14:16:22 <Sundar> #startmeeting openstack-cyborg
14:16:23 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Nov  7 14:16:22 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is Sundar. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:16:24 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:16:27 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'openstack_cyborg'
14:16:52 <Sundar> Sorry for the delay.
14:16:57 <Sundar> #topic Roll call
14:17:43 <Sundar> #info Sundar
14:18:23 <xinran> #info xinran
14:18:29 <xinran> Hi all
14:19:44 <Sundar> Hi Xinran
14:20:14 <Sundar> Looks like just we two and maybe Li so far
14:20:21 <Li_Liu> Hi guyss
14:20:33 <Li_Liu> Let me ask people in wechat group
14:20:38 <Sundar> Hi Li
14:20:57 <Li_Liu> Hi
14:21:22 <wangzhh> Hi
14:21:35 <wangzhh> #wangzhh
14:21:40 <Li_Liu> Sundar, Did you have the change to look at the spec I submit last weekend?
14:21:46 <wangzhh> #info wangzhh
14:21:56 <Sundar> Hi wangzhh
14:22:07 <wangzhh> Hi Sundar.
14:22:10 <Li_Liu> I know i must still miss things, but I just wanna get the thing started first
14:22:21 <Sundar> Li: Yes, I had some comments. I am still writing them. Will post by today.
14:22:29 <Li_Liu> sure, thanks a lot
14:22:49 <Li_Liu> #info Li_Liu
14:23:03 <Li_Liu> ok, let's get started on the business
14:23:24 <Li_Liu> I think CoCo is still on her way home. but we can go ahead for the meeting
14:23:33 <Li_Liu> #topic status updates
14:24:05 <Li_Liu> Hi CoCo
14:24:32 <Li_Liu> start with https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open%20project:openstack/cyborg
14:24:32 <Sundar> Storyboard has been updated for db and driver-agent
14:24:59 <Sundar> Some driver-agent tasks probably need tweaks. I'll also file some for the end-to-end workflow.
14:24:59 <Li_Liu> regarding "Add Allocation/Deallocation API"
14:25:18 <Li_Liu> still blocked right? xinran
14:25:29 <Sundar> Apart from that, folks are free to add tasks, modify them or sign up
14:25:39 <Li_Liu> Thanks  a lot Sundar :)
14:25:52 <Sundar> Li: np :)
14:25:55 <Coco_gao> Hi all
14:26:22 <Coco_gao> #info Coco_gao
14:27:00 <Li_Liu> is xinran in the meeting
14:27:46 <Coco_gao> Thanks Sundar，I will check the storyboard to sign up tomorrow.
14:28:47 <Li_Liu> Sundar, do you have any input on "Add Allocation/Deallocation API"?
14:29:18 <xinran> Yes I'm here
14:29:45 <xinran> I think we should abandon Add Allocation/Deallocation API spec, and follow Sundar's new design
14:30:24 <Li_Liu> That one I saw you adandon the other day.
14:30:29 <Li_Liu> but for https://review.openstack.org/#/c/596187/
14:30:38 <Li_Liu> do you wanna abandon it as well?
14:32:42 <shaohe_feng> #info shaohe
14:32:53 <shaohe_feng> hi all
14:32:59 <wangzhh> Hi shaohe.
14:33:02 <xinran> I think it doesn't matter, I can commit new version according to new spec. if you guys think it's better to abandon it and submit another one, that's fine
14:33:04 <Coco_gao> hi shaohe
14:33:32 <Li_Liu> xinran, it's totally up to you
14:33:37 <Coco_gao> That is depends on you
14:33:51 <shaohe_feng> yes, depends on you.
14:34:33 <Sundar> We should probably align on the db schema first. Li_Liu, do you want to talk about the db spec here ?
14:34:47 <Li_Liu> "Add gpu driver" xiao hei, your comments on this? still blocking by the new db design right?
14:35:12 <Li_Liu> Sundar, that might involve too much tech details once we start the discussion.
14:35:24 <Coco_gao> if you think there are too many diffrience  maybe you can add a new patch
14:35:26 <Li_Liu> I wanna focus on the status update first, then we can talk about it
14:35:33 <wangzhh> Yes, Li.
14:35:40 <Li_Liu> ok, thanks xiaohei
14:36:01 <Li_Liu> "Resource report to placement", xinran, you comments on this?
14:36:54 <xinran> yes
14:36:56 <Coco_gao> my patch is the same problem, still need to implement new design
14:37:39 <Li_Liu> thanks coco, got it
14:38:26 <Li_Liu> alright, I think I got most of the feedback on the patches status
14:38:44 <Li_Liu> #topic  New DB scheme planning
14:39:05 <Li_Liu> Sundar, you wanna talk about the storyboard items you created?
14:40:05 <Sundar> Li_Liu: Sure. #link https://storyboard.openstack.org/#!/project/openstack/cyborg
14:40:45 <Sundar> Storyboard has a openstack/cyborg project. We can create stories for specific features or topics, and tasks within those stories.
14:42:01 <Sundar> We can optionally create worklists and group them into boards. For example, we could create a worklist for Stein. However, i have chosen to keep it simple: Stein is just a tag on every story we want to complete in this release
14:42:22 <Sundar> The tag is a label. we can add more tags as needed
14:42:46 <Li_Liu> Regarding the DB work, I think there might be changes on those tasks. Will keep you guys posted
14:43:43 <Sundar> Time to talk about the sb spec?
14:43:45 <Sundar> *db
14:43:49 <wangzhh> Yep
14:44:30 <Sundar> I think we all agreed that the new db schema will not be PCI-specific.
14:45:18 <wangzhh> I think so.
14:46:01 <Sundar> Great. I thought we also agreed that Deployables should be the equivalent of resource providers
14:47:01 <Li_Liu> "equivalent" might not be precise, I think they are counter-part of each other
14:47:20 <Li_Liu> one in the context of Cyborg, the other one in the context of Nova
14:47:35 <Sundar> That's exactly what I meant by 'equivalent'
14:47:56 <Coco_gao> Li，is  new db spec availale now?
14:48:03 <Sundar> We had this doc which we reviewed: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XLQtvyGJeEgo3ztBQiufWLF-E7S7yGLaYrme8iUPtA0/edit
14:49:23 <Coco_gao> agree with Li
14:49:49 <Sundar> Can we please align the spec to it? Otherwise, we will have lots more discussion. The current spec shows a diagram tying Deployables to PF, VF .
14:50:03 <Li_Liu> CoCo, check this out #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/615462/
14:50:49 <Li_Liu> Sundar, I think after my spec is finalized, we should get all the pieces aligned
14:50:58 <Coco_gao> okay thank you。
14:51:18 <Sundar> Li, the spec is not as per our past discussion
14:52:06 <Sundar> Why are we still referring to Deployables as PF, VF?
14:54:16 <Li_Liu> I was just giving an example. but we can discuss it seperately. The spec is not final, comments and suggetions are welcome
14:57:09 <Sundar> OK. We can move on to other topics, if any
14:57:46 <Li_Liu> I think that's all we need to talk about. It seems the road blocker for most the stuff is the DB thing
14:58:04 <Li_Liu> so guys, please provide review and comments for https://review.openstack.org/#/c/615462/
14:58:18 <Li_Liu> Let's land this one asap
14:58:30 <xinran> ok, will review it soon
15:00:00 <Li_Liu> Thank you team. Keep claim and code one  :P
15:00:07 <Li_Liu> have a good night
15:00:33 <Li_Liu> should be "Keep claim and code on"  =_+
15:00:43 <Li_Liu> #endmeeting
15:01:20 <Li_Liu> did you guys start the meeting bot?
15:04:22 <Coco_gao> bye
15:04:43 <Coco_gao> I will review it tomorrow
15:04:58 <edleafe> Sundar started the meeting, so he has to end it
16:39:52 <fungi> #endmeeting