13:03:21 <gmann> #startmeeting nova api
13:03:22 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Oct  4 13:03:21 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gmann. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
13:03:23 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
13:03:25 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'nova_api'
13:03:37 <gmann> who is here today?
13:03:47 <takashin> o/
13:04:19 <gmann> takashin: hi
13:04:32 <gmann> i think its holiday in china so alex_xu might not be here
13:04:34 <takashin> gmann: Ho.
13:04:37 <takashin> Hi
13:05:28 <gmann> let's wait for couple of min for more people to join
13:07:18 <gmann> let's start
13:07:26 <gmann> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/508101/
13:07:40 <gmann> i pushed spec for policy removal proposal from API extensions merged things
13:08:12 <gmann> sdague: mriedem can you check this spec, should be quick - #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/508101/
13:08:55 <gmann> almost 11 policies which are  used for extensions attribute addition in response are listed for removal
13:09:11 <gmann> i added their purpose to get quick glance of those policies
13:10:12 <gmann> i will ping on nova channel also to review this.
13:10:31 <gmann> #topic open
13:10:50 <gmann> takashin: you have anything to discuss ?
13:11:19 <takashin> gmann: Yes.
13:11:42 <takashin> #link Abort Cold Migration https://review.openstack.org/#/c/334732/
13:12:18 <takashin> Could you give any advice about response code?
13:12:29 <takashin> 400 or 409
13:12:52 <gmann> takashin: what we have for live migration case?
13:13:58 <takashin> gmann: Live migration case line 82-89 in https://review.openstack.org/#/c/334732/61/specs/queens/approved/abort-cold-migration.rst
13:15:55 <gmann> takashin: i see.
13:16:28 <gmann> cdent has  point about its is more state conflict things not bad request.
13:16:51 <takashin> gmann: Yes.
13:17:12 <gmann> i need to check more detail on this.  at first look it looks like 409 is right one to return but need to check how those error are being returned.
13:18:01 <takashin> gmann: oomichi said 400 is better.
13:18:02 <gmann> takashin: at least L106, L109 are good as 409 than 400
13:19:16 <gmann> takashin: we do 409 when delete server is in lock state
13:19:59 <gmann> so if we see in that direction that it is state of resource is not in  correct type then conflict is right thing to tell
13:20:09 <gmann> but i need to check case by case
13:20:27 <gmann> takashin: is it ok if i looks each case in detail and reply on review ?
13:20:45 <takashin> gmann: Yes. Thank you.
13:21:12 <gmann> ok
13:21:43 <gmann> i do not have much for today, any thing else takashin  ?
13:21:59 <takashin> gmann: Nothing.
13:22:19 <gmann> ok let's close meeting early.
13:22:22 <gmann> thanks
13:22:26 <takashin> thanks
13:22:37 <gmann> #endmeeting