21:00:57 <kevinbenton> #startmeeting networking
21:00:58 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Apr  3 21:00:57 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is kevinbenton. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
21:00:59 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
21:01:02 <haleyb> hi
21:01:03 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'networking'
21:01:53 <kevinbenton> #topic announcements
21:02:19 <electrocucaracha> o/
21:02:23 <sindhu> hi
21:02:47 <kevinbenton> the openstack summit is about a month away from now
21:03:51 <asingh_> hello
21:03:58 <kevinbenton> there will be a component of it called "The Forum" that is relevant to developers
21:04:00 <kevinbenton> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Forum
21:04:25 <kevinbenton> to get feedback from users and operators
21:04:40 <mlavalle> that's a good idea
21:04:48 <kevinbenton> the topics people are interested in have been submitted here: http://forumtopics.openstack.org/
21:05:40 <kevinbenton> we will find out soon which of those are selected
21:05:47 <kevinbenton> by the forum selection committee
21:06:04 <kevinbenton> and then we will know which neutron relevant sections have been picked
21:06:26 <kevinbenton> so people at the summit can plan to attend
21:06:40 <kevinbenton> and people that can't make it can offer feedback ahead of time
21:07:30 <kevinbenton> that's all for the forum
21:07:43 <kevinbenton> does anyone have any other announcements?
21:08:50 <electrocucaracha> this is the firs time using that approach right?
21:09:00 <kevinbenton> yes
21:09:20 <kevinbenton> since there wont' be a design summit
21:09:30 <kevinbenton> this is the way operators are supposed to get feedback to users
21:09:32 <electrocucaracha> ok, let's give a try
21:09:44 <kevinbenton> sorry (to developers)
21:09:50 <electrocucaracha> finally more DevOps culture
21:10:07 <kevinbenton> ok, moving on
21:10:11 <kevinbenton> #topic neutron-lib
21:10:44 <kevinbenton> boden can't make it to this meeting but he left me this message
21:11:07 <kevinbenton> (a) we need to cleanup the periodic failures before the␜ 1.4.0 release can happen (see ^^).. (b) there are some core neutron rehoming patches that could use some review lovin: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/neutron-lib+status:open+topic:bp/neutron-lib-networking-ovn
21:12:40 <kevinbenton> so it sounds like there are some failures that need to be fixed before we can release 1.4.0
21:13:06 <dasm> boden took care of one of failures inside midonet, althought now it's failing in other place ;)
21:13:12 <dasm> and odl is almost done.
21:13:24 <dasm> when we'll be past that, we will release new neutron-lib
21:13:32 <kevinbenton> dasm: ok, so these are just failures in stadium projects and not the main repo?
21:13:38 <dasm> both failures seem to be unrelated to neutron-lib, but better have it covered
21:13:48 <dasm> kevinbenton: yes. just midonet and odl
21:13:56 <kevinbenton> dasm: ok, thanks
21:14:40 <kevinbenton> #topic bugs
21:15:00 <kevinbenton> amotoki is going to be bug deputy it looks like this week
21:15:23 <kevinbenton> haleyb: do you have any bugs from last week that need some attention?
21:15:23 <haleyb> i was deputy last week
21:16:07 <haleyb> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1677729
21:16:07 <haleyb> i'm wondering if the work on that is done
21:16:07 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1677729 in neutron "some tests failing after merge of "Skip DHCP agent query in provisioning block setup"" [Undecided,New]
21:16:14 <haleyb> there's the bot
21:16:41 <kevinbenton> haleyb: oh, yes
21:16:51 <kevinbenton> haleyb: it's been temporarily fixed with a revert
21:17:21 <haleyb> ok, i'll leave open then ?
21:17:22 <kevinbenton> haleyb: but we need to get fullstack fixed so we can remove it again
21:17:25 <kevinbenton> haleyb: yeah
21:17:37 <kevinbenton> haleyb: and assign to Jakub
21:17:49 <kevinbenton> haleyb: he was going to look into adding the dhcp agent to fullstack
21:17:52 <haleyb> kevinbenton: always a good idea when someone isn't here :)
21:17:59 <mlavalle> LOL
21:18:00 <dasm> haleyb: ;)
21:18:01 <kevinbenton> haleyb: yes :)
21:18:21 <haleyb> this was another one that i have not triaged, but was also port race condition
21:18:23 <haleyb> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1677131
21:18:23 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1677131 in neutron "race condition between interface detach and port delete" [Undecided,New]
21:18:28 <haleyb> it's on mitaka
21:19:33 <haleyb> kevinbenton: i was wondering if that rang a bell with you
21:19:54 <haleyb> it's not a common scenarios meddling with your own ports
21:20:53 <kevinbenton> haleyb: i'll dig into that one afterwards
21:21:00 <kevinbenton> haleyb: haven't heard of that issue before
21:21:23 <haleyb> ok, nothing else critical that i saw
21:21:29 <kevinbenton> haleyb: ack
21:22:07 <kevinbenton> anyone have any other bugs that need reviews or attention?
21:22:54 <kevinbenton> ok
21:23:00 <kevinbenton> #topic blueprints
21:23:17 <manjeets_> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/410101/
21:23:40 <kevinbenton> ah
21:23:43 <manjeets_> this is will fix the issue of qos_policy with mechanism_driver so review will help
21:24:10 <kevinbenton> just need another core review for that
21:24:10 <kevinbenton> mlavalle: ^^
21:24:10 <mlavalle> kevinbenton: will take alook
21:24:21 <manjeets_> thanks mlavalle kevinbenton
21:24:21 <kevinbenton> for blueprints, is anyone with an approved blueprint blocked by anything?
21:24:37 <kevinbenton> e.g. not getting reviews, dependent work not moving, etc
21:25:51 <kevinbenton> ok
21:26:04 <kevinbenton> #topic docs
21:26:43 <princenana> kevinbenton: I have a question retaed to this https://review.openstack.org/#/c/383673/
21:26:51 <princenana> kevinbenton: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/348947/
21:26:52 <kevinbenton> princenana: sure
21:27:18 <sindhu> kevinbenton: need reviews for https://review.openstack.org/#/c/347867
21:27:21 <princenana> armax: proposed a slightly different approach to what's been implemented
21:28:10 <sindhu> kevinbenton: in general for the config options refactoring patches
21:28:14 <princenana> Can you check out his comments on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/383673/ kevinbenton
21:28:32 <kevinbenton> princenana: yes, i'll make a note to review this later today
21:29:02 <kevinbenton> sindhu: ack, i'll add it to my queue
21:29:13 <kevinbenton> haleyb: can you take a look at it as well?
21:29:14 <princenana> ok kevinbenton
21:29:20 <sindhu> kevinbenton: great, thank you :)
21:29:23 <kevinbenton> haleyb: looks mainly agent related
21:29:47 <haleyb> kevinbenton: ack
21:30:08 <kevinbenton> I don't see john-davidge online
21:30:25 <kevinbenton> so unless someone else can give use a docs update we'll just move on
21:31:21 <kevinbenton> #topic OSC
21:31:38 <kevinbenton> anyone online that can give us an update here?
21:31:55 <kevinbenton> i see last week amotoki just announced that things were progressing steadily
21:32:03 <kevinbenton> so i assume that's still the the case
21:32:41 <kevinbenton> #topic open discussion
21:33:18 <kevinbenton> ok, anyone have anything else to bring up?
21:33:18 <mlavalle> yeah, I want to update on the Upstream Institute
21:33:18 <kevinbenton> otherwise we might have a nice short meeting this week :)
21:33:18 <kevinbenton> mlavalle: sure
21:33:28 <dasm> mlavalle: "Upstream Institute"?
21:33:29 <mlavalle> We are going to have a Neutron on-boarding room in Boston
21:33:59 <mlavalle> The Upstream Institute is the training that takes place for new comers the weekend before the summit
21:34:19 <dasm> ack
21:34:19 <asingh_> As sindhu mentioned earlier, it would be great to have these patches merged https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/neutron+branch:master+topic:bug/1563069
21:34:42 <mlavalle> and after that initial training, new contributors are encouraged to go to the projects on-boarding rooms, during the week
21:34:50 <mlavalle> ours will be on Wednesday
21:35:07 <mlavalle> I'll put together an agenda and submit for the team to review
21:35:34 <mlavalle> I would like some of our team memebers come and see hello to the newbies
21:35:35 <mlavalle> say hello^^^
21:35:39 <blancos> I had a question regarding Neutron policy: Is the Neutron policy.json meant to be an exhaustive list of Neutron policies? And is Neutron planning on moving to policy in code any time soon?
21:35:48 <mlavalle> that was it, a quick update :-)
21:36:20 <kevinbenton> mlavalle: thanks. assuming I can go i'll try to show up  :)
21:37:05 <mlavalle> that would be great, to have the PTL there :-)
21:37:05 <kevinbenton> mlavalle: when things get a little closer we should put together an etherpad of neutron dev attendees
21:37:06 <mlavalle> yeah, let's do it
21:37:06 <kevinbenton> mlavalle: just for general coordination
21:37:13 <kevinbenton> i'll add that to my todo for the next couple of weeks
21:37:20 <mlavalle> ++
21:37:45 <kevinbenton> blancos: there isn't a plan to move it into code yet
21:38:15 <kevinbenton> blancos: it's been discussed before occasionally
21:38:15 <kevinbenton> blancos: usually at design summits
21:39:07 <kevinbenton> blancos: but it's one of those things where it's going to be a lot of work and it will inevitably break someone's deployment
21:39:17 <kevinbenton> blancos: so it's been lower priority
21:40:11 <blancos> kevinbenton: I see, thank you :)
21:40:35 <kevinbenton> for context, what blancos is talking about is getting rid of the /etc/neutron/policy.json file and having all of those permissions directly in the neutron code
21:40:43 <kevinbenton> so operators wouldn't be able to modify it
21:41:36 <kevinbenton> ok, if that's all
21:41:46 <kevinbenton> we can take 18 minutes back
21:41:52 <mlavalle> yaay!
21:41:54 <dasm> thanks yall
21:41:55 <kevinbenton> have a nice day!
21:41:59 <dasanind> thank you
21:42:02 <kevinbenton> #endmeeting