15:00:44 #startmeeting neutron_l3 15:00:45 Meeting started Thu Apr 21 15:00:44 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is mlavalle. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:47 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:49 The meeting name has been set to 'neutron_l3' 15:01:02 #chair tidwellr_ 15:01:03 Current chairs: mlavalle tidwellr_ 15:01:11 #chair carl_baldwin 15:01:12 Current chairs: carl_baldwin mlavalle tidwellr_ 15:01:55 Agenda for today is here: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Neutron-L3-Subteam#Agenda 15:02:03 hi 15:02:18 hi 15:02:21 #topic Announcements 15:02:47 Looking forward to see you all next week in Austin! 15:02:47 o/ 15:03:20 We will not have this meeting next week 15:03:44 We will resume at the same tine on May 5th 15:04:11 Other annoucements from the team? 15:04:48 If not, let's dive in... 15:04:55 #topic Bugs 15:05:26 We gained 1 bug this week, but it seems its solution is shared with another bug... 15:05:48 first up is https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1543094 15:05:49 Launchpad bug 1543094 in neutron "[Pluggable IPAM] DB exceeded retry limit (RetryRequest) on create_router call" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Ryan Tidwell (ryan-tidwell) 15:06:28 Since there are 3 related patchsets to this bug, I added a note last night pointing to the 2 fixes under review in Gerrit 15:06:50 tidwellr_: any comments? 15:06:53 thanks for doing that 15:07:14 there are still 1 or 2 unit tests that I'm working through 15:08:02 the unit test changes are in the first patch, the next 2 in the chain should be ready to go as soon as this get ironed out 15:09:17 any other comments? 15:09:28 no, nothing else 15:09:43 Great work tidwellr_ 15:09:57 ok, next up is https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1572474 15:09:58 Launchpad bug 1572474 in neutron "[Pluggable IPAM] Deadlock on simultaneous update subnet and ip allocation from subnet" [High,Confirmed] - Assigned to Pavel Bondar (pasha117) 15:10:28 This one was added yesterday by pavel_bondar. It seems that the fix to the bug we reviewed previously will fix this one 15:10:37 pavel_bondar: is that correct? 15:10:41 interesting 15:10:58 yeah, tidwellr_fix will fix it entirely 15:11:06 because of removing availability ranges 15:11:22 yay! 15:11:27 I'm now on the hook for 2 of these bugs, now I'm really scrambling :) 15:11:41 but additionally to that I plan to upload for review backportable version of the fix for it 15:12:13 pavel_bondar: that would be good, what I'm doing is not backportable :) 15:12:22 thanks for that pavel_bondar ! 15:13:13 any other comments? 15:13:20 no 15:13:41 Next up is https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1564335 15:13:43 Launchpad bug 1564335 in neutron " [Pluggable IPAM] delete subnet in ml2 plugin does not comply with pluggable ipam (deletes ip allocations directly from db)" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Pavel Bondar (pasha117) 15:13:58 pavel_bondar is a busy man today :-) 15:14:26 :) 15:14:34 there is a partial fix for that https://review.openstack.org/#/c/300984/ 15:14:39 has one +2 15:14:52 pavel_bondar: does it need to be rebased? 15:15:22 mlavalle: may be 15:15:33 but as I see it is not in merge conflict state 15:15:55 so may be ok 15:16:13 and another part of fix to cover SLAAC allocations is still in my todo 15:16:17 If it isn't in merge conflict, don't rebase. 15:17:16 any more comments? 15:17:48 here is one nit, so probably I'll rebase and address nit 15:18:07 for 300984 15:18:22 that it for this one 15:18:26 pavel_bondar: ping me when you do. 15:18:37 carl_baldwin: sure 15:19:41 ok, let's move on 15:20:11 The last one in the list this week is https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1566383 15:20:13 Launchpad bug 1566383 in neutron "The creation fip does not endure restarting of l3-agent" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Brian Haley (brian-haley) 15:20:42 This one is assigned to haleyb, but he might be off this week 15:20:57 per his comments in the bug 15:21:37 any other comments from the team? 15:22:17 any other bugs from the team? 15:22:40 ok, we are done with bugs this week 15:22:49 #topic Routed Networks 15:23:09 Hi 15:23:22 For me, things are progressing again. 15:24:02 My patches now create a service plugin. 15:24:38 Yesterday, I made a little more progress on the subnet - segment association and I plan to move on to finishing up the IPAM changes. 15:25:12 ... along with deferred IP allocation and implementing the port without IP address BP. 15:25:36 But, I now have to get to summit prep stuff that I've been putting off. 15:25:53 Anything from you, mlavalle ? Or, anyone else? 15:26:15 I am working on the SR-IOV mechanism driver 15:26:45 The idea is for it to have the same interface as the other in-tree agent based mechanism drivers 15:27:22 mlavalle: I'll hunt you down next week, I'm curious about that 15:27:41 With that, we will be able to call all of them in a uniform manner in the host segments mapping 15:28:11 and on the Nova side, we have a conversation pending with jaypipes 15:28:27 I made sure he is aware of the latest revision to the spec 15:28:39 tidwellr_: sure :-) 15:28:41 mlavalle, dansmith, carl_baldwin: can we do that conversation today at 1pm EST? 15:29:04 jaypipes: I am fine at that time 15:29:30 jaypipes: I dunno, is your tennis outfit clean? 15:29:40 dansmith: yup. 15:29:44 then yes 15:29:50 mlavalle: mlavalle at gmail? 15:29:51 that should work 15:31:03 that's it from me for routed networks 15:31:13 carl_baldwin, dansmith, mlavalle: invite sent. 15:31:51 jaypipes, dansmith: thanks! 15:32:36 ok moving on... 15:32:52 #topic BGP Dynamic Routing 15:33:00 hi 15:33:02 hi 15:33:13 New repo is finally UP ;) 15:33:19 https://github.com/openstack/neutron-dynamic-routing 15:33:34 nice, I didn't realize that 15:33:36 ++ 15:33:59 vikram: i think it is a surprise 15:34:20 I was going to say I had nothing to add today, but I'm going to take a look and see what it takes to begin moving code 15:34:25 Na_Zhu: ;) 15:34:42 vikram: i see the new repo does not include neutronclient code 15:34:55 tidwellr_: We need a solid plan for moving the things fater 15:34:58 *faster 15:35:14 Na_Zhu: It needs lot of work 15:35:28 Na_Zhu: It just created with previous commits 15:35:45 vikram: i can help you, i am doing that part 15:35:46 Na_Zhu: It will fail miserably 15:35:53 yes, I hope to catch up with mickeys next week and talk about some things 15:36:06 tidwellr_: +1 15:36:09 tidwellr_: that would be good 15:36:19 tidwellr_: Let's have a plan and distribute the work 15:36:21 Yes, I will be in Austin and we should catch up! 15:36:28 tidwellr_: We need to do a lot 15:36:49 mickeys: I'd love to, preferred email? 15:36:49 thanks for your support Na_Zhu 15:37:04 tidwellr: mickeys has proposal about adding bgp evpn, but first of all, we have to make the moving work done 15:37:07 emspiege@us.ibm.com 15:37:09 i will miss you guy's ;( 15:37:17 won't be there in Austin 15:37:44 tidwellr_: Will it be possible to include me in the discussion 15:38:05 tidwellr_: hangout/skype 15:38:07 I'll see what we can do, we might be able to run a hangout 15:38:23 tidwellr_: thanks 15:38:45 vikram: +2 powers on the repo are all set correctly? 15:39:12 tidwellr_: I have asked infra team to add 15:39:17 ok 15:39:19 tidwellr_: Will be done soon 15:39:38 alright, well that's all I had 15:40:08 anything else vikram? 15:40:08 I am also done 15:40:18 one thing 15:40:18 ok, moving on... 15:40:25 not yet :-) 15:40:29 ;( 15:40:39 do we need a separate irc for the new project 15:40:44 or we will continue here? 15:41:45 vikram: tidwellr: can we discuss the plan after the meeting ? 15:42:17 Maybe that depends on you specific plan going forwward 15:42:49 ok.. let's then continue for sometime and then we can decide 15:42:52 let's keep it on the agenda for now and see how things progress 15:43:11 anything else? 15:43:26 I am done now ;) 15:43:32 :-) 15:43:46 #topic Open Discussion 15:44:07 any topics from the team? 15:44:50 vikram: about the works of bgp move out, can we discuss with tidwellr now? 15:44:53 I am close with getting clean jenkins pass for switch to pluggable ipam migration 15:44:59 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/181023/ 15:45:59 pavel_bondar: thanks 15:46:57 Now it incorporates 3 additional fixes to make clean pass possible with pluggable ipam by default, so reviews are welcome 15:47:25 pavel_bondar has been a busy! 15:47:32 yeah 15:47:36 yeah:) 15:48:22 finally, it time to finish all the pluggable ipam stuff 15:49:25 ok, I think we are done for this week 15:49:39 we'll met again on May 5th 15:49:47 safe travels to Austin 15:49:55 #endmeeting