14:00:17 <ttx> #startmeeting releaseteam 14:00:17 <opendevmeet> Meeting started Fri Mar 3 14:00:17 2023 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is ttx. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:00:17 <opendevmeet> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 14:00:17 <opendevmeet> The meeting name has been set to 'releaseteam' 14:00:26 <hberaud> o/ 14:00:27 <ttx> Ping list: hberaud armstrong elodilles 14:00:57 <ttx> Agenda at https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/antelope-relmgt-tracking down to line 372 14:01:19 <elodilles> o/ 14:01:31 <ttx> Hi everyone! 14:01:40 <ttx> #topic Review task completion 14:01:50 <ttx> * Process any remaining library branching exception (all) 14:01:59 <ttx> was there any left? 14:02:09 <elodilles> https://review.opendev.org/q/topic:antelope-stable-branches+is:open 14:02:16 <elodilles> empty list ^^^ 14:02:24 <ttx> \o/ 14:02:25 <hberaud> \o/ 14:02:38 <elodilles> there were some leftover, but we merged them yesterday 14:02:51 <ttx> - generate release requests for all deliverables that have do not have a suitable candidate yet (hberaud) 14:03:23 <hberaud> for the devstack plugins https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875376 https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875376 14:03:32 <hberaud> sorry: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875375 14:04:03 <ttx> still waitring on PTL approval on those ones? 14:04:03 <hberaud> both are still opened 14:04:11 <ttx> do we have a deadline? 14:04:17 <hberaud> gmann: FYI ^ 14:04:38 <hberaud> good question 14:04:50 <ttx> I think it needs to be done but not super urgently 14:04:58 <ttx> and I trust gmann will be on top of it 14:05:09 <hberaud> I check the patches from the previous series and I didn't see any deadline in the commit message 14:05:20 <hberaud> /check/checked 14:05:51 <hberaud> else for the CWI projects all the patches are listed into the etherpad 14:06:00 <hberaud> we check where they are now 14:06:04 <hberaud> can* 14:06:20 <ttx> Only two left 14:06:32 <ttx> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875378 and https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/874758 14:06:36 <ttx> the other I just approved 14:06:57 <hberaud> I'll update https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875378 14:06:58 <ttx> Horizon 23.1.0 is waiting on a patch 14:07:24 <ttx> the other yes might need a major bump 14:07:32 <ttx> I think those can wait until early next week 14:07:33 <elodilles> for the bifrost release: I hesitated a bit about the version bump + no response from the team :/ 14:08:01 <ttx> maybe we can wait on their input 14:08:02 <elodilles> ttx: ack, let's check them early next week 14:08:06 <opendevreview> Hervé Beraud proposed openstack/releases master: Release bifrost for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875378 14:08:12 <hberaud> bifrost ^ 14:08:19 <elodilles> hberaud: ++ 14:08:25 <ttx> Oh well, it's done now 14:08:47 <fungi> JayF: ^ 14:09:03 <hberaud> and indeed the one remaining can be handled early next week 14:09:10 <hberaud> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/874758 14:09:21 <ttx> yep 14:09:30 <ttx> What about RC1s 14:09:56 <hberaud> I left a comment to the last one 14:10:01 <hberaud> to ping the team 14:10:19 <hberaud> concerning the rc1 14:10:36 <hberaud> I think we can merge those whitout responses 14:10:38 <ttx> we have 5 RC1s that have been -1ed and should wait next week 14:10:38 <hberaud> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/874758 14:10:43 <ttx> the others had no answers and should be preocessed today or Monday in absnce of PTL+1 14:10:59 <hberaud> they are legit people ask to wait a bit for patches 14:11:06 <elodilles> i've reviewed most of the open ones and mostly +2'd, 14:11:17 <elodilles> on 1 or 2 i have raised some question 14:11:26 <hberaud> I think we can merge those -1d early next week 14:11:33 <ttx> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875438 hit a snatch in gate 14:11:37 <ttx> will retry it 14:12:04 <elodilles> oh -> "No package matching 'git-review' is available" 14:12:23 <hberaud> I missed the questions 14:12:24 <elodilles> this was the ubuntu repo mirror issue last week, wasn't it? :S 14:12:25 <ttx> I just reenqueued it 14:12:37 <ttx> was it? 14:12:50 <elodilles> fungi: were the mirror re-enabled recently? :-o 14:13:19 <fungi> there was a mirror server down in the inmotion iad3 region. i'll see if it died again 14:13:30 <elodilles> :S 14:13:51 <elodilles> if it died, then we should wait with the patch approvals :S 14:14:02 <ttx> elodilles: hberaud : given that Hervé posted the "last warning" earlier today, what do you think about merging those without answer first thing Monday? 14:14:25 <ttx> want to give the PT/Asia people a chance to react to the last minute warning 14:14:44 <hberaud> np 14:14:52 <hberaud> as you want 14:14:55 <elodilles> ttx: mostly OK; sahara-* patches can be merged though (no PTL & release liaison) 14:14:56 <ttx> I'll add it as a task and assign me 14:15:06 <ttx> elodilles: ah yes 14:15:07 <hberaud> ok 14:15:32 <elodilles> ttx: we have a task for that: Process any standing RC1 deadline exceptions (all) 14:15:35 <elodilles> ;) 14:15:54 <elodilles> well, these are not 'exceptions' but anyway... :) 14:16:07 <ttx> exceptions are those with -1 14:16:12 <ttx> and we have the full week to process them 14:16:13 <elodilles> exactly 14:16:24 <ttx> so I clarified in the etherpad 14:16:33 <hberaud> I didn't find questions inside those -1, only additional time requested 14:16:46 <elodilles> ttx: perfectly formulated :) 14:16:50 <hberaud> s/requested/request 14:17:12 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release networking-generic-switch 7.1.0 for antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/874828 14:17:38 <ttx> ok anything else on that task? 14:17:58 <hberaud> nope 14:18:11 <ttx> I can w+1 the sahara ones 14:18:13 <ttx> now 14:18:30 <elodilles> should we wait for fungi? 14:18:37 <ttx> ah maybe 14:18:43 * ttx pauses 14:18:46 <elodilles> though a patch has landed 1 min ago ^^^ 14:18:56 <ttx> will do after meet 14:19:02 <fungi> the server is back up again 14:19:03 <elodilles> ack 14:19:17 <ttx> - Send countdown email (ttx) 14:19:19 <pranali> elodilles, Glance is facing issues on gate, but if our intended patch is merged before monday then I'll update the release patch accordingly before monday EOD 14:19:23 <ttx> Will do after the meeting review 14:19:40 <elodilles> pranali: ack, thanks for the heads up o/ 14:19:42 <fungi> but yes, seems to be a repeat of last week. nova shut the server down approximately 40 minutes ago so i'm going to take that region entirely out of service until someone has time to debug nova 14:20:52 <elodilles> fungi: thanks, let us know when it is safe to start the merges 14:21:22 <fungi> it should be safe now 14:21:30 <elodilles> thanks! 14:21:38 <fungi> taking the region out of service is just additional insurance against it happening again 14:23:04 <ttx> ok, moving on 14:23:04 <ttx> #topic Assign next week tasks 14:23:27 <ttx> two tasks left.. sending email should go to meeting chair 14:23:44 <ttx> the "After all the projects enabled in devstack ..." one is a bit fuzzy 14:24:32 <ttx> there are details on https://releases.openstack.org/reference/process.html#r-2-week 14:24:40 <elodilles> i've taken them 14:24:50 <ttx> cool, thanks elodilles 14:25:00 <elodilles> np 14:25:12 <ttx> #topic Review countdown email 14:25:20 <ttx> #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/relmgmt-weekly-emails 14:26:13 <ttx> do we actually need to branch on Monday? 14:26:31 <ttx> or was that done already 14:27:19 <hberaud> I think the tool will tell us 14:27:32 <elodilles> mostly done, this is just a safety call i think 14:27:37 <ttx> ok 14:27:55 <hberaud> yeah just a check to be sure we left nothing 14:28:24 <hberaud> LGTM 14:28:44 <elodilles> RC deadline is 16th, isn't it? 14:29:07 <hberaud> yeah during r-1 14:29:20 <elodilles> updated 14:29:31 <ttx> We usually give people until the Friday for last RCs iirc 14:29:33 <hberaud> https://releases.openstack.org/antelope/schedule.html#a-finalrc 14:29:56 <ttx> hence the 17th? 14:29:59 <hberaud> yes 14:30:12 <ttx> 17 it is 14:30:13 <hberaud> I think we can left them the friday 14:30:25 <hberaud> just in case 14:30:33 <ttx> ok all set 14:30:45 <ttx> #topic Open Discussion 14:30:54 <ttx> Anything else to discuss? Any red flag? 14:31:05 <hberaud> nope 14:31:56 <elodilles> i don't see issues 14:32:16 <elodilles> hberaud: when you have time could you please review this? https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875448 14:32:29 <hberaud> sure 14:32:40 <elodilles> 'new-release' command fix for stable/release_id 14:32:47 <ttx> Yes we do have a few stuck reviews 14:33:14 <ttx> including some reno ones, which we could merge (but not do a release until after 2023.1) 14:33:42 <elodilles> oh, and a note: reno seems broken for Antelope -> it lists all the versions that ever existed under 2023.1 14:34:44 <elodilles> i don't know whether i will have time next week to look into the issue 14:34:51 <ttx> hmm, does that reseult in broken release notes? 14:35:06 <ttx> do you have an example? 14:35:10 <elodilles> ttx: the job passes, release notes are generated, 14:35:17 <elodilles> let me search for one 14:36:43 <elodilles> this one for example: https://26e666f454b67535de15-3d610b89476ce95ad7fe6841f1088a80.ssl.cf5.rackcdn.com/874600/1/gate/build-openstack-releasenotes/b97219c/docs/2023.1.html 14:36:47 <ttx> Also we can approve https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/872407 14:37:27 <ttx> elodok so the generated notes include too many versions 14:37:44 <elodilles> ttx: yes, from previous releases 14:37:59 <ttx> that one is going to be not fun. I'll have a look to see if that's easily fixed 14:38:23 <ttx> but there is a lot of dhellmann's dark magic in the way reno traverses git repositories 14:38:55 <ttx> so not sure fixing that to accomodate with stable/2023.1 - style names will be easy 14:39:10 <ttx> adding a task for it 14:39:31 <elodilles> ttx: it might be related to 'restarting the alphabet' :) but yes 14:40:23 <ttx> yeah, I'm also not convinced we should call it the "2023.1 series" since some of the releases listed under it date back from 2022. That's one of the cases where calling it "Antelope" makes more sense 14:40:40 <ttx> (in that specific release notes context) 14:41:07 <ttx> but we'll keep whatever makes reno happiest 14:41:30 <ttx> changing release numbers is just not super fun for release tooling 14:41:51 <ttx> ok task added and assigned to me 14:41:53 <elodilles> the projects started to merge reno patches already with 2023.1 14:41:56 <bauzas> (just lurking the discussion) 14:42:01 <elodilles> ttx: thanks! 14:42:13 <bauzas> is 2023.1 a problematic name for a reno ? 14:42:14 <elodilles> hi bauzas o/ 14:42:34 <ttx> well the release notes it generates for 2023.1 are listign every version ever 14:42:45 <ttx> see https://26e666f454b67535de15-3d610b89476ce95ad7fe6841f1088a80.ssl.cf5.rackcdn.com/874600/1/gate/build-openstack-releasenotes/b97219c/docs/2023.1.html 14:42:47 <opendevreview> Yasufumi Ogawa proposed openstack/releases master: Release tacker RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875471 14:42:55 * bauzas had some dreams about having a 2023.1.0.0 nova version but this plan turned down quickly :D 14:42:59 <elodilles> or https://storage.bhs.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_dcaab5e32b234d56b626f72581e3644c/zuul_opendev_logs_372/876301/1/gate/build-openstack-releasenotes/3720edf/docs/2023.1.html 14:43:06 <elodilles> as another example 14:43:21 <ttx> ew 14:43:24 <elodilles> bauzas: /o\ 14:43:33 <frickler> ha, just wanted to mention the same thing 14:44:10 <bauzas> https://docs.openstack.org/releasenotes/nova/unreleased.html 14:44:17 <bauzas> I'm confused 14:44:24 <bauzas> we use our nova version number 14:44:35 <bauzas> oh, but the stable branches, gotcha 14:44:54 <ttx> yes the 2023.1 release notes are the ones that will be linked to in the release page 14:44:56 <fungi> yeah, on the "nova 2023.1.0.0" thing, there were a lot of reasons we moved away from synchronized release numbers for projects. someone should probably revisit the history of those decisions just so people don't propose solutions that bring back the problems we worked hard to solve 14:45:07 <ttx> while the "unreleased" one are inconstant flux 14:45:15 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release sahara-plugin-mapr RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875458 14:45:17 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release sahara-extra RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875454 14:45:20 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release sahara-plugin-spark RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875459 14:45:22 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release sahara-plugin-storm RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875460 14:45:25 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release sahara-plugin-cdh RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875457 14:45:28 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release sahara-plugin-vanilla RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875461 14:45:31 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release sahara-plugin-ambari RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875456 14:45:33 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release sahara-image-elements RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875455 14:45:36 <opendevreview> Merged openstack/releases master: Release sahara RC1 for Antelope https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/875462 14:46:09 <ttx> OK, I'll have a look to that reno thing but i suspect I will have to defer to more actively-trained python eyes to debug it 14:46:28 <ttx> that's what you get turning me into a manager 14:46:44 <ttx> anything else before we close the meeting? 14:46:45 <elodilles> :) 14:47:05 <elodilles> nothing i can think of 14:47:14 <ttx> ok will send email in a few 14:47:44 <hberaud> nope 14:48:11 <ttx> #endmeeting