14:00:36 #startmeeting networking 14:00:37 Meeting started Tue Jun 6 14:00:36 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is jlibosva. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:00:38 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 14:00:40 The meeting name has been set to 'networking' 14:00:43 Hello everyone! 14:00:57 hello 14:01:03 o/ 14:01:08 hi 14:01:08 hello 14:01:11 hi all 14:01:17 #topic Announcements 14:01:41 I still haven't caught up with what's going on in upstream after my leave, so I have no announcements 14:01:44 hi 14:01:46 does anybody want to announce anything? 14:02:36 seems like the answer is 'no', so let's move on 14:02:44 #topic Blueprints 14:03:33 does anybody have a work on a blueprint that is blocked or wants to discuss anything here? 14:03:51 jlibosva: hi 14:03:58 annp: hi :) 14:04:05 jlibosva: I have one. https://review.openstack.org/#/c/415817/ this patch needs your eye to go to forward. 14:04:47 jlibosva: Could you please take a look and leave your comment? thanks in advance. 14:05:59 annp: it seems you already have two reviews from core members 14:06:04 annp: is there anything in particular? 14:07:06 jlibosva: yes, but i need to your opinion related to api endpoint. 14:07:52 annp: ok, I'll read and I'll also try to ping other relevant team members 14:07:59 annp: thanks for bringing this up 14:08:14 In the point of API, it needs Akihiro's comment. And also I'll review again. 14:08:22 hichihara: thanks 14:08:32 Akihiro already has some comments there 14:08:46 jlibosva, hichihara: thank you. 14:08:52 I also have one bp I'd like to bring up 14:08:54 https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1580880 14:08:56 Launchpad bug 1580880 in neutron "[RFE] Distributed Portbinding for all port types" [Wishlist,In progress] - Assigned to Jakub Libosvar (libosvar) 14:09:29 this is something I started working on - I have two patches that don't get attention although the rfe is scheduled for p2 14:10:00 jlibosva: do you have links handy? 14:10:03 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/414251/ and https://review.openstack.org/#/c/469949/ 14:10:10 oh, I see I have a comment on the first one :) 14:10:12 ahhh, you read my mind 14:10:12 I missed that 14:10:29 mlavalle: ;) I could find them for a while 14:10:56 anyways, if anybody has some "spare time" to review, I'd really appreciate that 14:11:15 * mlavalle will do his best toi find time ;-) 14:11:25 I don't really have anything to discuss about that rfe, so if anybody has other blueprint to highlight, then please speak up :) 14:11:29 mlavalle: thanks! 14:12:09 jlibosva: I'll check the patch. I already found some questions. 14:12:38 oh, and Pike-2 milestone is set to 8 June 2017 which is this week. :) 14:12:47 hichihara: thanks, I'll read them after the meeting 14:12:57 if there is no other blueprint to discuss, we can move on 14:13:04 #topic Bugs and gate failures 14:13:07 (hi everyone, sorry for being late) 14:13:23 hichihara: were you bug deputy for last week? 14:13:29 tmorin1: o/ 14:13:31 yes 14:13:53 was there anything interesting worth telling the team? 14:13:58 nothing much from me but I found https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1696098 before meeting 14:13:59 Launchpad bug 1696098 in neutron "Race in deleting ports during Tempest Runs" [Critical,Confirmed] 14:14:50 We should fix it ASAP :( 14:15:06 yeah, I also planned to bring this up, the failure rate is high there 14:15:36 hichihara, jlibosva I filed a similar bug yesterday on the Nova side 14:15:44 mlavalle: do you have a link handy? 14:15:50 hang on 14:16:08 Is it nova bug not neutron? 14:16:29 I'll get back up to you in a biot 14:18:52 mlavalle: maybe if you think they are related, it would be good to comment on the LP to link to the "nova one" 14:18:57 jlibosva, hichihara https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bug/1696006 14:18:59 Launchpad bug 1696006 in OpenStack Compute (nova) "Libvirt fails to detach network interface with Linux bridge" [Undecided,New] 14:19:02 mlavalle: thanks 14:19:16 based on my analysis, this is really a nova bug 14:19:28 oh, is that only a linuxbridge job that gets affected? 14:19:29 I had time to dig in the logs 14:19:42 I see 14:19:44 and the way I see evidence it pojnts to a problem in libvirt 14:20:20 after the meeting I can take a look at the bug hichihara pointed out and see if it is the same thing 14:20:46 mlavalle: Thank you 14:20:53 thanks, the example in bug posted by hichihara also points to LB job 14:21:13 lots of hist in kibana since May 31st 14:21:18 hits^^^ 14:21:35 that's when it suddenly started 14:21:36 was there some libvirt update on the nodes? 14:21:53 don't know. I filed the bug last night. 14:22:16 ok, I'll try to find that information after meeting 14:22:39 mlavalle: hichihara thanks for updates :) 14:22:44 :-) 14:22:45 does anybody have other bug to dicuss? 14:23:52 ok, let's find a deputy for the next week 14:23:56 I think we don't have anybody 14:24:03 is there any volunteer? 14:24:18 maybe it's for this week? 14:24:30 hichihara: yeah, right 14:25:06 if noone wants next week, I can take it 14:25:16 I want to do it! 14:25:25 8-) 14:25:33 jlibosva: I'm curious what is the status of https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1626010 14:25:34 Launchpad bug 1626010 in neutron "OVS Firewall cannot handle non unique MACs" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Jakub Libosvar (libosvar) 14:25:34 trevormc: ok! it's yours then :) 14:25:44 trevormc: +1 14:25:45 trevormc: can you please update wiki with your name? 14:25:49 will do 14:25:52 trevormc: thanks 14:26:26 tmorin1: there is a patch to dvr needed which will move some dvr flows to later tables 14:26:32 make sure I get approved the bug supervisors group this time 14:27:01 tmorin1: also the "basic" ovsfw flow table needs to be moved - currently the bug is blocked by the fact dvr doesn't work with ovs firewall. I'm a dvr noob so it takes me time now 14:27:07 jlibosva: is more detailed info available somewhere ? 14:27:34 tmorin1: good point, maybe there is not. I'll probably report a new bug 14:27:49 tmorin1: thanks for bringing this up 14:27:53 jlibosva: ok, thanks 14:28:43 I don't think we have a docs liaison so there is probably nobody to update about docs 14:28:46 #topic Transition to OSC 14:28:53 amotoki: hi, are you here? 14:28:55 jlibosva: I am the docs liaison now 14:29:02 mlavalle: oh, you are? sorry :) 14:29:21 jlibosva: np, let's finish the OSC topic and we get back to docs 14:29:22 mlavalle: missed the good news, we can do docs after osc 14:30:21 seems amotoki is not here 14:30:40 #topic Docs 14:30:43 mlavalle: hi :) 14:31:00 Last Thursday I attended my first docs team meeting 14:31:07 they get together every 2 weeks 14:31:20 Tried to catch up on what needs to be done 14:31:37 We have a list of docs bugs that need to be addressed: 14:31:52 #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bugs?field.tag=networking-guide 14:32:06 I encourage the team to take a look 14:32:32 amotoki has been doing a great job tackling the critical bug at the top of the list 14:32:51 and he is active with the docs team. he offered to share the load with me 14:32:58 yes, i think just the diagrams are left 14:33:12 haleyb: correct 14:33:19 haleyb: I think so. They should all have the source files in the /figures folder 14:33:22 * asettle waves 14:33:45 asettle and the docs team appreciate the networking guide a lot 14:33:55 Definitely a priority for us :) 14:34:04 We just don't have the people/knowledge to work in it right now :( 14:34:05 so we should keep a close eye on it 14:34:43 John Davidge put together an improvement plan for the guide here: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/networking-guide-improvements 14:35:03 I am going to review it and encourgae the team to do the same 14:35:39 jlibosva: that's the update for the team this week 14:35:45 mlavalle: great, thanks for updates 14:36:04 it looks like you jumped into it pretty quickly :) 14:36:07 * mlavalle waves back at asettle 14:36:23 let's move to the neutron-lib 14:36:26 #topic Neutron-lib and planned neutron refactoring 14:36:32 boden: hi! 14:36:37 hi 14:36:52 boden: do you have any updates re. neutron-lib? 14:36:57 I have a few FYI/quick things 14:37:28 First, as I’m sure you’ve seen, there are a number of rehoming patches out for review for neutron-lib as well as a number of consumption patches in neutron and others 14:37:41 I don’t see a reason to dig into these, unless anyone has questions/comments? 14:38:38 boden: seems like no questions here :) 14:38:42 Otherwise, from a networking-ovn perspective, we’ve pretty much rehomed all the “low hanging” fruit and now have some fun things to decouple 14:39:05 ahhh fun time yaaay! 14:39:17 that said, I will likely be creating at least 2 specs (for review) on how we might proceed decoupling these (DB and ML2Plugin in particular) 14:39:31 that’s all I have here in neutron-lib world 14:40:24 boden: you mean breaking up ml2 plugin? 14:41:06 jlibosva, well more about how can we decouple it so that consumers can still import/use it without importing neutron… today it appears pretty “tied into” neutron internals 14:41:21 It's for ML2 drivers of neutron stadium? 14:41:59 boden: ok, I'll wait for the spec 14:42:10 http://codesearch.openstack.org/?q=from%20neutron%5C.plugins%5C.ml2%20import%20plugin&i=nope&files=&repos= 14:42:24 yes, lets discuss in the spec; maybe its an easy problem :) 14:42:59 * mlavalle likes boden's optimism ;-) 14:43:23 mlavalle: wishful thinking, but likely not realistic ! :) 14:43:53 boden: wow, I see. Thanks for updates :) 14:44:02 #topic open discussion 14:44:57 Who's looking at splitting neutron-server into uwsgi and rpc? 14:44:58 does anybody have a topic he/she would like to discuss? 14:46:05 ebbex: can you be more specific? 14:46:47 it's a release-goal for pike, to be able to deploy a wsgi file for the api part. 14:47:48 ebbex: ah, that one. I know ihrachys|afk did some work on it during Atlanta ptg 14:48:07 neutron-rpc-server is a dead command as is. kevinbenton had a look at a patch we submitted some time ago to make it run, thanks btw :) 14:48:35 there is a bug for it: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1666779 14:48:36 Launchpad bug 1666779 in neutron "Expose neutron API via a WSGI script" [Wishlist,In progress] - Assigned to Ihar Hrachyshka (ihar-hrachyshka) 14:49:00 Yep, and this one: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1687896 14:49:01 Launchpad bug 1687896 in neutron "neutron-rpc-server fails to start on configuration that works under neutron-server" [Undecided,In progress] - Assigned to Sean McCully (sean-mccully) 14:50:04 Just hoping it gets more attention, that's all. 14:50:27 ebbex: thanks for bringing this up to our attention :) 14:51:04 I'm not sure we should be running rpc server separately - but maybe I just lack knowledge of wsgi 14:51:48 is there any other topic? 14:51:56 or we could end the meeting earlier 14:52:33 seems like no topic :) 14:52:39 thanks everyone for coming! 14:52:42 #endmeeting