02:37:46 <xinranwang> #startmeeting openstack-cyborg
02:37:46 <opendevmeet> Meeting started Thu Jul 15 02:37:46 2021 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is xinranwang. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
02:37:46 <opendevmeet> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
02:37:46 <opendevmeet> The meeting name has been set to 'openstack_cyborg'
02:37:55 <xinranwang> #topic roll call
02:38:13 <brinzhang> #info brinzhang
02:38:17 <xinranwang> #info xinranwang
02:38:47 <songwenping_> #info songwenping__
02:39:00 <xinranwang> here is our agenda,  the first topic is PTG plan. https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/CyborgTeamMeeting#Agenda
02:39:09 <xinranwang> #topic PTG plan
02:39:59 <xinranwang> the ptg registration is open now.  do you thik 6-8 UTC time(14-16 Beijing Time) is good for you
02:40:05 <brinzhang> today will free specs
02:40:23 <xinranwang> brinzhang:  yes, that's the next topic
02:40:36 <brinzhang> ah, follow you, is there some specs need to be done today?
02:41:02 <songwenping_> ptg time is ok for me
02:41:02 <xinranwang> let's talk about this later.
02:41:21 <brinzhang> I am not sure that time whether is ok for me, it too far from now
02:41:23 <xinranwang> we need have an agreement about the ptg time slot
02:41:42 <xinranwang> each time should register the slot now
02:42:05 <arthurdayne> hi all
02:42:07 <songwenping_> when ptg begin?
02:42:12 <xinranwang> yeah, I agree. it is far from now...
02:42:28 <xinranwang> Oct 18th I remember
02:42:28 <xinranwang> hi arthurdayne
02:42:31 <xinranwang> welcome to join
02:43:16 <songwenping_> it's really far
02:43:28 <xinranwang> brinzhang:  do you think the evening time is better?
02:43:31 <brinzhang> I think we can decide it as your suggestion, if there need to be changed we can try to change
02:43:50 <xinranwang> songwenping_:  yeah, I don't know why it starts such early this time.
02:44:03 <brinzhang> except the topic need to be cross many project team ^^
02:44:19 <xinranwang> brinzhang: ok, so let's make it as 6-8 UTC
02:44:39 <xinranwang> and we plan to have a cross project with nova
02:44:46 <xinranwang> to discuss the vgpu support
02:45:12 <xinranwang> which need your presence as well
02:45:20 <brinzhang> about the cross-project topic we shuold follow nova team's time, so I think it will be later for us
02:46:02 <xinranwang> I will send a maillist to nail down the time slot about cross project
02:46:30 <xinranwang> about the duration, do you think 1 hour is enough?
02:47:00 <brinzhang> the vgpu's controversial point is the trait name, may 1 hour is enough, do you think so?
02:47:33 <xinranwang> yeah, do you have any other topic want discuss with nova?
02:48:14 <brinzhang> no, and I have another nova topic, there is no time to update, so it is pending long time :(
02:48:59 <xinranwang> never mind, so we only have vgpu topic right?
02:49:11 <brinzhang> from now, I think yes
02:49:21 <xinranwang> ok, great
02:49:56 <xinranwang> #topic spec freeze day
02:50:12 <xinranwang> next topic is about spec freeze.
02:50:29 <xinranwang> the spec will be freezed at the end of today .
02:50:43 <xinranwang> for now, we have 3 pending specs.
02:51:06 <xinranwang> first one is PGPU spec
02:51:44 <xinranwang> sorry for missing the previous spec submission, I think we should address the previous comment as well.
02:51:53 <xinranwang> what do you think songwenping_ ?
02:53:01 <songwenping_> but yumeng can't review again
02:53:10 <songwenping_> it's all yument's comments
02:54:56 <xinranwang> I agree with yumeng about adding more device specific info in the spec, like data model, rp structures etc, it is good.
02:56:27 <songwenping_> ok, i'll add these infos today.
02:56:59 <brinzhang> I mean we should use the old spec, there are some discussion we can trace
02:57:10 <xinranwang> cool. thanks songwenping_  for the effort.
02:57:37 <xinranwang> brinzhang:  both are ok for me.
02:57:47 <brinzhang> so I would like you can restore the old one, and update or copy your updated info in it
02:58:26 <xinranwang> maybe no need to restore, make the old one as a reference is ok for me
02:59:14 <xinranwang> and we can add the new spec link as the abandon message in previous one.
02:59:28 <brinzhang> yes, but it looks not a good operation
02:59:55 <xinranwang> the goal is to make it well traced, you can choose the way you prefer.
03:00:21 <brinzhang> if you are all agree, I can follow ^
03:01:39 <xinranwang> brinzhang:  thanks brinzhang
03:02:28 <xinranwang> songwenping_:  seems you have dropped off, we were discussing your PGPU spec, please check the log  and let us know if any question.
03:02:46 <xinranwang> the next pending spec is pmem spec.
03:03:05 <songwenping__> no question, please go on
03:03:09 <xinranwang> is fossen around?
03:03:19 <songwenping__> he is offline
03:03:24 <songwenping__> i ping him
03:03:36 <songwenping__> he is off seat
03:03:42 <xinranwang> ok, we well discuss it when he's back.
03:03:53 <songwenping__> ok let's go on
03:03:57 <xinranwang> the third one is disable/enable api spec.
03:04:20 <xinranwang> I think this one will be postponed to next release.
03:05:04 <xinranwang> it lacks of reviews and updates.  I don't think we can land it by today...
03:05:25 <xinranwang> what do you think
03:06:56 <songwenping__> where is the spec?
03:07:33 <xinranwang> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/cyborg-specs/+/790917
03:07:42 <qiujunting> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/cyborg-specs/+/799173
03:07:58 <xinranwang> if you have time to review, I can update it today and try to land it :)
03:08:03 <xinranwang> hi qiujunting
03:08:10 <xinranwang> thanks for your spec
03:08:43 <songwenping__> i am sorry i miss this spec
03:09:11 <qiujunting> xinranwang:hi
03:09:33 <xinranwang> could you please add more details in the spec, I have some comments on it.
03:09:45 <qiujunting> I am sorry, i will update the spec later
03:09:45 <songwenping__> there are too many incoming reviews in my list.
03:10:24 <xinranwang> qiujunting:  it's ok.  so we may need to postpone the pmem spec to next release
03:10:48 <songwenping__> xinranwang: will review today, i think this is not complex.
03:11:47 <qiujunting> ok
03:12:32 <xinranwang> qiujunting:  from my perspective, we need some introduction about the pmem, which mode we use, why we don't support other mode, etc.  which kind of resouece vm treat it as, etc
03:12:52 <xinranwang> songwenping__:  ok, thansk, big core review ;)
03:13:20 <songwenping__> ^-^
03:13:38 <qiujunting> ok, i will update this to the spec
03:14:11 <xinranwang> so that's all status of the pending spec.  1 spec postponed, and 2 specs trying to be merged by today.
03:14:38 <xinranwang> qiujunting:  ok, thanks a lot
03:15:24 <xinranwang> #topic vgpu support
03:15:37 <xinranwang> the next topic is vgpu support.
03:16:01 <songwenping__> our env is not available
03:16:14 <xinranwang> why
03:16:26 <xinranwang> still the license problem?
03:16:32 <songwenping__> no
03:17:50 <songwenping__> my server cann't visit extranet
03:18:21 <songwenping__> our company is perfoming network check
03:19:05 <xinranwang> is there any tunnel permit you get access to extranet
03:19:08 <songwenping__> maybe next week the application will be passed
03:19:30 <songwenping__> this need apply
03:19:41 <xinranwang> ok, so it is a temporary problem
03:19:53 <songwenping__> i think the code is ok mainly
03:20:01 <songwenping__> i have tested before.
03:20:56 <xinranwang> yes, I remember.
03:21:06 <xinranwang> https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/nova-yoga-ptg
03:21:29 <songwenping__> we need the detailed test report.
03:21:30 <xinranwang> here is nova's etherpad, please add the vgpu discussion on it.
03:21:51 <songwenping__> ok thanks
03:23:10 <xinranwang> songwenping__: yeah. But nova has some different opinion, I think we should have an agreement first.  we can show them the test report of current implementation, it is nice to have.
03:23:26 <songwenping__> sure
03:24:50 <xinranwang> ok,cool
03:25:23 <xinranwang> #topic AoB
03:25:34 <songwenping__> so please review this patch: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/cyborg/+/790937
03:25:47 <songwenping__> and there is nothing from myside
03:26:20 <xinranwang> yeah, I was planning to discuss it during meeting, but we are running out of time. I will leave the comments
03:26:48 <xinranwang> ok, if nothing else, let's wrap up the meeing.
03:26:56 <songwenping__> yeah
03:27:15 <xinranwang> please remember we have 2 spec need review and updates by today!
03:27:21 <xinranwang> bon courage
03:28:07 <xinranwang> #endmeeting