16:00:10 <gibi> #startmeeting nova
16:00:12 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Oct 22 16:00:10 2020 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gibi. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:00:13 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:00:15 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'nova'
16:00:29 <gibi> o/
16:00:56 <melwitt> o/
16:01:32 <bauzas> \o
16:01:40 <melwitt> hm, I wonder if people aren't around bc of the summit
16:02:01 <bauzas> honestly, not a lot of nova-related sessions
16:02:22 <bauzas> (i mean, today)
16:02:58 <gibi> I promise I will be quick :)
16:03:13 <gibi> #topic Bugs (stuck/critical)
16:03:23 <gibi> No Critical bugs
16:03:31 <gibi> #link 7 new untriaged bugs (+1 since the last meeting): https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bugs?search=Search&field.status=New
16:04:15 <gibi> We have checked our repos after the gerrit security incident
16:04:22 <gibi> everything seems clean
16:04:41 <gibi> any other bug we need to talk about today?
16:04:41 <bauzas> yup
16:04:49 <artom> ~o~
16:04:50 <bauzas> just one
16:04:58 <bauzas> https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bug/1900800
16:04:59 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1900800 in OpenStack Compute (nova) "VGPUs is not recreated on host reboot" [Low,Confirmed] - Assigned to Sylvain Bauza (sylvain-bauza)
16:05:04 <dansmith> o/
16:05:12 <bauzas> do we agree on removing the fact that we should recreate mdevs ?
16:05:30 <bauzas> for SR-IOV, nova doesn't recreate VFs when we reboot
16:05:38 <bauzas> so, for mdevs, we should do the same
16:05:40 <gibi> based on that nova never recreate PCI VFs I support not to try to recreate mdevs
16:06:06 <bauzas> agreed with gibi, anyone having another opinion ?
16:06:09 <melwitt> sounds like it makes sense
16:06:09 <bauzas> 1.
16:06:11 <bauzas> 2.
16:06:11 <artom> IIRC our doc even has steps to manually create VFs, no?
16:06:29 <bauzas> artom: i dunno
16:06:39 <gibi> bauzas: after your change does nova will never create mdevs? or created them at boot but never recreate them?
16:06:49 <bauzas> gibi: we could create mdevs
16:06:59 <bauzas> but not recreate them if you reboot
16:07:23 <bauzas> that's simple
16:07:35 <gibi> so a fully matching solution with SRIOV would be not to even create mdevs in the first place
16:08:01 <bauzas> well, then it would be a bad behaviour
16:08:16 <sean-k-mooney> well mdevs and vf are not really the same
16:08:22 <bauzas> anyway, given we have questions, let's stop to discuss it now
16:08:41 <bauzas> let's say we have still open questions so we could discuss it in -nova tomorrow
16:08:48 <bauzas> for the moment, that's it
16:08:54 <bauzas> no consensus, fine with me
16:08:55 * gibi will be on PTO tomorrow
16:09:05 <bauzas> okay, then on PTG
16:09:09 <gibi> cool
16:09:11 <bauzas> will add it
16:09:15 <bauzas> moving on
16:09:17 <gibi> thanks
16:09:20 <gibi> any other bugs?
16:09:25 <bauzas> (/me didn't wanted to take more than 3 mins for it)
16:10:16 <gibi> #topic Release Planning
16:10:24 <gibi> Wallaby Milestone 1 is in early December
16:10:37 <gibi> so lets review specs and prepare for the PTG
16:11:02 <gibi> any other note about the Wallaby release?
16:11:18 <bauzas> just that wallaby-1 will be my birthday ?
16:11:24 <bauzas> :p
16:11:37 <gibi> :)
16:11:50 <gibi> #topic Stable Branches
16:12:06 <gibi> elod told me that he has no news since last week
16:12:40 <gibi> anybody else has news?
16:13:01 <gibi> #topic Sub/related team Highlights
16:13:07 <gibi> API (gmann)
16:14:14 <bauzas> I guess he's not around
16:14:18 <gibi> Libvirt (bauzas)
16:14:26 <bauzas> #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/nova-libvirt-subteam
16:14:29 <bauzas> nothing to report
16:14:33 <gibi> thanks
16:14:39 <gibi> ?
16:14:40 <bauzas> if folks have libvirt changes ^
16:14:50 <gibi> #topic PTG and Forum planning
16:14:57 <gibi> Next week is PTG # link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/nova-wallaby-ptg
16:15:04 <bauzas> ...and Forum ? man, you're late :p
16:15:08 <gibi> sorry :/
16:15:14 <gibi> :)
16:15:28 <gibi> We will use the Zoom room as we learned last time that meetpad is not available from China.
16:15:53 <gibi> I did some small reorg on the etherpad to move related items closed together
16:16:15 <gibi> and today I had to recover the contet after somebody translated parts of the page to chines
16:17:07 <gibi> any questions about next week?
16:17:41 <sean-k-mooney> we are doign everything over monday-wednesday?
16:17:51 <sean-k-mooney> when are the cross project sessions?
16:18:04 <gibi> Wednesday - Friday
16:18:10 <gibi> corss projects are on Wednesday
16:18:11 <sean-k-mooney> ah ok cool
16:18:58 <gibi> I assume Monday - Tuesday is common stuff like release, oslo, qa
16:19:06 <sean-k-mooney> so the ptg is not starting monday
16:19:21 <sean-k-mooney> oh ya maybe we should check i guess
16:20:22 <melwitt> I think gibi means wed is our nova cross-project day where we meet with other teams on nova stuff
16:20:57 <gibi> melwitt: correct
16:21:01 <sean-k-mooney> yep wed-friday are the nova ptg days with wednesday where we are socail and talk to others
16:21:01 <melwitt> mon-tues is the general cross project days as usual
16:21:16 <gibi> here is the full ptg schedule https://object-storage-ca-ymq-1.vexxhost.net/swift/v1/6e4619c416ff4bd19e1c087f27a43eea/www-assets-prod/Uploads/PTG2-Oct26-30-2020-Schedule-1.pdf
16:21:57 <bauzas> mon-tues is for other WGs and SIGs
16:22:28 <bauzas> people could find interest in some of the tracks
16:22:45 <sean-k-mooney> that not what it look like most project are doing
16:22:56 <sean-k-mooney> neutron and cinder are havign a 5 day ptg
16:23:13 <bauzas> ah indeed
16:23:47 <gibi> #topic Open discussion
16:23:50 <gibi> nothing on the agenda
16:23:58 <gibi> anything else in the room?
16:24:14 <sean-k-mooney> not from me
16:24:19 <bauzas> I'm thirsty
16:24:47 <gibi> then thanks for joining. See you next week on the PTG
16:24:53 <sean-k-mooney> o/
16:24:56 <gibi> #endmeeting