17:00:19 <devkulkarni> #startmeeting Solum Team Meeting
17:00:20 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Mar 22 17:00:19 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is devkulkarni. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:21 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:24 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'solum_team_meeting'
17:00:26 <devkulkarni> #topic Roll Call
17:00:30 <devkulkarni> Devdatta Kulkarni
17:01:03 <devkulkarni> here is the agenda for today's meeting: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Solum#Agenda_for_2016-03-22_1700_UTC
17:01:41 <vijendar> o/
17:01:46 <devkulkarni> hi vijendar
17:01:57 <vijendar> hi devkulkarni
17:02:07 <devkulkarni> here is the agenda that I have prepared for us for today: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Solum#Agenda_for_2016-03-22_1700_UTC
17:03:02 <devkulkarni> vijendar: lets wait for few minutes to see if others join the meeting
17:03:17 <vijendar> devkulkarni: sure
17:04:58 <pt_15> devkulkarni: hi!
17:05:03 <devkulkarni> hi pt_15
17:05:12 <devkulkarni> we also have vijendar
17:05:26 <pt_15> hi vijendar!
17:05:33 <devkulkarni> here is the agenda for today's meeting: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Solum#Agenda_for_2016-03-22_1700_UTC
17:05:33 <vijendar> hi pt_15
17:05:47 <devkulkarni> ok, lets get started
17:05:53 <vijendar> sure
17:05:59 <devkulkarni> #topic Announcements
17:06:06 <devkulkarni> 1) PTL Elections
17:06:13 <devkulkarni> #link 	•	https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/PTL_Elections_March_2016
17:06:28 <devkulkarni> currently PTL elections for all openstack projects are underway
17:06:46 <devkulkarni> you can read the position statements from various candidates
17:06:52 <devkulkarni> on the above link
17:06:53 <vijendar> devkulkarni: are we going to get email notification for voting?
17:07:12 <devkulkarni> vijendar: you should have already for the projects that will have elections
17:07:22 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, hi
17:07:22 <devkulkarni> hi james_li, ashishjain
17:07:25 <james_li> hi devkulkarni
17:07:27 <devkulkarni> we are just getting started
17:07:37 <vijendar> devkulkarni: ok
17:07:39 <devkulkarni> here is the agenda for today's meeting: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Solum#Agenda_for_2016-03-22_1700_UTC
17:07:49 <devkulkarni> we are in the announcement topic
17:07:57 <devkulkarni> PTL elections are currently underway
17:08:13 <devkulkarni> you can read position statements on https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/PTL_Elections_March_2016
17:08:33 <devkulkarni> 2) Ashish Jain to present at IndiaHacks hackathon
17:08:38 <devkulkarni> this is from last week
17:08:43 <devkulkarni> how did it go ashishjain?
17:08:55 <ashishjain> It was a good conference
17:09:02 <devkulkarni> nice
17:09:14 <ashishjain> lot of good presentations from lot of leaders from oracle, walmart,
17:09:15 <devkulkarni> do you have a video/presentation?
17:09:22 <devkulkarni> cool..
17:09:26 <ashishjain> and lot of startups
17:09:44 <ashishjain> currently I do not see any video will share once the link is there
17:09:48 <devkulkarni> were all the presentations and presentors in bangalore?
17:09:51 <ashishjain> my presentation was good
17:09:55 <devkulkarni> or was it distributed
17:09:59 <devkulkarni> oh nice!!
17:10:02 <ashishjain> it was all in bangalore
17:10:08 <devkulkarni> what kind of questions did you get?
17:10:20 <devkulkarni> so all the presentations were in-person?
17:10:22 <ashishjain> there was one excellent prsentation by teamindus just checkout once you get time
17:10:33 <ashishjain> yes all the presentations were in person
17:10:43 <devkulkarni> the reason I ask is, you had said that the presentations were 'hangouts'
17:10:45 <devkulkarni> oh cool
17:10:55 <devkulkarni> can you share the link for the teamindus's presentation?
17:10:59 <devkulkarni> what did they talk about?
17:11:02 <ashishjain> teamindus.in
17:11:19 <ashishjain> they are a startup who is venturing into space
17:11:33 <ashishjain> and they plan to land on moon by 2017 end
17:11:44 <devkulkarni> oh wow
17:11:52 <ashishjain> started by 4 guys without any knowledge on space
17:12:01 <ashishjain> they were just amazing
17:12:21 <devkulkarni> cool
17:12:30 <devkulkarni> what kind of questions did you get for your presentation?
17:12:39 <ashishjain> For my presentation
17:12:51 <ashishjain> the guys had crazy question
17:12:57 <ashishjain> how can I hack openstack :D
17:13:10 <ashishjain> specially keystone
17:13:25 <ashishjain> it was offline questions
17:13:47 <devkulkarni> ha ha
17:14:04 <devkulkarni> did you get any questions about solum?
17:14:07 <ashishjain> Another one was how can I break openstack so that one tenant/user is able to access of other
17:14:24 <devkulkarni> wow
17:14:45 <ashishjain> On solum there was no specific question, I did touch upon solum when I talked about development best practices
17:14:54 <devkulkarni> I see
17:14:58 <ashishjain> yeah those guys were all student
17:15:08 <devkulkarni> oh ok
17:15:21 <ashishjain> and have been working on some good innovative projects
17:15:33 <devkulkarni> did any folks from any startup or any other company attend your presentation?
17:15:45 <ashishjain> Not sure
17:15:51 <devkulkarni> ok
17:15:55 <ashishjain> but there was one who attended from a company
17:16:07 <devkulkarni> nice
17:16:09 <ashishjain> and wanted some guidance on how to go about learning openstack
17:16:20 <ashishjain> I suggested him some links and references
17:16:22 <devkulkarni> oh good
17:16:26 <devkulkarni> nice
17:16:35 <ashishjain> I told those guys to send an email for more info
17:16:48 <ashishjain> and if they are keen to work on solum they are most welcome
17:16:57 <devkulkarni> makes sense.. also they can attend irc meetings..
17:17:01 <ashishjain> these all were mostly offline discussion
17:17:04 <devkulkarni> awesome !!
17:17:16 <ashishjain> I had a small quiz session also
17:17:23 <ashishjain> and distributed some goodies
17:17:24 <ashishjain> later
17:17:29 <devkulkarni> ha ha .. nice
17:17:45 <ashishjain> :)
17:17:52 <devkulkarni> alright this was good update ashishjain :)
17:18:07 <ashishjain> cool thanks devkulkarni
17:18:13 <devkulkarni> lets move to next topic
17:18:20 <devkulkarni> #topic Patches for review
17:18:29 <devkulkarni> No current outstanding patches
17:18:32 <devkulkarni> :)
17:18:40 <ashishjain> :)
17:18:50 <devkulkarni> thanks to vijendar and james_li our patch queue is almost empty
17:19:01 <devkulkarni> we have some old patches in the queue
17:19:02 <devkulkarni> https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/solum+status:open,n,z
17:19:08 <devkulkarni> https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/solum-dashboard+status:open,n,z
17:19:21 <devkulkarni> pt_15: can you resubmit your horizon patch ^^
17:19:26 <devkulkarni> it needs to be rebased
17:19:47 <pt_15> devkulkarni: ok, sure! :)
17:20:12 <devkulkarni> moving to the next topic
17:20:20 <devkulkarni> #topic Bug Review
17:20:31 <devkulkarni> 1) Issue in deleting an already deployed app
17:20:36 <devkulkarni> https://bugs.launchpad.net/solum/+bug/1557613
17:20:38 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1557613 in Solum "app-delete-not-deleting-app-for-failed-deployments" [High,New]
17:20:57 <devkulkarni> Details about this bug are as follows:
17:21:34 <devkulkarni> Essentially, what I am noticing is that when we try to delete an app that was previously deployed, we are getting an exception in the solum-deployer
17:21:57 <devkulkarni> and because of this exception, the app's entry is not getting deleted from the solum's db
17:22:20 <devkulkarni> If someone wants to take it up, I have provided details in the bug report
17:22:30 <vijendar> devkulkarni: I thought my recent patch addresses this issue
17:22:49 <devkulkarni> vijendar: good point.. I was about to say that
17:23:10 <devkulkarni> the third bug that I have listed in the agenda was the fix that you added
17:23:18 <devkulkarni> 2) App delete receiving stack not found
17:23:22 <devkulkarni> https://bugs.launchpad.net/solum/+bug/1548382
17:23:23 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1548382 in Solum "app-delete-receiving-stack-not-found" [Critical,New] - Assigned to Vijendar Komalla (vijendar-komalla)
17:24:06 <devkulkarni> I think the issue that I saw in the first bug listed above is probably due to the code that was added to fix the second bu
17:24:11 <devkulkarni> second bug
17:24:47 <devkulkarni> we need more verification on both these bugs
17:25:15 <devkulkarni> if any of you have a working devstack, can you try to reproduce it?
17:26:16 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, I will try to reproduce these
17:26:32 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: cool, that will be very helpful
17:26:45 <ashishjain> btw, how did you create the failure
17:26:51 <ashishjain> for this https://bugs.launchpad.net/solum/+bug/1557613
17:26:52 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1557613 in Solum "app-delete-not-deleting-app-for-failed-deployments" [High,New]
17:27:10 <ashishjain> aah I am sorry
17:27:13 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: here is what I did
17:27:15 <ashishjain> it is failing all the time
17:27:29 <ashishjain> I remember you raised a bug for this
17:27:32 <devkulkarni> yeah
17:28:03 <ashishjain> So I should be able to recreate it
17:28:17 <ashishjain> moreover java app deployment was successful
17:28:31 <devkulkarni> oh nice !!!
17:28:37 <devkulkarni> thanks for confirming this ashishjain
17:28:48 <devkulkarni> the java sample app was created by james_li
17:28:52 <ashishjain> you are welcome devkulkarni
17:28:55 <ashishjain> cool
17:28:57 <devkulkarni> thanks to james_li for the app
17:29:26 <devkulkarni> now the README for example apps is updated as well: https://github.com/openstack/solum/tree/master/examples/apps
17:30:00 <james_li> nice
17:30:04 <devkulkarni> if we can get sample app for php, nodejs, and ruby that will be really nice
17:31:26 <devkulkarni> are there any other bugs that need to be discussed as a team?
17:33:05 <devkulkarni> alright, lets move to open discussion
17:33:17 <devkulkarni> #topic Open discussion
17:33:23 <devkulkarni> 1) Austin summit planning
17:33:28 <devkulkarni> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/solum-austin-summit-planning
17:33:52 <devkulkarni> I have created above etherpad that we can use to plan the worksession and the fishbowl session for the austin summit
17:34:15 <devkulkarni> please add items to the work session agenda if you want us to discuss any particular item as a team
17:34:52 <devkulkarni> note that this will be our main opportunity to meet face-2-face as a team and discuss about project related things
17:35:15 <devkulkarni> feel free to add any item that you want us to talk as a team
17:36:05 <devkulkarni> for the fishbowl session, lets plan on what all things we want to present
17:37:11 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: just today was wondering about kolla-based deployment for solum that one of your team members had started looking into
17:37:44 <devkulkarni> pt_15: ping
17:37:48 <ashishjain> devkulkarni, no progress has been made on that
17:37:55 <devkulkarni> ashishjain: alright
17:38:09 <pt_15> devkulkarni: hey
17:38:12 <devkulkarni> pt_15: have added some comments to your proposal
17:38:33 <devkulkarni> - changed "Horizon's API" to "Solum's API"
17:38:53 <pt_15> devkulkarni: yeah, saw them, I'll resubmit my application with these changes :)
17:39:00 <devkulkarni> ok
17:39:12 <devkulkarni> other than those changes, it looks good
17:39:26 <pt_15> devkulkarni: ok, great! :D
17:40:35 <devkulkarni> other item in open discussion is tagging our mitaka release
17:41:04 <devkulkarni> vijendar: are there any outstanding patches that we need to wait for?
17:41:20 <vijendar> devkulkarni: no
17:41:33 <devkulkarni> thanks vijendar
17:41:47 <devkulkarni> I will submit patch for the release today then
17:42:39 <vijendar> sure
17:42:41 <devkulkarni> those were all the items that I had for today
17:43:15 <devkulkarni> anything that any of you have on mind that we should discuss as a team?
17:45:28 <devkulkarni> alright then.. I will end the meeting
17:45:38 <devkulkarni> thanks everyone for joining today
17:45:43 <devkulkarni> #endmeeting