o/
17:04:15 <apoorvad> o/
17:04:19 <ja3> o/
17:04:20 <asselin> hey
17:04:28 <asselin> sorry I'm late
17:04:42 <mmedvede> inexcusable
17:04:46 <mmedvede> :)
17:04:55 <asselin> #topic announcements
17:05:04 <asselin> anyone have anything to announce?
17:05:44 <asselin> me neither.
17:05:51 <asselin> #topic CI Watch
17:06:14 <mmedvede> #link open reviews https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:+ci-dashboard+status:open
17:06:48 <mmedvede> need to ask for https://review.openstack.org/#/c/238606/ to be approved
17:07:31 <mmedvede> last week I did start on implementing a few unit tests
17:07:43 <asselin> yeah, apoorvad are you using that now? or still manual deploy?
17:08:00 <asselin> mmedvede, saw that. very nice. still need to review
17:08:46 <mmedvede> asselin: the patch series is incomplete - I would appreciate just a general review on direction. Maybe I am moving too many things around
17:08:52 <apoorvad> I am using mmedvede script to deploy stuff
17:09:12 <asselin> mmedvede, ok will do that
17:09:22 <asselin> apoorvad, cool!
17:09:28 <mmedvede> asselin: and the script uses the puppet module. So it is tested
17:10:19 <mmedvede> apoorvad: I also noticed you deployed the latest regression fix, thank you
17:11:28 <apoorvad> Apparently I forgot to push the regex fix as a part of the latest patch and it got merged without the correct diff
17:11:55 <asselin> apoorvad, ??
17:12:34 <apoorvad> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/270688/ fixed it
17:13:36 <asselin> sorry I didn't understand this: "Apparently I forgot to push the regex fix as a part of the latest patch and it got merged without the correct diff"
17:14:22 <apoorvad> asselin: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/270688/ fixed things missed in my last patch
17:15:01 <asselin> apoorvad, ok....so we're all good now? deployed version = master?
17:15:31 <apoorvad> asselin : thats correct
17:15:42 <asselin> ok, good :)
17:16:26 <asselin> anything else?
17:16:30 <apoorvad> asselin : Can you approve this? https://review.openstack.org/#/c/238606/
17:16:48 <asselin> no I don't have +2
17:16:57 <mmedvede> need to ask on of puppet cores
17:17:09 <asselin> but I can ping some people after the meeting
17:17:19 <apoorvad> alright!
17:18:43 <asselin> #topic Common-CI Solution
17:19:22 <asselin> quite a few third-party vernders are working on setting up common-ci
17:19:46 <asselin> #link Notes for users who have set it up. These should be added back into the documentation and/or bug fixes: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/thirdpartyci
17:20:12 <asselin> seems to be quite a few issues still that can be addressed ^^
17:20:40 <asselin> that's an etherpad to help track people notes so we can address them more informally than bugs/launchpad.
17:21:05 <asselin> that link is also under "Reference links" in this meeting's wiki page: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/ThirdParty#Agenda_for_next_Working_Group_meeting
17:21:27 <asselin> infra has merged quite a few nodepool changes which is impacting documentation
17:21:46 <asselin> in particular, you can't build an image without nodepool running.
17:21:57 <mmedvede> ouch
17:22:24 <asselin> there's a few more issues IMO, but I think they're still ironing those out.
17:22:55 <asselin> unfortunately I haven't had much time to look into it and debug these.
17:23:30 <Swanson> hello
17:23:40 <asselin> I've been suggesting folks to pin nodepool to the last tag 0.2.0
17:23:49 <asselin> #common ci pin nodepool to 0.2.0 https://git.openstack.org/cgit/openstack-infra/puppet-openstackci/tree/contrib/single_node_ci_data.yaml#n38
17:23:58 <asselin> #link common ci pin nodepool to 0.2.0 https://git.openstack.org/cgit/openstack-infra/puppet-openstackci/tree/contrib/single_node_ci_data.yaml#n38
17:24:02 <asselin> Swanson, HI!
17:24:47 <asselin> #link Nodepool Release prior to image builders merging.  https://git.openstack.org/cgit/openstack-infra/nodepool/tag/?h=0.2.0
17:25:06 <mmedvede> asselin: I am pinning nodepool and zuul myself
17:25:40 <mmedvede> but it was suggested to me before that it basically reduces participation in community, because less people would see problems and fix them
17:26:10 <asselin> yeah, I think this is one of the big issues right now wtih common-ci is that it's all based on 'master' and 'latest' and we don't have regerssion testing
17:27:27 <asselin> so I'm thinking of suggesting pins on the latest known working of nodepool, zuul, and jenkins to start with
17:27:44 <mmedvede> I would vote yes on this
17:28:28 <mmedvede> especially for new CIs, it might be hard to figure out why things suddenly break when something bad got deployed from master
17:29:03 <Swanson> I'm having enough issues getting the environment setup to run against my HW/SW without worrying about the infra tools.
17:29:03 <asselin> right..that's the challenge when debugging....is it a regression or a conf issue
17:31:06 <asselin> Swanson, I think I was you're using that etherpad right?
17:31:18 <asselin> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/thirdpartyci
17:31:47 <Swanson> I was using it in addition to the documentation.  Not everything on it applies anymore.
17:33:00 <asselin> sorry...something has come up and I need to go....
17:33:10 <asselin> anything else to discuss?
17:33:35 <Swanson> Not at the moment
17:33:55 <mmedvede> asselin: I would ask in infra channel for the puppet-ciwatch review
17:33:56 <asselin> Swanson, docs should be accurate with nodepol 0.2.0. pin
17:35:07 <Swanson> asselin, I'm currently trying to work out a localrc/local.conf setup that actually lets me test my hardware.  Will revist credential issues after that.
17:35:40 <asselin> #endmeeting