14:00:50 <igordcard> #startmeeting network_common_flow_classifier
14:00:51 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Aug  8 14:00:50 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is igordcard. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:52 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:54 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'network_common_flow_classifier'
14:01:00 <igordcard> hello all
14:01:14 <bcafarel> o/
14:01:53 <igordcard> let's wait a few minutes
14:02:21 <igordcard> I know david needs a few mins
14:03:51 <bcafarel> I should prepare the coffee earlier
14:04:35 <igordcard> yes maybe we should move the coffee discussion topic to the beginning
14:05:18 <davidsha> Hi, sorry I'm late
14:05:28 <bcafarel> hi davidsha
14:05:36 <davidsha> bcafarel: Hey :)
14:05:36 <igordcard> hi davidsha
14:05:46 <igordcard> davidsha: is thaynara joining?
14:06:01 <davidsha> igordcard: I don't think so.
14:06:23 <davidsha> But I can give updates for her, if thats ok?
14:06:56 <igordcard> davidsha: of course
14:06:58 <igordcard> let's tart
14:07:19 <davidsha> kk
14:07:30 <igordcard> agenda: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Neutron/CommonClassificationFramework#Discussion_Topic_8_August_2017
14:07:36 <igordcard> #topic CCF v0 - first wave of code (update)
14:08:08 <igordcard> links:
14:08:12 <igordcard> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/445577/
14:08:18 <igordcard> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/487182/
14:08:46 <igordcard> davidsha: we wanted to submit final v0 around the time of this meeting, what's the status?
14:09:16 <bcafarel> is the poc code needed for v0?
14:09:53 <davidsha> igordcard: At the moment it's 90% done, myself and Thaynara are just working on getting the oslo versioned objects to maintain the API set out in the spec.
14:11:20 <davidsha> We do still need to add tests, but for V0 we're almost ready to submit the patch
14:12:11 <davidsha> It will be up within the next 2 hours or early tomorrow.
14:12:24 <igordcard> thanks davidsha
14:12:38 <igordcard> #topic PTG plans
14:13:09 <igordcard> as I mentioned in the past, won't be attending the PTG, but davidsha may
14:13:36 <davidsha> I'm just waiting for travel approval...
14:13:42 <bcafarel> davidsha: we're counting on you :)
14:13:49 <davidsha> :O
14:14:11 <igordcard> there was a PTG etherpad, I can't quite find it now, someone has it handy?
14:14:19 <davidsha> bcafarel: you won't be attending?
14:15:02 <bcafarel> davidsha: nope, too low in the budget queue :(
14:15:07 <igordcard> I only find this one: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron-ptg-queens
14:15:24 <davidsha> bcafarel: sorry to hear :(
14:15:28 <igordcard> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron-queens-ptg
14:15:38 <bcafarel> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/PTG/Queens/Etherpads
14:15:43 <igordcard> bcafarel: yap
14:16:14 <igordcard> I'll add the CCF to the etherpad
14:17:20 <igordcard> for queens release I see 2 main goals: - v1 - and the start of at least 1 consuming service
14:18:08 <igordcard> any other things aiming at queens?
14:19:21 <davidsha> igordcard: I'm planning on introducing it into the QoS extension for the dscp marking rule. There is an existing RFE that I files for it so I'll resurrect it.
14:19:39 <igordcard> davidsha: link?
14:20:02 <davidsha> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1527671
14:20:02 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1527671 in neutron "[RFE] traffic classification in Neutron QoS" [Wishlist,Expired] - Assigned to David Shaughnessy (david-shaughnessy)
14:20:09 <bcafarel> so full working version + one official consumer?
14:21:00 <davidsha> bcafarel: I'll need to see how the drivers meeting will react, but yes.
14:21:15 <igordcard> davidsha: thanks; keep the RFE expired as it seems to overlap with existing RFE
14:21:25 <igordcard> davidsha: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1476527
14:21:25 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1476527 in neutron "[RFE] Add common classifier resource" [Wishlist,Triaged] - Assigned to Igor Duarte Cardoso (igordcard)
14:21:35 <igordcard> davidsha: perhaps create new RFE for QoS consumption of CCF?
14:22:00 <igordcard> davidsha: apologies, I misread the title
14:22:04 <davidsha> igordcard: :P
14:22:40 <igordcard> davidsha: it's specifically for QoS so should be resurrected
14:23:23 <igordcard> great
14:23:28 <igordcard> any other goals for Queens?
14:23:33 <igordcard> bcafarel: networking-sfc?
14:25:07 <bcafarel> igordcard: yes, I was thinking about it
14:25:18 <igordcard> yushiro, reedip_brb, xgerman_ , interested in integrating with CCF for Queens?
14:25:48 <igordcard> (for meeting log readers, they are from the FWaaS team)
14:26:35 <reedip_brb> back .. hi
14:26:42 <davidsha> reedip_brb: hey
14:27:12 <reedip_brb> I was looking at the spec.. Now I would like to try out the PoC from davidsha :)
14:28:05 <davidsha> reedip_brb: We'll have updated code up within the next 24 hours, patch set is here: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/487182/
14:28:09 <reedip_brb> yushiro : let us discuss the same in the FWaaS Open discussion today, else lets put it as an agenda in the next meeting so that it is discussed
14:28:29 <bcafarel> igordcard: at least getting the ball rolling with networking-sfc would be great, count me in for that part
14:29:00 <igordcard> thanks reedip_brb
14:29:04 <igordcard> thanks bcafarel
14:29:25 <davidsha> reedip_: let us know if there are any protocols you guys need added and we'll try to get them in.
14:30:34 <reedip_> davidsha : I think the protocols which matter to neutron , and might also impact other projects is in https://github.com/openstack/neutron-lib/blob/99d4f1f35f8d915f48bfaa677f690b29bc4b0dbe/neutron_lib/constants.py#L202
14:30:36 <yushiro> igordcard, Hi, long time no see :)  Sounds good but let me check RFE and discuss in advance.
14:30:42 <yushiro> reedip_, OK.
14:30:59 <igordcard> anyhow, plan is to have merged v0 by end of Pike, so then consuming services can easily import the code and hack a little bit with it
14:31:08 <yushiro> I'm joining fwaas channel and chair now.  sorry for late response.
14:31:31 <igordcard> yushiro: thank you, also check the following links:
14:31:50 <davidsha> reedip_: ack, I have that book marked!
14:32:00 <igordcard> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/neutron/+spec/common-classification-framework
14:32:06 <igordcard> https://specs.openstack.org/openstack/neutron-specs/specs/pike/common-classification-framework.html
14:32:07 <reedip_> davidsha :) gr8
14:32:09 <igordcard> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Neutron/CommonClassificationFramework
14:32:43 <igordcard> yushiro: no problem, wonderful multi-tasking skills!
14:34:10 <igordcard> I think this is all, I'll add the ccf to the etherpad and probably send an email too, then I'll leave it to davidsha to find the best time and folks at the PTG itself
14:34:32 <yushiro> igordcard, aha, thanks for your link :)
14:35:02 <yushiro> igordcard, I'm single processor :)
14:35:23 <igordcard> I might join remotely if there's any etherpad drafting about the ccf
14:35:29 <reedip_> yushiro : that means you work dedicatedly :P
14:36:19 <igordcard> yushiro: reedip_: eheh
14:36:28 <igordcard> moving on
14:36:31 <igordcard> #topic Open discussion
14:36:47 * igordcard looks at bcafarel's mug
14:37:06 <igordcard> anything else we should be discussing?
14:37:19 <bcafarel> I emptied it a bit when we were waiting for the others :)
14:38:24 <davidsha> I mentioned it briefly, but getting a list of protocols that projects need us to support for them to consume would be good. do we still have the list of projects that participated at the ptg?
14:38:26 <bcafarel> davidsha: it was just a quick look an hour ago, but I commented on the v0 code, there was still probably "old" code in place, I suppose it will be cleaned with v1?
14:38:45 <igordcard> davidsha: yes: https://specs.openstack.org/openstack/neutron-specs/specs/pike/common-classification-framework.html
14:39:14 <davidsha> bcafarel: I noticed, I'll incorporate it into the patch coming soon.
14:39:24 <igordcard> we should have a ubiquitous enough list of classification types, but it will be waste of energy to conquer the world
14:39:58 <igordcard> fringe protocols should be requested (and maybe submitted) by interested consuming services
14:41:16 <igordcard> davidsha: bcafarel: about that; this patch is to be abandoned correct? https://review.openstack.org/#/c/445577/
14:41:34 <bcafarel> davidsha: thanks :)
14:42:02 <davidsha> igordcard: Thats abandoned, I'll do that now.
14:42:33 <bcafarel> it will be clearer for people that start/stumble on ccf
14:43:20 <igordcard> thanks davidsha
14:43:28 <igordcard> I don't have anything else
14:44:31 <igordcard> alright, seems that we're done
14:44:33 <bcafarel> all good here too (and out of coffee anyway)
14:44:36 <igordcard> thank you all for joining
14:44:44 <davidsha> Thanks!
14:45:02 <igordcard> au revoir
14:45:12 <igordcard> #endmeeting