14:01:40 <ttx> #startmeeting releaseteam
14:01:40 <opendevmeet> Meeting started Fri Oct  6 14:01:40 2023 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is ttx. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:01:40 <opendevmeet> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:01:40 <opendevmeet> The meeting name has been set to 'releaseteam'
14:01:50 <ttx> Ping list: elodilles armstrong
14:01:54 <hberaud> o/
14:01:58 <elodilles> ~o~
14:02:27 <ttx> Congrats on the successful on-time release!
14:02:34 <elodilles> \o/
14:02:38 <hberaud> \o.
14:02:40 <hberaud> /
14:02:41 <ttx> #topic Review task completion
14:02:50 <ttx> Not sure it's worth going through each of then line by line
14:03:02 <elodilles> probably not
14:03:16 <elodilles> we covered every task during the release day :)
14:03:20 <ttx> suffice to say they were all completed, and led to release
14:03:28 <elodilles> +1
14:03:31 <ttx> any comments on any of those?
14:04:02 <elodilles> time schedule was completely fine
14:04:14 <ttx> I just had one question for fungi , was the semaphore patch reverted?
14:04:18 <elodilles> we were ready 1 hr ahead
14:04:28 <elodilles> ttx: good point
14:04:32 <fungi> ttx: yes, it was
14:04:39 <elodilles> ++
14:04:49 <ttx> alright then
14:05:05 <fungi> #link https://review.opendev.org/896949 Revert "Temporarily remove release docs semaphores"
14:05:08 <ttx> We'll review things to improve in the process during our PTG session
14:05:16 <fungi> merged yesterday at 02:33:49z
14:05:18 <ttx> so no need to dive into it right now
14:05:26 <elodilles> +1 +1 +1
14:05:33 <ttx> #topic Assign next week tasks
14:05:41 <ttx> #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/caracal-relmgt-tracking
14:05:52 <ttx> I created the etherpad so that we could assign next week's tasks
14:06:08 <ttx> also note a few skipped meetings in the coming weeks (\o/)
14:06:09 <elodilles> thanks for working on it ttx
14:06:21 <hberaud> +1
14:06:44 <ttx> the signing key patch... was merged iirc
14:06:51 <elodilles> not yet
14:07:01 <ttx> ah ok
14:07:11 <elodilles> will happen on monday if i remember correctly
14:07:15 <ttx> I'll assign to fungi
14:07:30 <fungi> yep
14:07:32 <fungi> planned for monday
14:07:43 <fungi> i've still got it wip at the moment
14:07:43 <elodilles> looking forward to it
14:07:56 <ttx> who wants to chair next week's meeting?
14:08:27 <elodilles> thx hberaud o:)
14:09:01 <ttx> #topic Open Discussion
14:09:22 <ttx> I dropped one item there re: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/897054
14:09:54 <ttx> "This includes some features which landed shortly after the deadline which were granted an exception to release this cycle." sounds weird to me
14:10:06 <elodilles> indeed
14:10:13 <ttx> this is basically a featureful release in a stable branch
14:10:14 <elodilles> it sounds weird to me too
14:10:22 <ttx> with a minor bump
14:10:43 <ttx> but I probably missed the discussions that led to it being released post-release
14:11:09 <ttx> we have two options:
14:11:19 <hberaud> same thing for me I'm not aware of that
14:11:23 <ttx> - release it in stable/2023.2 which would be a breach of the stable policy
14:11:48 <ttx> - release it in master / Caracal since it's an intermediary-released thing
14:11:58 <elodilles> actually as far as i see there's 1) a CI patch 2) a .gitreview patch 3) a TOX_CONSTRAINTS patch in it... do i miss something?
14:12:25 <elodilles> https://storage.bhs.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_dcaab5e32b234d56b626f72581e3644c/zuul_opendev_logs_2f7/897054/2/check/releases-tox-list-changes/2f7bf75/tox/list-changes/list-changes-results.log
14:13:25 <ttx> hm I'm seeing "[NEW] Introduce NGS agent design"
14:14:03 <ttx> ah no that's open patches
14:14:08 <elodilles> yepp
14:14:44 <hberaud> I agree with elodilles concerning the landed patches
14:14:46 <elodilles> anyway, i don't know whether that commit message has some ironic meaning (hah, pun)
14:15:04 <ttx> I'm confused, those patches should have been in the 7.2.0 that was released earlier
14:15:11 <elodilles> otherwise, the MINOR bump is fishy, then...
14:16:05 <ttx> ah no those are post branch patches
14:16:08 <ttx> ok so
14:16:18 <elodilles> ttx: actually, those patches are usually generated after branching with the final release, and we don't do another release usually
14:16:24 <elodilles> yepp
14:16:33 <ttx> it feels like this does not have any feature and can be released as a PATCH release on stable/2023.2
14:16:57 <ttx> (and should probably have a different commit message
14:16:59 <ttx> )
14:17:03 <ttx> I'll comment toward that
14:17:13 <hberaud> ++
14:17:14 <elodilles> furthermore, as there's no functional change in it, we don't even need to release, in my opinion...
14:17:23 <hberaud> yep
14:18:40 <ttx> ok commented
14:18:47 <ttx> any other topic in open discussion?
14:18:57 <hberaud> nope
14:19:14 <elodilles> neither from me
14:19:30 <ttx> perfect. Talk to y'all next week!
14:20:02 <elodilles> thanks ttx o/ see you next week!
14:20:02 <ttx> #endmeeting