08:19:49 <gongysh> #startmeeting tacker
08:19:49 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Apr 24 08:19:49 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gongysh. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:19:50 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
08:19:53 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'tacker'
08:20:32 <phuoc_> hi
08:20:40 <YanXing_an> hi
08:20:58 <joxyuki> hi
08:21:32 <mardim> hello
08:22:25 <gongysh> #topic annoucement
08:22:37 <gongysh> TC election
08:22:58 <dangtrinhnt> hi
08:23:17 <gongysh> please take part in the TC election poll.
08:23:30 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh. I already done the TC election.
08:23:41 <gongysh> if you got the poll invitation email.
08:23:55 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, great.
08:24:32 <gongysh> #topic summit topic status
08:24:37 <gongysh> mardim, hi
08:24:51 <mardim> hello
08:25:02 <mardim> The demo is pretty much ready
08:25:12 <mardim> I created to demos actually so we can have a backup
08:25:34 <mardim> two(
08:25:37 <mardim> two*
08:25:50 <mardim> the demo architecture is like dynamic sfc through zabbix
08:25:58 <phuoc_> mardim, that's great
08:26:01 <mardim> so when an event occurs in zabbix
08:26:20 <gongysh> mardim, do you have a video for it?
08:26:41 <mardim> triggers automatically an action and update the classifier to steer the traffic through the chain
08:26:56 <mardim> gongysh, Not yet I will I think till next week
08:27:06 <mardim> when I make one I will send it to you
08:27:16 <mardim> do you need the video now ?
08:27:26 <mardim> or like a backup for the summit ?
08:27:27 <gongysh> do you have?
08:27:31 <mardim> not yet
08:28:01 <gongysh> mardim, we will have a video for backup, but we'd better to do live demo.
08:28:18 <mardim> yes I agree I think I will have the video until next week
08:28:38 <mardim> the only think is that I would like to add your public keys guys to the demo server
08:28:41 <gongysh> you can update the slide to show us your idea of the demo.
08:28:53 <mardim> so you can have accesses from your PCs
08:29:05 <phuoc_> mardim, what is your constraints of the trigger?
08:29:08 <mardim> because maybe my PC will have problems with HDMI
08:29:14 <gongysh> mardim, I will send you my public key.
08:29:18 <mardim> Avg Bps
08:29:25 <mardim> gongysh, Great
08:30:00 <mardim> phuoc_, if the Average BPs in the eth0 is higher than 3500 Bps
08:30:05 <mardim> then do the action
08:30:25 <gongysh> mardim, what are your two vnfs?
08:30:32 <phuoc_> I will note your scenario
08:30:50 <mardim> gongysh, you mean the SFs in the chain  right ?
08:30:58 <gongysh> yes
08:31:03 <mardim> IDS and FW
08:31:41 <gongysh> what open software is for IDS?
08:31:47 <mardim> suricata
08:31:58 <gongysh> and FW?
08:32:08 <mardim> the simple firewall that ubuntu has
08:32:14 <mardim> UFW I think is the name
08:32:40 <phuoc_> maybe that is similar to iptables xD
08:32:52 <mardim> yes it is but is running as a service
08:33:01 <mardim> you can enable it and disable it
08:33:25 <mardim> But for demo purposes is working llike a charm
08:33:26 <mardim> :)
08:33:30 <gongysh> mardim, why not using openwrt?
08:33:37 <mardim> no reason
08:33:48 <mardim> I just choose the simple solution
08:33:53 <mardim> is that a problem ?
08:34:04 <gongysh> we can config the openwrt through tacker.
08:34:35 <mardim> hmmm didn't know that
08:34:41 <gongysh> openwrt is our only vnf we are supporting now. if we don't use it,  no one will use it.
08:34:52 <gongysh> let's use openwrt for fw.
08:35:18 <mardim> ok I will try to use it but I cannot promise because I am pretty overloaded right now
08:35:26 <mardim> I will try to find some spare time
08:35:52 <gongysh> mardim, share the work, we can do it together.
08:35:54 <mardim> gongysh, can you please send me some links regarding openwrt and tacker
08:36:20 <mardim> gongysh, yes ok I will put your public key to the demo server so you can have access
08:36:30 <dangtrinhnt> mardim, I can help with openwrt driver. I've worked with it for a while.
08:36:46 <mardim> dangtrinhnt, nice of you :)
08:36:57 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, you are so kind.
08:36:58 <gongysh> https://docs.openstack.org/tacker/latest/install/deploy_openwrt.html
08:37:53 <dangtrinhnt> no prob. Just tell me what you need.
08:38:00 <gongysh> mardim, send out the google doc link again
08:38:23 <mardim> gongysh, sure
08:39:15 <mardim> done
08:39:17 <gongysh> phuoc_, I think you have one more lighting talk, is that done?
08:40:36 <phuoc_> I, trinh and dkuhswaha have a lighting talk
08:40:57 <gongysh> phuoc_, the slide is finished?
08:41:12 <phuoc_> the slide is not finished yet
08:41:23 <gongysh> ok.
08:41:27 <phuoc_> we will try to finish in one or two weeks later
08:42:29 <gongysh> after we have done the demo, we can add suricata and openwrt into our vnf market.
08:43:05 <gongysh> #topic bp
08:43:18 <gongysh> I cannot see much progress in our bp
08:43:47 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, what do you think about the new direction for Tacker Studio? https://review.openstack.org/#/c/553684/
08:47:34 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, we need do more invetigation for ui pull and drag way.
08:48:15 <gongysh> I have heard you said the heat horizon is using drag and drop way, right?
08:48:48 <dangtrinhnt> yes, It does but it very complicated in the users point of view. I looked over other projects, they use forms.
08:49:40 <phuoc_> I think we can do the OSM way
08:49:44 <dangtrinhnt> For example, Opensource MANO, to generate the templates, users only need to use a very simple form.
08:49:55 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, you can write it as an alternative method.
08:50:00 <phuoc_> drag and drop way is complicated I think
08:50:03 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, ok.
08:50:43 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, you can even record heat horizon and oepnsource mano and have the link in the spec.
08:51:17 <dangtrinhnt> gongysh, sure. I will update the spec.
08:52:03 <gongysh> dangtrinhnt, thanks
08:52:20 <gongysh> phuoc_, any update?
08:53:06 <phuoc_> I am coding in the sfc with container and VM
08:53:35 <phuoc_> basically, the feature works but it is not stable enough
08:54:03 <phuoc_> I will improve this feature, and upload the code too
08:54:20 <gongysh> phuoc_, ok, it seems the k8s  openstack cloud provider is buggy.
08:55:25 <gongysh> #topic open discussion
08:55:43 <gongysh> joxyuki, hi
08:55:48 <gongysh> any thing to talk?
08:55:54 <joxyuki> gongysh, hi
08:56:11 <joxyuki> please review my specs when you have a time
08:56:20 <gongysh> which one?
08:56:41 <joxyuki> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/561840/
08:56:45 <joxyuki> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/563844/
08:56:47 <gongysh> joxyuki, I got two
08:56:48 <gongysh> ok
08:56:52 <joxyuki> thanks
08:57:05 <gongysh> I will devote some time to have a look.
08:57:34 <gongysh> and, if you guys are interested in kubernetes and openstack, please have a test on phuoc_ 's patch.
08:58:18 <phuoc_> thanks
08:58:38 <gongysh> 2 mins left
08:59:18 <gongysh> 1 mis
08:59:22 <gongysh> 1 min left.
08:59:42 <phuoc_> nothing from me xD
08:59:45 <gongysh> guys, don't forget to vote for me for the TC election if you got a poll invitation email.
08:59:48 <gongysh> thanks
08:59:49 <mardim> me neither
08:59:57 <gongysh> #endmeeting