18:05:32 <aignatov_> #startmeeting savanna
18:05:32 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Sep 19 18:05:32 2013 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is aignatov_. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
18:05:33 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
18:05:36 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'savanna'
18:05:48 <aignatov_> #topic Agenda
18:05:57 <aignatov_> #info News / updates
18:06:07 <aignatov_> #info Roadmap cleanup / update
18:06:17 <aignatov_> #info Action items from the last meeting
18:06:26 <aignatov_> #info General discussion
18:06:38 <aignatov_> #topic News / updates
18:06:54 <aignatov_> what about EDP?
18:07:42 <nadya> yesterday I successfully run pig job usin UI
18:07:51 <aignatov_> smll note, Sergey is away today, I'm proxing him now
18:08:17 <aignatov_> that's great, Nadya!
18:08:48 <aignatov_> do you know knews from RedHat guys, Trevor and Chad working on edp?
18:08:59 <aignatov_> knews-> news
18:09:53 <nadya> yes
18:10:07 <aignatov_> update from me, I've sent all patches related to moving vanilla to 1.2.1 Hadoop version
18:10:26 <akuznetsov> we find work around with problem getting information about host
18:10:55 <akuznetsov> nova return hostId which is hash of tenant id and host name
18:11:05 <aignatov_> so, don't froget to update images in your environments and labs:)
18:11:06 <nadya> Trevor is working on job_manager refactoring and several bugs. Chad uploaded patch for UI that I've tested
18:11:37 <akuznetsov> so knowing the rack configuration and using this information we can restore information about machine host
18:12:03 <akuznetsov> code is available on following patch set
18:12:27 <akuznetsov> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/45434/
18:12:31 <aignatov_> #info we find work around with problem getting information about host
18:13:32 <aignatov_> #info work in progress on UI part and refactorin job_manager for EDP
18:14:17 <jmaron> what image updates do we have to make in association with host issue?
18:15:12 <aignatov_> hi, jmaron, what is that issue about? Can you give us more details?
18:15:28 <rnirmal> akuznetsov: thanks for getting that in with the hostid... might be good to work with the scheduler team to get rack information as well.. but that's down the road
18:16:57 <aignatov_> #topic Roadmap cleanup / update
18:16:59 <rnirmal> jmaron: if you are referencing the rack/host information.. no changes should be needed for the image. the topology.sh script should be injected on start
18:17:19 <jmaron> ok.  I was worried about "so, don't froget to update images in your environments and labs"
18:17:51 <aignatov_> I think we should add Heat integration to  for the next cycle after the Savanna 0.3 released
18:18:23 <ruhe> aignatov_, isn't it already in the roadmap?
18:19:47 <aignatov_> I knnow that we palnned to add Heat to Savanna 1.0 release, it was the far future in our minds before TC meetings
18:19:49 <aignatov_> ok
18:20:17 <aignatov_> #action aignatov Update roadmap with Heat integration
18:21:22 <rnirmal> I think we need to have a separate heat discussion. someone can correct me... but heat is based on file templates ... which may lead to a hacky solution trying to map the cluster templates to heat templates. i.e I think they don't have a programmable option. Or we covert cluster template to a heat template.
18:22:15 <rnirmal> I've been trying to read up on heat.. hopefully will get to it this week
18:22:33 <ruhe> rnirmal, i agree we don't need to pass hadoop cluster templates to Heat. But we can use Heat to provision and configure VMs with bare operating system
18:22:52 <aignatov_> that's good point rnirmal,
18:23:04 <aignatov_> ruhe, also +1
18:23:11 <ruhe> Heat might also take care of anty-affinity, cinder volumes, etc
18:23:26 <aignatov_> I've moving the next topic
18:23:47 <aignatov_> #topic Action items from the last meeting
18:24:19 <aignatov_> there are no AIs on the last meeting, so next topic :)
18:24:33 <aignatov_> #topic General discussion
18:25:33 <aignatov_> rnirmal, you can create doc on wiki and etherpad to rite pur proc and cons and defficulty with Heat interation in details
18:26:05 <rnirmal> aignatov_: yes I'll create a doc for it
18:26:05 <aignatov_> I mean not only wiki pages with info why we can or cant use Heat in high level
18:26:38 <nadya> yes, it's a good point. I think we should start thinking about integration with Heat
18:27:24 <rnirmal> I'll start an etherpad which we can use to discussions first
18:27:27 <rnirmal> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/savanna_heat
18:27:32 <nadya> besides, Heat guys started to discuss autoscaling feature
18:27:41 <jmaron> specifically interested in some of the ssh and /etc/hosts setup required for savanna
18:28:10 <jmaron> (can heat allow for such VM post processing)
18:28:21 <rnirmal> jmaron: yeah I don't think that feature has been completed yet
18:28:27 <rnirmal> that will def be a blocker
18:28:31 <jmaron> that's a problem
18:28:38 <ruhe> jmaron, we'll need to implement it :)
18:28:45 <ruhe> in Heat
18:28:52 <jmaron> :)
18:29:02 <ruhe> to be good citizens in OpenStack community
18:29:06 <nadya> if we want something special for Savanna from AS-feature we should let them know I guess
18:29:08 <aignatov_> yes, we have to contribute to Heat in this case
18:29:51 <aignatov_> otherwise it'll be a long way to get Savanna integrated w/o Heat :)
18:29:56 <rnirmal> yeah it's going to end up that way
18:31:34 <jmaron> I guess it would be clearer to TC what the savanna value proposition is post Heat integration
18:32:36 <aignatov_> guys another request from Sergey and me: we have a tons of patches on the review
18:33:21 <mattf> i'll take another shot at some this evening
18:33:57 <aignatov_> please work with the code reviews more frequently
18:34:06 <aignatov_> that;s request for all
18:35:23 <aignatov_> thanks mattf
18:36:28 <aignatov_> I'll try to merge patches with high raiting
18:37:26 <aignatov_> hihg rating I mean more than two +1/+2
18:37:35 <ruhe> Important reminder: Next TC meeting will be on Tuesday at 20:00 UTC at #openstack-meeting ; TC will vote for Savanna incubation
18:37:47 <mattf> ruhe, thanks for the reminder
18:37:57 <aignatov_> thanks ruhe
18:38:53 <aignatov_> are there any other items to discuss?
18:41:54 <aignatov_> 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 three
18:42:14 <aignatov_> 2 1
18:42:26 <aignatov_> #endmeeting savanna