21:00:23 <danwent> #startmeeting quantum
21:00:24 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Mar 11 21:00:23 2013 UTC.  The chair is danwent. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
21:00:25 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
21:00:26 <amotoki> hi
21:00:28 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'quantum'
21:00:37 <danwent> #info agenda: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Network/Meetings
21:00:53 <danwent> #topic announcements
21:01:09 <danwent> first off, congrats to markmcclain, who will be the new Quantum PTL :)
21:01:22 <nati_ueno> congrats!
21:01:30 <danwent> markmcclain: i have a bunch of emails I haven't replied to yet for quantum... i'm thinking of just forwarding them to you :P
21:01:50 <danwent> #info markmcclain will be quantum ptl for havana
21:01:50 <emagana> markmcclain: congratulations sr.
21:02:03 <salv-orlando> all hail our new lider maximo!
21:02:23 <danwent> #info the grizzly-rc1 branch date is tomorrow, march 12th, EOD pacific time
21:02:39 <garyk> hi
21:02:50 <danwent> once we pull that branch, master will be open for havana commits, and we will remove -2 from existing reviews
21:03:09 <garyk> danwent: yong said that he will not be able to make the meeting tonight
21:03:12 <danwent> Just a heads up, I will be OOO wed-sun
21:03:16 <danwent> garyk: thx
21:03:50 <danwent> #info at team meeting next monday, we will decide if we need to release an RC2, and if so, what changes we would need to backport from master
21:04:11 <danwent> so if you have a fix post RC1, we will first commit it to master and backport (much like an existing stable release)
21:04:23 <danwent> any other announcements/comments?
21:04:44 <danwent> #topic Grizzly RC1 bugs (markmcclain)
21:05:03 <danwent> #info https://launchpad.net/quantum/+milestone/grizzly-rc1
21:05:17 <markmcclain> First, thanks to you dan.. you've left some big shoes to fill as PTL
21:05:46 <danwent> markmcclain: thanks.  time to take me behind the barn and shoot me :P
21:06:09 <med_> Is THAT the transition process.
21:06:19 <danwent> med_: no body told you?
21:06:31 <danwent> ok markmcclain , looks like we have 5 active bugs?
21:06:39 <markmcclain> haha
21:06:52 <markmcclain> yeah and 3 of those are all related to migrations
21:06:59 <markmcclain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1153585
21:07:00 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1153585 in quantum "Add a migration for plugins which added L3 support in Grizzly" [High,In progress]
21:07:07 <markmcclain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1153366
21:07:09 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1153366 in quantum "port_security migration does not migrate data" [High,In progress]
21:07:14 <markmcclain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1153616
21:07:16 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1153616 in quantum "nvp_port_mapping breaks upgrade from folsom for NVP users" [High,In progress]
21:07:48 <markmcclain> they're currently covered by two core devs each and we're testing the fixes
21:08:25 <markmcclain> the two medium fixes have reviewers but I'm not sure they've been tested enough
21:08:26 <markmcclain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1115999
21:08:28 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1115999 in quantum "quantum-netns-cleanup does not stop metadata proxies" [Medium,In progress]
21:09:31 <markmcclain> amotoki or garyk any thoughts on this?
21:09:58 <markmcclain> review is here: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/21489/
21:10:05 <garyk> markmcclain: it looked good last time i saw it - minor little change
21:10:31 <markmcclain> ok… so that will stay in for RC1
21:10:42 <garyk> markmcclain: i think that tomorrow it will be done
21:10:53 <markmcclain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1135948
21:10:55 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1135948 in quantum "Wrong behavior when a DHCP agent goes down" [Medium,In progress]
21:11:16 <danwent> yeah, both of those patchsets seemed a bit on the big side, but as long as we have core devs testing + reviewing, I think they are ok
21:11:44 <markmcclain> fixes a problem that existed in Folsom too… the change has been simplified a great deal
21:12:08 <markmcclain> salv-orlando: do you still have time available to review it?
21:12:13 <salv-orlando> yep
21:12:22 <markmcclain> ok.. so we've got 2 cores on it
21:12:33 <markmcclain> that's it for the bugs…anything else?
21:12:56 <garyk> markmcclain: is this a bug that should be backported?
21:12:56 <danwent> markmcclain: we have been seeing issues in quantum/nova integration when using an admin toke
21:13:00 <danwent> token
21:13:12 <danwent> but those should be changes purely to nova, I suspect.
21:13:26 <markmcclain> ok.. is there a bug to track?
21:13:31 <danwent> have another bug to mention in python quantumclient section
21:13:34 <garyk> danwent: can you please elaborate
21:14:29 <danwent> garyk: need to do the full bug write-up, but basically, nova/quantum integration currently seems to require that you use a "service user", rather than an "admin token"
21:15:21 <danwent> it seems like we should be doing something more akin to how nova authenticates for talking to glance
21:15:28 <garyk> danwent: ok. i know that certain requests require to admin t get port details. the rest should be regulra user
21:15:49 <danwent> which uses a single set of auth config in nova, rather than quantum-specific auth variables.
21:16:31 <danwent> garyk: anyway, I don't know as much about this as I should yet... will file a bug when i get done working through it myself.
21:16:41 <garyk> ok, thanks
21:16:57 <danwent> garyk: could be that i'm just missing something... i tend to just configure nova to use a service user
21:17:10 <danwent> ok, anything else on RC1 bugs.
21:17:19 <garyk> danwent: yeah, me too
21:17:51 <danwent> #topic quantum python-client
21:18:14 <markmcclain> we released 2.2.0 on Mar 7th
21:18:15 <danwent> markmcclain: again?
21:18:51 <markmcclain> arosen: has proposed requirement updates for the other projects to raise the minimum to 2.2.0
21:18:57 <danwent> markmcclain: markmcclain nevermind, was just saying you need to talk again :)
21:19:14 <markmcclain> I get tired of hearing me talk too :)
21:19:31 <markmcclain> the requirement update process has a gone a little slower than expected
21:20:15 <markmcclain> we're the first requirement change that's going through the centralized requirements process so everyone is figuring out how the process works
21:21:26 <markmcclain> the client does have one bug that was reported shortly before the meeting that we'll look at
21:21:27 <markmcclain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/python-quantumclient/+bug/1153715
21:21:29 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1153715 in python-quantumclient "no commandline option to set insecure=True" [High,New]
21:21:30 <danwent> markmcclain: this came up today: https://bugs.launchpad.net/python-quantumclient/+bug/1153715
21:21:37 <danwent> haha
21:21:53 <danwent> my shitty IRC webclient doesn't scroll... so I keep missing that you've already said things.
21:22:49 <salv-orlando> danwent:
21:22:50 <salv-orlando> web chat on free node usually scrolls
21:22:51 <danwent> seems like openstack projects need to do a better job of making sure "generic" flags like this as applied across all projects
21:23:10 <danwent> salv-orlando: mmm... that's what i'm using
21:24:00 <markmcclain> any other client questions?
21:24:32 <danwent> nope
21:24:49 <danwent> #topic documentation (danwent)
21:24:57 <danwent> so it seems like we're a bit behind on docs.
21:25:13 <danwent> i took a full pass through the admin guide and have started updating general items
21:25:37 <danwent> I particularly need people to help around metadata and lbaas
21:26:23 <danwent> salv-orlando: what is status on API guide updates?  I think you'll need to wrestle more work out of people than I will for the admin guide.
21:26:44 <markmcclain> danwent: I'll claim the metadata doc ticket
21:26:45 <salv-orlando> I am starting doing by myself the provider net updates
21:26:59 <salv-orlando> which is simple. But I really need help for the LBaaS chapter which is huge
21:27:11 <garyk> danwent: i need to document the vif updates
21:27:29 <salv-orlando> I'm also going to randomly select one between nati-ueno and arosen for the security group API work!
21:27:30 <danwent> any takers for the lbaas?  otherwise, I'll just do a varient of the wiki page I wrote to make sure there is something there
21:27:41 <nati_ueno> salv-orlando: Thanks!
21:28:12 <salv-orlando> congrats nati_ueno who has just accepted to the the API doc for security groups!
21:28:18 <salv-orlando> (you did not read the fine print)
21:28:38 <nati_ueno> salv-orlando: He he I'll do my best
21:28:40 <danwent> Ok, at the meeting next week, we need all doc bugs to be filed.  We've done a great job getting the code in shape, now we need to make sure the docs are also up to par.
21:29:05 <danwent> markmcclain: i also need help on the folsom + db upgrade stuff
21:29:26 <markmcclain> right… I'll help with that too
21:29:28 <danwent> I want to make sure people are testing this, as I think its a likely source of bugs, and I don't want those bugs popping up too late in the cycle
21:29:48 <danwent> (we already saw a flurry of migration related bugs in the last few days).
21:30:19 <alexxu> an advert... there is pagination api doc ready for review at https://review.openstack.org/#/c/22536/
21:30:23 <danwent> I can take a crack at the initial metadata stuff if that frees you up to do the DB
21:31:00 <danwent> ok, anything else on docs?
21:31:00 <annegentle> also an advert… review https://review.openstack.org/#/c/20960/ so that we can publish to api.openstack.org/api-ref.html
21:31:21 <annegentle> salv-orlando: has been reviewing, maybe it's good-to-go, just need that last +
21:31:31 <nati_ueno> salv-orlando: do you have already bug report for security group stuff?
21:31:37 <danwent> salv-orlando: thanks for reviewing that already
21:31:52 <salv-orlando> nati_ueno: I need to find it gimme a sec
21:32:08 <danwent> ok, moving on to horizon
21:32:12 <salv-orlando> danwent: actually annegentle had to chase me a lot as I kept forgetting that review :/
21:32:24 <danwent> #topic Horizon + quantum ( amotoki / nati_ueno )
21:32:27 <annegentle> yeah it's hard to remember the api-site repo :) it's okay
21:32:45 <nati_ueno> congrat for Akihiro. He is also horizon core now!
21:32:57 <garyk> congratulations
21:33:04 <emagana> +2
21:33:12 <amotoki> nati_ueno: thanks. It help us to bridge QUantum and Horizon.
21:33:19 <amotoki> everyone thanks!
21:33:33 <SumitNaiksatam> congrats amotoki!
21:33:38 <danwent> nice!
21:33:56 <markmcclain> congrats amotoki
21:33:57 <alexxu> amtoki, congratulations
21:34:05 <danwent> also, if you guys haven't seen the new net visualization stuff from nati_ueno in grizzly horizon, it is VERY cool
21:34:20 <SumitNaiksatam> indeed! great work nachi!
21:34:21 <danwent> makes giving quantum demos much more fun.
21:34:26 <nati_ueno> danwent: Thanks! also from Hayashi from my team
21:34:43 <amotoki> that's cool
21:35:01 <amotoki> anther topic is lbaas. quantum-lbaas has been merged and minor fixed/improvements are under reivew.
21:35:32 <amotoki> we received a new bug https://bugs.launchpad.net/horizon/+bug/1153477 yesterday.
21:35:36 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1153477 in horizon "editing security group rules ends up with ValueError when Quantum secgroup is enabled" [Undecided,New]
21:36:15 <amotoki> I need to wait to post a fix until next week.
21:36:30 <amotoki> since I will take off for a week from this Wed.
21:37:00 <danwent> amotoki: ok, or maybe someone else can take a crack at it as well.
21:37:20 <amotoki> I hope so, but currently not....
21:37:28 <danwent> i will talk to arosen, as he has been making the nova security group proxy changes
21:37:40 <danwent> #topic open discussion
21:37:43 <amotoki> It's truly horizon issue.
21:37:51 <danwent> any other topics to discuss?
21:37:58 <danwent> amotoki: yup
21:38:36 <danwent> please send email to core with any new issues that may impact RC1
21:38:59 <danwent> again, I will be mostly (completely according to my wife) offline from wed :)
21:39:34 <garyk> danwent: enjoy
21:39:38 <danwent> ok, nice short meeting :)
21:39:43 <salv-orlando> I'm pretty sure she will succeed
21:39:58 <danwent> ok, thanks again for all of the reviewing in the last few days... really put us in good shape
21:39:58 <nati_ueno> +1 for danwent's wife :)
21:40:11 <danwent> nati_ueno: haha
21:40:23 <danwent> ok, talk to you all later.  have a good afternoon/evening :)
21:40:26 <danwent> #endmeeting