17:01:01 <mtreinish> #startmeeting qa
17:01:03 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Jul  2 17:01:01 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is mtreinish. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:01:04 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:01:07 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'qa'
17:01:10 <mtreinish> hi, who's here today?
17:01:16 <janonymous_> o/
17:01:41 <mtreinish> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/QATeamMeeting#Proposed_Agenda_for_July_2nd_2015_.281700_UTC.29
17:01:45 <mtreinish> ^^^ Today's agenda
17:01:51 <dtroyer> o/
17:01:57 <cdent> o/
17:02:16 <afazekas> o/
17:02:34 <mtreinish> andreaf, mkoderer, jordanP: around?
17:03:21 <mtreinish> ok, let's get started
17:03:30 <mtreinish> #topic Specs Reviews
17:03:43 <mtreinish> are there any currently open spec reviews to discuss today?
17:04:00 <mtreinish> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/qa-specs,n,z
17:04:34 <dpaterson> o/
17:04:50 <mtreinish> it looks like oomichi pused a couple of updates to approved specs, they should be quick reviews when people get a chance
17:05:08 <mtreinish> other than that it doesn't look like anything has really changed on that list
17:05:46 <dpaterson> mtreinish: I am actively working on CLI and should be pushing initial review next week
17:06:00 <mtreinish> let's move on then
17:06:03 <mtreinish> #topic Blueprints
17:06:28 <mtreinish> dpaterson: oh, I actually kinda kicked the tires on that already: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/tempest+branch:master+topic:bp/tempest-cli-improvements,n,z
17:06:39 <mtreinish> I took what you had and made the base endpoint patch
17:06:55 <mtreinish> and then started building the init and run commands on top of that
17:06:56 <dpaterson> mtreinish: cool will check it out.
17:07:40 <mtreinish> dpaterson: most of the spec like converting the existing entry-points, etc still needs to be done
17:07:48 <mtreinish> but the base entrypoint was a blocker for a few things
17:08:29 <mtreinish> ok, are there any other open bps to discuss today?
17:08:44 <mtreinish> I put one more on the agenda but I'll give everyone else a chance first :)
17:10:27 <mtreinish> well I guess no one else has a bp to discuss today :)
17:10:38 <mtreinish> the other one I wanted to bring up was the tempest plugin interface:
17:10:40 <mtreinish> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/tempest+branch:master+topic:bp/external-plugin-interface,n,z
17:10:56 <mtreinish> I have started working on patches to add it
17:11:17 <mtreinish> it's still early though I haven't bothered to test that any of it works yet. (although in my head it should)
17:11:27 <mtreinish> but that's the basic idea I was starting with
17:11:39 <mtreinish> it already differs a bit with what I had in the spec, but not too much
17:13:10 <mtreinish> the next step will be docs to explain what's there
17:13:26 <mtreinish> then I hope to prototype a plugin with mkoderer using manila
17:14:29 <mtreinish> that's really all I had for blueprints today, if there's nothing else let's move on
17:15:31 <mtreinish> #topic Devstack
17:15:45 <mtreinish> dtroyer: so what's new in devstack-land tm
17:16:08 <dtroyer> a couple of things
17:16:55 <dtroyer> the move of sahara to external plugin is in the gate ATM, as is the support for lifeless constraints in pip
17:17:49 <mtreinish> cool
17:18:00 <mtreinish> how many things to convert to plugins does that leave us with now? :)
17:18:05 <cdent> I've got the same pending for ceilometer, but I'm mildly stuck
17:18:22 <cdent> mostly because I'm ignorant, so I'm sure I can be pushed over the hump pretty easily
17:18:41 <dtroyer> four or five left
17:18:54 <mtreinish> cdent: what's the issue? although I guess we can pick this up post-meeting
17:19:04 <mtreinish> dtroyer: oh, that's less than I thought
17:19:20 <dtroyer> cdent: do you have review(s) up?
17:19:27 <cdent> Yeah, I don't think we need to talk about it now, just wanted to flag that it was in progress. There's a stack of related reviews (for grenade too): https://review.openstack.org/#/q/owner:%22chdent%22+AND+(project:openstack-dev/devstack+OR+project:openstack-dev/grenade)+AND+status:open,n,z
17:19:41 <cdent> (one of those is not related)
17:20:15 <dtroyer> also in progress is a series of patches to switch to using only Identity v3
17:20:31 <dtroyer> at some point we'll make v2 off the default
17:20:36 <cdent> \o/
17:20:49 <mtreinish> dtroyer: oh, the ones from samueldmq I thought we had landed those already, or something else?
17:21:06 <mtreinish> dtroyer: cool, that'll be great
17:21:24 <dtroyer> this is jamielennox's set
17:21:31 <mtreinish> oh, ok
17:21:32 <dtroyer> changing all of the OSC commands to use v3
17:21:37 <mtreinish> ah, gotcha
17:22:00 <dtroyer> ianw found some side effects to those too
17:22:30 <dtroyer> the last bit is sdague nuke-all-but-rabbitmq patch is up too
17:22:41 <dtroyer> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/192154/
17:22:44 <samueldmq> dtroyer: mtreinish yes, in fact, the work jamielennox is doing uses that v3 gate
17:22:55 <samueldmq> dtroyer: mtreinish patches start here I think https://review.openstack.org/#/c/186681/
17:23:09 <mtreinish> samueldmq: ah ok, it all comes full circle now :)
17:23:28 <samueldmq> :)
17:23:28 <mtreinish> dtroyer: want me to +A it?
17:23:52 <dtroyer> it has 2 +2 but I wanted to give opportunity for one last pause after the commotion it sirred up a while back
17:23:58 <dtroyer> go ahead
17:24:09 <dtroyer> since I wasn't around for most of that
17:24:32 <mtreinish> dtroyer: well I think it's been settled now
17:24:38 <mtreinish> since sdague demonstrated how simple the plugin was
17:24:48 <mtreinish> but I'm sure SpamapS will still say something :)
17:25:15 <dtroyer> that's it from me
17:25:27 <mtreinish> ok, does anyone else have anything to discuss on devstack?
17:25:28 <SpamapS> err, I said +1 didn't I?
17:25:43 <mtreinish> SpamapS: oh, heh I didn't even look
17:25:47 * cdent must dash
17:25:49 * cdent waves
17:25:50 <mtreinish> I just assumed you'd have something to say :)
17:25:54 <mtreinish> cdent: o/
17:25:57 <dtroyer> he did!  ;)
17:27:01 <mtreinish> ok, let's move on
17:27:04 <mtreinish> #topic Grenade
17:27:14 <mtreinish> dtroyer: anything new for grenade this week?
17:28:16 <dtroyer> not much action there, some cleanups and work cdent just mentioned for celio
17:28:21 <dtroyer> he grenade part of the sahara move is also in the gate
17:28:33 <mtreinish> cool
17:28:55 <dtroyer> dansmith just posted a change to do the nova flavor migration _before_ the upgrade step happens.
17:29:20 <mtreinish> I thought we were already doing that in the runs
17:29:23 <mtreinish> oh before, nm
17:29:24 <dtroyer> it's a departure from the usual flow and it's all new to me so I'd like to get some other eyes on it.  sdague in particular when he is back
17:29:42 <dansmith> it's actually part of sdague's plan AFAICT,
17:29:42 <dtroyer> maybe?  it was new to me
17:29:45 <dansmith> it just was never called from any of the plugins
17:29:52 <dansmith> and I think that's because he throws a warning if there is nothing to do
17:29:54 <mtreinish> dtroyer: ok, I'll take a look
17:29:56 <dtroyer> I haven't been paying that close of attention to it for a little while
17:30:16 <mtreinish> yeah he kinda changed the workflow a bit
17:31:01 <mtreinish> oh, I guess it's worth pointing out the multi-node grenade stuff that jogo was starting before he abandoned us is still sitting there
17:31:17 <mtreinish> we have multi-node smoke non-voting jobs on several projects now
17:31:41 <mtreinish> those were supposed to give us an idea of how far away multi-node grenade would be (from a gating perspective)
17:31:49 <mtreinish> although I don't think the jobs are working right now
17:31:56 <mtreinish> so probably not the best sign
17:32:57 <mtreinish> some one needs to pick that up since jogo kinda dropped it on the floor
17:34:26 <mtreinish> ok, is there anything else on grenade?
17:34:42 <dtroyer> not from me
17:34:54 <mtreinish> ok then let's move on
17:34:59 <mtreinish> #topic Bugs
17:35:06 <mtreinish> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/Tempest-bug-report
17:35:15 <mtreinish> does anyone have anything to discuss about bugs this week?
17:36:26 <mtreinish> I guess not :)
17:36:52 <mtreinish> then let's move on
17:37:04 <mtreinish> #topic Critical Reviews
17:37:19 <mtreinish> so does anyone have any reviews that they'd like to get additional eyes on?
17:37:27 <dpaterson> yes
17:37:42 <dpaterson> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/191978/
17:38:12 <dpaterson> dkranz had already given +2 but then I got a merge conflict from another patch so need to to another round
17:38:31 <mtreinish> dtroyer: ok, cool. test-accounts aware cleanup
17:38:37 <mtreinish> I'll take a look
17:39:25 <mtreinish> are there any others?
17:41:45 <mtreinish> ok I guess not
17:41:52 <mtreinish> I guess let's open the floor
17:41:56 <mtreinish> #topic Open Discussion
17:42:08 <mtreinish> does anyone have a topic to discuss which wasn't on the agenda?
17:44:25 <mtreinish> ok, I guess not
17:44:36 <mtreinish> if there's nothing else I guess let's end the meeting here today
17:44:38 <mtreinish> thanks everyone
17:45:00 <mtreinish> #endmeeting