19:00:35 <sgordon> #startmeeting telcowg
19:00:36 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Sep  2 19:00:35 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is sgordon. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
19:00:37 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
19:00:38 <sgordon> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/nfv-meeting-agenda
19:00:40 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'telcowg'
19:00:42 <sgordon> #topic roll call
19:00:50 <sgordon> howdy folks, anyone around for telco wg meeting?
19:01:19 <cloudon> hi
19:02:59 <sgordon> #topic Product WG updates
19:03:27 <sgordon> ok so i delivered an update on some product wg stuff last week but some more things that may be relevant to this group
19:03:36 <sgordon> #info product wg - Specs Page and Cross Project Meeting Info
19:03:40 <sgordon> #link
19:03:45 <sgordon> #undo
19:03:46 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Link object at 0xa7a2410>
19:03:50 <sgordon> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/product-wg/2015-September/000694.html
19:03:56 <sgordon> #info Cross project relations
19:04:02 <sgordon> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/CrossProjectLiaisons#Product_Working_Group
19:04:06 <sgordon> and most importantly...
19:04:12 <sgordon> #info User stories
19:04:15 <sgordon> #link http://git.openstack.org/cgit/openstack/openstack-user-stories/tree/user-stories
19:04:50 <sgordon> there are small groups forming around those initial user stories
19:05:08 <sgordon> the capacity management one includes some scope coverage of a reservation handling
19:05:18 <sgordon> which is a gap i know has been articulated in ETSI NFV
19:05:23 <sgordon> mainly raised as an FYI for now
19:05:38 <sgordon> #topic reviews
19:05:43 <sgordon> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:stackforge/telcowg-usecases,n,z
19:05:56 <sgordon> cloudon, i suspect it may be just you and me today because of the latter timeslot
19:06:14 <sgordon> any issues on the SBC side?
19:06:24 <cloudon> need a couple of bits of help...
19:06:28 <sgordon> looks like it might have hit a minor syntax error
19:06:32 <sgordon> sure, what's the issue :)
19:06:56 <cloudon> Yuri suggested adding ASCII art, which I tried but think have exceeded my RST knowledge...
19:07:07 <cloudon> any expertise?
19:07:48 <cloudon> on the IMS one it's a case of the magic git incantantions not working
19:08:13 <sgordon> i think on the ascii art you may need another newline and/or indentation after ::
19:09:00 <cloudon> ah, OK, will give that a try
19:09:02 <sgordon> http://docutils.sourceforge.net/docs/ref/rst/restructuredtext.html#literal-blocks
19:09:24 <sgordon> on the IMS one looks like it got collapsed into the SBC submission
19:09:27 <sgordon> was that intentional?
19:09:41 <cloudon> God, no
19:09:46 <Rockyg> question:  are you guys following the possible resurrection of Blazar for reservations and is it applicable?
19:10:22 <sgordon> Rockyg, that is part of what i refer to talking about reservations
19:10:38 <sgordon> Rockyg, but the actual resurrection or not of Blazar is not actually immediately relevant
19:10:56 <sgordon> Rockyg, other than to know hey there are people are looking at this again so we can dust off our thoughts around that
19:11:23 <Rockyg> gotcha.  Thanks!
19:11:39 <sgordon> whether reservations are built into the projects and/or handled by blazaar as an API is more of an implementation detail we would leave up to the project teams
19:11:46 <sgordon> (incl. the Blazar one)
19:12:09 <sgordon> cloudon, hmmm
19:12:11 <sgordon> well then
19:12:23 <sgordon> let me check that submission out and see what the git log looks like
19:12:41 <sgordon> but my guess is you accidentally git added both in the same git commit --amend
19:12:49 <cloudon> Ah, that may be an issue with my local repository & and over-zealous copy
19:12:57 <sgordon> you shouuulld be able to remove it again doing the reverse
19:13:50 <cloudon> Problem with the IMS one was a failed cherry pick trying to follow mkoderer's instructions
19:14:04 <sgordon> ah
19:14:16 <cloudon> May be quickest  to abandon and do a brand new submission - would that cause any problems?
19:14:33 <sgordon> let me have a quick crack
19:14:44 <sgordon> and see if i can sort it out in git/gerrit on my side
19:14:48 <sgordon> and then you can fetch it again
19:21:21 <sgordon> cloudon, im going to #endmeeting
19:21:24 <sgordon> but am working on it
19:21:28 <sgordon> k?
19:21:34 <cloudon> ok, no problem
19:21:52 <cloudon> let me know if easier to just abandon/resubmit
19:22:08 <sgordon> #endmeeting