21:00:24 <mlavalle> #startmeeting networking 21:00:25 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Mar 5 21:00:24 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is mlavalle. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 21:00:26 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 21:00:28 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'networking' 21:01:10 <mlavalle> hi there! 21:01:15 <haleyb> o/ 21:01:30 <amotoki> hi (still from Dublin) 21:01:40 <haleyb> :( 21:01:42 <slaweq_> hi 21:01:53 <mlavalle> Today's agenda is here: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Network/Meetings#Bugs_and_Gate_issues 21:01:54 <hongbin> o/ 21:02:15 <mlavalle> Before going on, please give a round of applause to amotoki 21:02:24 * mlavalle clap clap clap 21:02:34 * slaweq_ clap clap :) 21:02:55 <mlavalle> He is stranded in Dublin and yet found the time to make it to today's meeting 21:03:26 <mlavalle> amotoki: good luck tomorrow with your flight 21:03:28 <amotoki> yeah, Aer Lingus assigned me tomorrow flight :) 21:04:09 <mlavalle> #topic Announcements 21:04:42 <mlavalle> Our next milestone is Rocky-1, on April 16 - 20 21:05:08 <mlavalle> As usual, it will senak up on us before we realize it :-) 21:05:54 <mlavalle> The entire Rocky schedule can be found here: https://releases.openstack.org/rocky/schedule.html 21:06:40 <mlavalle> You can find the Rocky PTG etherpad here: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron-ptg-rocky 21:07:03 <mlavalle> I will send a message to the ML with a summary of our sessions over the next few days 21:07:21 <mlavalle> but in the meantime you can read the notes in the therpad 21:07:26 <mlavalle> etherpad^^^^ 21:08:30 <mlavalle> Finally, those of you who attended to the Queens or the Rocky PTG shoud have received an email from the foundation with a code to register at no cost for the Vancouver Summit 21:08:51 <mlavalle> If you are planning to be there, register and make your hotel reservation 21:08:57 <mlavalle> I just did earlier today 21:09:22 <mlavalle> Any other announcements? 21:09:26 <pasuder> OT: sorry for being late, I found out to late, that it is no diff channel, went through http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/networking/2018/networking.2018-03-05-21.00.log.txt - amazing amotoki clap clap :) 21:09:44 <amotoki> pasuder: hehe :) 21:10:22 <mlavalle> #topic Blueprints 21:11:13 <mlavalle> This week, as part of my duties of sumarizing the PTG for the team, I will create the dashboard in Launchpad to track the blueprints that we will implement in Rocky 21:12:03 <mlavalle> In the meantime, does anyone have a blueprint that needs to be discussed today? 21:13:00 <mlavalle> ok, we will have the Launchpad dashboard ready for next week's meeting 21:13:13 <mlavalle> #topic Community Goals 21:13:43 <mlavalle> amotoki had the excellent idea to have a specific section in the weekly meeting to track the community goals 21:14:12 <amotoki> i just did what we discussed in the PTG 21:14:36 <mlavalle> In Queens we completed the split of Tempest to Tempest plugin 21:14:53 <mlavalle> But we missed the policy in code goal 21:15:15 <mlavalle> and also the wsgi support from Pike 21:15:25 <mlavalle> so we need to get caught up 21:15:43 <mlavalle> and implememt the two for Rocky: 21:16:27 <mlavalle> mox3 removal which is not a problem in the Neutron code, but needs to be addressed in the python neutron client 21:16:34 <mlavalle> amotoki: right^^^^? 21:16:54 <amotoki> mlavalle: mainly yes. 21:17:05 <amotoki> I filed bug 1753504 which describes more detail 21:17:06 <openstack> bug 1753504 in Neutron VPNaaS dashboard "Remove mox/mox3 usage from testing" [High,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1753504 - Assigned to Akihiro Motoki (amotoki) 21:17:25 <amotoki> four projects are affected. 21:17:48 <amotoki> two are horizon plugins. the other two are neutronclient and CLI of networking-midonet 21:18:50 <mlavalle> The other goal in Rocky is Enable mutable configuration 21:19:29 <mlavalle> amotoki: you are working on mox3 and policy in code. Do we need volunteers for the others? 21:19:58 <amotoki> mlavalle: yes + mox3 removal needs more volunteers 21:20:29 <mlavalle> amotoki: ok, thanks for the update and the help :-) 21:20:40 <boden> hi, I had posted some code for the ‘policy in code’ effort.. was hoping that I or my other team member could help with that one? 21:20:59 <slaweq_> mlavalle: about this mutable configuration, is it for all parameters or only "debug" option? 21:21:11 <amotoki> boden: thanks. I will check it later this week after back to japan 21:21:40 <slaweq_> AFAIR some emails there was some idea to make it only mutable for "debug" option but I'm not sure 21:22:07 <amotoki> slaweq_: you are right. https://governance.openstack.org/tc/goals/rocky/enable-mutable-configuration.html#completion-criteria 21:22:33 <mlavalle> slaweq_: https://governance.openstack.org/tc/goals/rocky/enable-mutable-configuration.html 21:22:49 <mlavalle> LOL, amotoki posted the same thing 21:23:29 <amotoki> for Rocky. DEBUG is the minimal criteria 21:23:38 <slaweq_> ok, so I think neutron already supports toggle of debug in runtime (but I might be wrong and it has to be checked) 21:24:13 * mlavalle added the goal description to the meeting wiki 21:25:10 <mlavalle> anything else on community goals for today? 21:25:50 <mlavalle> ok, moving on 21:25:58 <mlavalle> #topic Bugs 21:26:35 <mlavalle> slaweq_ was the busg deputy last week 21:26:46 <mlavalle> This is his summary: http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2018-March/127925.html 21:26:55 <slaweq_> yes 21:27:07 <slaweq_> basically it wasn't "hard" week for me 21:27:36 <slaweq_> but I wanted to ask about this bug for lbaas - should we do something with it or just close it and as autor to report it on storyboard? 21:27:46 <slaweq_> as octavia uses storyboard already 21:28:26 <amotoki> slaweq_: I chatted octavia bug on launchpad with johnsom a few week ago 21:28:35 <mlavalle> johnsom: how do you want us to handle this: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1753380 21:28:36 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1753380 in neutron "Lbaasv2 Update listener failed" [Undecided,New] 21:28:36 <mlavalle> ? 21:28:42 <amotoki> hopefully all bugs are filed on storyboard 21:29:17 <amotoki> if we forward lbaas bugs to octavia launchpad, he usually checks them and re-file them if needed 21:29:31 <mlavalle> ok, we can do that 21:30:01 <slaweq_> ok, so I will report it on storyboard also, fine? 21:30:08 <amotoki> so I think our best option is to let bug authors know octavia storyboard and file bugs on storyboard 21:30:18 <slaweq_> amotoki: ok 21:30:19 <amotoki> slaweq_: we can 21:30:23 <mlavalle> that's fine slaweq_ 21:30:23 <slaweq_> :) 21:30:52 <amotoki> we can file a new story to https://storyboard.openstack.org/#!/project_group/70 21:30:53 <slaweq_> so, from other things, there is one critical and one high bugs without assignee 21:31:10 <slaweq_> one is about fwaas v2: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1753507 21:31:11 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1753507 in neutron "FWaaS V2: Upgrade Pike->Queen causes error" [Critical,New] 21:31:30 <slaweq_> and second is for vlan type driver in ml2: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1743425 21:31:31 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1743425 in neutron "Changes to VLAN mapping results in "is not mapped" error" [High,Confirmed] 21:32:23 <mlavalle> the FWaaS bug was reported xgerman_ 21:32:43 <mlavalle> so the we can consider that the FWaaS team is aware of it 21:33:02 <mlavalle> for the VLAN one, I will take a look later today 21:33:03 <slaweq_> yes, but I wanted to mention it here also 21:33:09 <slaweq_> ok, thx 21:33:13 <mlavalle> or tomorrow morning 21:33:30 <amotoki> I just added queens-backport-potential to the official tags 21:33:32 <mlavalle> slaweq_: understood about the FWaaS one 21:34:00 <slaweq_> ok, so that's all from my side 21:34:17 <mlavalle> This week, haleyb is our designated bigs deputy 21:34:29 <slaweq_> bigs deputy? :D 21:34:30 <haleyb> yes, ready and waiting 21:34:59 <pasuder> slaweq: ribs deputy? :D 21:35:02 <haleyb> mlavalle: i did notice armax was listed in a couple of weeks, should we still give him work? :) 21:35:10 * haleyb likes ribs, mmmmm 21:35:38 <mlavalle> LOL 21:35:51 <armax> bug deputy? 21:35:57 <mlavalle> haleyb: good point. I'll talk to him on Wednesday and see what he says 21:36:04 <mlavalle> armax: yes 21:36:06 <haleyb> armax: was just asking if you still wanted to be in bug deputy rotation 21:36:15 <armax> let me check my calendar 21:36:22 <haleyb> week of March 19th 21:38:03 <mlavalle> In the mean time, please note that I added pasuder to the end of the roster 21:38:13 <pasuder> Yeap, thx for mlavalle 21:38:17 <slaweq_> welcome pasuder :) 21:38:26 <mlavalle> pasuder: please make sure your name is correct there 21:38:34 <haleyb> we can always update roster later armax, no hurries 21:38:42 <armax> OK 21:38:42 <pasuder> Correct mlavalle 21:38:47 <pasuder> Thx! 21:39:18 <pasuder> I will read docs regarding bug deputy and ping slaweq and mlavalle if I will have questions 21:39:30 <mlavalle> slaweq_: if you have a chance, please spend some time with pasuder face to face walking him through the bugs triage process 21:39:44 <slaweq_> mlavalle: sure 21:39:55 <pasuder> thx slaweq 21:40:18 <mlavalle> pasuder: welcome to the team :-) We are glad and excited to have you around! 21:40:42 <pasuder> Thank you! Glad to met you on PTG Dublin 21:41:04 <mlavalle> Anything else regarding bugs? 21:41:40 <mlavalle> ok, let's move on 21:41:53 <mlavalle> #topic Docs 21:42:53 <mlavalle> boden: any updates on docs? 21:43:13 <boden> mlavalle: nothing.. I haven’t seen a PTG summary come out yet 21:43:24 <mlavalle> ok, cool 21:43:30 <mlavalle> let's move on 21:43:45 <mlavalle> #topic CLI / SDK 21:43:58 * mlavalle notes the header of this section has changed :-) 21:44:14 <amotoki> yeah, I changed it :) 21:44:32 <amotoki> in the PTG, we agreed to move forward OpenStackSDK migration. 21:44:49 <amotoki> I will check the current status this or next week 21:45:02 <amotoki> so that we can gather volunteers 21:45:36 <slaweq_> amotoki: I can help with this so ping me if You will have something :) 21:45:50 <amotoki> slaweq_: thanks. 21:46:04 <mlavalle> oh yeah, slaweq_ is an expert in client stuff 21:46:09 <amotoki> our team has core both in SDK and OSC 21:46:19 <amotoki> so we can easily move things forward :) 21:46:27 <slaweq_> yes, I have +2 power in SDK repo :) 21:46:42 <mlavalle> ok, elt's gang up :-) 21:46:52 <mlavalle> let's^^^ 21:47:27 <mlavalle> ok, anything else on this topic? 21:47:30 <amotoki> for attribute extension support, we didn't discussed it much in PTG. If boden or other folks would like to have some support in OSC, we can discuss it next week or later. 21:47:43 <amotoki> *didn't discuss* 21:47:50 <boden> amotoki: yes please connect when you get time 21:48:00 <amotoki> boden: sure 21:48:22 <mlavalle> moving on 21:48:32 <mlavalle> #topic neutron-lib 21:49:39 <mlavalle> boden: during the PTG we took time to review the 2 specs you added to the etherpad 21:49:48 <mlavalle> overall, they looked good to me 21:50:11 <boden> mlavalle ok cool, I’ve done some investigation on them too, but can digress later :) 21:50:24 <mlavalle> and at least for one of them, others also took a look 21:50:51 <mlavalle> you evn got a +1 from ajo 21:51:03 <mlavalle> which is no small feat ;-) 21:51:44 <mlavalle> any other updates on neutron-lib? 21:52:15 <boden> just regular stuff.. some consumption patches out there in neutron and other projects when folks get time 21:53:00 <mlavalle> ok, cool 21:53:14 <mlavalle> moving on 21:53:22 <mlavalle> #topic On demand agenda 21:53:33 <mlavalle> Any other topics we shoud discuss today? 21:54:25 <mlavalle> Ok team, thanks for your attendance 21:54:28 <amotoki> I see "Typo fixing patches" section in the meeting agenda 21:54:37 <amotoki> is it discussed last week? 21:54:53 <mlavalle> it was discussed last meeting 21:55:02 <mlavalle> I'll remove it from the wiki 21:55:34 <amotoki> okay, I didn't check the last meeting minute :( 21:55:59 <mlavalle> amotoki: I will keep my fingers crossed and have my wife do the same thing until I know you are in Tokyo ;-) 21:56:07 <mlavalle> Have a safe trip 21:56:16 <amotoki> thanks 21:56:20 <slaweq_> yeah, good luck amotoki :) 21:56:31 <mlavalle> #endmeeting