04:00:25 <krtaylor> #startmeeting third-party 04:00:26 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Feb 25 04:00:25 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is krtaylor. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 04:00:27 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 04:00:29 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'third_party' 04:00:51 <krtaylor> anyone here for third party working group meeting? 04:00:56 <patrickeast> o/ 04:01:04 <krtaylor> hi patrickeast 04:01:12 <patrickeast> hey 04:01:15 <mmedvede> o/ 04:01:26 <krtaylor> hey mmedvede 04:01:32 <mmedvede> hi 04:01:36 <krtaylor> looks like you made it afterall :) 04:01:45 <mmedvede> barely :) 04:02:28 <krtaylor> ok, well fairly light agenda for today's meeting 04:02:39 <krtaylor> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/ThirdParty#2.2F25.2F15_0400_UTC 04:02:50 <asselin_> hi 04:03:05 <krtaylor> hi asselin_ 04:03:14 <krtaylor> we just started 04:04:16 <krtaylor> I was just going to remind everyone, and anyone that might read the log later, of the plans to have gerrit upgraded March 21st 04:04:31 <asselin> I think the date got pushed out 04:04:38 <krtaylor> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2015-February/056508.html 04:04:41 <asselin> to april 11 or may 9 in today's infra meeting 04:04:58 <krtaylor> asselin, oh, I missed that, and I was there :) 04:05:09 * krtaylor admits to doing other things during 04:05:44 <asselin> and pleia2 will setup a hello world service on the gerrit port for firewall testing 04:06:11 <krtaylor> ah, ok, oh I do remember that part 04:06:22 <krtaylor> I guess I missed the date 04:07:47 <krtaylor> I jut checked for a new announcement for it, I guess that is coming 04:08:17 <krtaylor> anyone have any other announcements before we move on? 04:08:40 <krtaylor> on it is then 04:08:55 <krtaylor> #topic Third-party CI documentation 04:09:15 <krtaylor> the documentation is still moving forward, at a slow pace 04:09:41 <krtaylor> there are some good reviews and it looks like some are ready 04:09:55 <krtaylor> just need some +2 to push them through 04:10:00 * asselin needs to look again 04:10:47 <krtaylor> I am thinking that the running-your-own doc is in danger of not getting where we need it to be 04:11:05 <krtaylor> but maybe that will be ok, with in-tree coming 04:11:39 <krtaylor> there have been a few changes, rfolco namely, and I know he has some more changes in mind 04:11:43 <asselin> I never tried the running-you-own. I would like to eventually. 04:12:24 <krtaylor> yeah, its one of those things that it is hard to critique unless you are doing it 04:13:53 <krtaylor> any thing else for documentation? 04:14:30 <krtaylor> next then 04:14:44 <krtaylor> #topic in-tree 3rd party ci solution 04:15:03 <asselin> I pushed up a big update today 04:15:04 <krtaylor> asselin, I did see that you had a new version 04:15:13 <krtaylor> yep! 04:15:22 <krtaylor> I need to go review that one again 04:15:37 <asselin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/139745/ 04:15:46 <krtaylor> thanks 04:16:08 <krtaylor> it is good to see all the comments, it is shaping up really nicely 04:16:26 <asselin> jeblair had a good suggestion: make -infra use it too. that simplifies a lot 04:16:55 <asselin> so it's being renamed openstack-ci instead of 3rd party ci 04:17:14 <krtaylor> yes 04:18:23 <krtaylor> infra might find some of the tools we'll pull together useful too, but more on that later 04:18:47 <krtaylor> also I saw that the refactor patch got a new version 04:18:48 <asselin> it will make running your own much simpler too (I think) 04:19:00 <krtaylor> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/137471/ 04:19:26 <krtaylor> asselin, yes! 04:19:51 <krtaylor> so reviews on these everyone! 04:19:57 <asselin> yes, need to review that again. It's a very important change and the 'openstack ci' change will greatly need it. 04:20:45 <krtaylor> asselin, anything else on this? 04:20:52 <mmedvede> asselin: the 139745 has the story link wrong :) 04:21:03 <mmedvede> not wrong, just missing space 04:21:11 <asselin> really? oh ok 04:21:17 <asselin> will fix it then 04:21:25 <krtaylor> mmedvede, you can get a review out of it :) 04:21:37 <krtaylor> good catch! 04:21:46 <mmedvede> hehe, I need -1's 04:21:54 <asselin> yes, thanks! :) 04:22:53 <asselin> ok,nothing more from me 04:23:22 <krtaylor> onward then 04:23:27 <krtaylor> #topic Repo for third party tools 04:23:35 <krtaylor> so, we brought this up last meeting 04:23:42 <krtaylor> and had a really good discussion 04:23:56 <krtaylor> fueled by tools that were shared by patrickeast 04:24:09 <krtaylor> and we have a few that would be useful 04:24:40 <krtaylor> give ci operators options for functionality and a place to look for ideas 04:24:48 <krtaylor> for how they can automate 04:24:52 <krtaylor> and monitor, etc 04:25:05 <krtaylor> I created an etherpad 04:25:13 <krtaylor> (just minutes ago) 04:25:36 <krtaylor> if I can get more free time in the next few days, I'll pull that together 04:25:46 <krtaylor> #link 04:25:50 <krtaylor> oops 04:25:54 <krtaylor> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/third-party-ci-wg-repo 04:26:29 <krtaylor> that is just the beginnings, ideas and comments appreciated 04:27:28 <krtaylor> I am leaning toward one repo, with functional directories for tools, maybe in sub directories 04:27:45 <krtaylor> we want to bundle tools, readmes etc together 04:28:06 <krtaylor> but organize them by, well, in some way 04:29:13 <asselin> krtaylor, +1 for organized directories 04:29:20 <krtaylor> right, the comments there also reflect what I was thinking, treat this as a kind of incubator 04:29:41 <krtaylor> if a tool grows to the point where it needs to be split out, it can 04:29:55 <asselin> agreed 04:30:14 <patrickeast> sounds like a good plan to me 04:30:19 <mmedvede> +1 04:30:39 <krtaylor> it will be really interesting to see how many tools we can gather up 04:31:19 <krtaylor> the concept of having a huge toolchest full of idea for fixing problems in ci systems is pretty darn cool 04:32:01 <krtaylor> everyone was enthused in Paris about it anyway :) 04:32:04 <asselin> +1 04:32:12 <krtaylor> maybe that was the wine :) 04:32:34 <asselin> that's the nice part of this new meeting time 04:32:40 * asselin having some wine 04:32:42 <krtaylor> hehheh 04:33:03 * krtaylor trying to stay focused after a long day 04:33:35 <krtaylor> so, any comments, suggestions, ideas, put them in the etherpad 04:34:18 <krtaylor> I'll get that going this week 04:34:39 <krtaylor> that's all I had, any questions? 04:35:22 <krtaylor> #topic Open Discussion 04:35:31 <krtaylor> open floor 04:37:18 <krtaylor> this might be a quick meeting then 04:37:48 <krtaylor> I'll hang around for a few minutes, in case someone jumps in with a question 04:42:12 <asselin> ok goodnight 04:42:34 <mmedvede> night 04:43:08 <krtaylor> yeah, that's a wrap 04:43:12 <krtaylor> thanks everyone! 04:43:29 <krtaylor> #endmeeting