04:07:13 <tpatil> #startmeeting  Masakari
04:07:14 <rkmrHonjo> sorry, thanks.
04:07:14 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Oct  3 04:07:13 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is tpatil. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
04:07:15 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
04:07:17 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'masakari'
04:07:46 <tpatil> #topic High Priority Items
04:08:29 <tpatil> Anyone has any high priority items for discussions?
04:09:35 <tpatil> Ok, let's move on to next topic
04:09:50 <tpatil> #topic Bugs (stuck/critical)
04:10:41 <sagara> it seems no stuck/critical bugs
04:10:48 <tpatil> Yes
04:10:53 <tpatil> let's move on to next topic
04:11:00 <rkmrHonjo> ok.
04:11:10 <tpatil> #topic Discussion Points
04:11:22 <tpatil> Application for become OpenStack oficial project:
04:11:34 <tpatil> # link : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/500118/
04:11:34 <patchbot> patch 500118 - governance - Masakari - Instances High Availability Service
04:12:04 <tpatil> This patch is not merged yet, but there are several +2, hopefully it will be merged soon
04:12:18 <tpatil> Install guide document
04:12:49 <tpatil> Abhishek will use the official project templates to document installation guide.
04:13:16 <rkmrHonjo> Takahara wrote documents about masakari-monitors. Please review it.
04:13:18 <rkmrHonjo> #link  https://review.openstack.org/#/c/500118/
04:13:19 <patchbot> patch 500118 - governance - Masakari - Instances High Availability Service
04:13:38 <rkmrHonjo> Sorry...
04:13:41 <rkmrHonjo> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/489095/
04:13:41 <patchbot> patch 489095 - masakari-monitors - Masakari-monitors operator's documentation
04:13:52 <tpatil> Sure
04:13:57 <rkmrHonjo> tpatil: thanks.
04:14:18 <tpatil> Next item : recovery method customization
04:14:42 <tpatil> I need to discuss two options to add mistral actions
04:14:59 <tpatil> 1. Add all required actions in masakari repo
04:15:22 <tpatil> 2. Create a new repo
04:15:58 <tpatil> with option #1, wherever mistral executor is running, operator will need to install masakari package, is it acceptable to operators?
04:16:14 <tpatil> option #2 is straight forward
04:17:15 <tpatil> The new repo will be a library (masakari-mistral-actions) which should be installed on mistral executor nodes
04:17:34 <tpatil> Do you have guys any comments on option#1?
04:18:07 <tpatil> I have seen option #1 is used in tacker project
04:19:19 <rkmrHonjo> tpatil: In #1, we can divide package. So I think that operators will accept the install the package e.g. "masakari-mistral-action.deb".
04:19:33 <tpatil> # link : https://github.com/openstack/tacker/tree/master/tacker/mistral
04:20:04 <tpatil> rkmrHonjo: Sounds like a good option
04:21:29 <tpatil> Next topic: Find hosts without specifying segments
04:22:05 <tpatil> # link : Find hosts without specifying segments
04:22:14 <tpatil> # link : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/506986/
04:22:15 <patchbot> patch 506986 - masakari-specs - Find segment by specifying host
04:22:18 <rkmrHonjo> I wait the workflow +1 for this spec.
04:22:34 <rkmrHonjo> Sampath said that he'd like to review this.
04:23:14 <rkmrHonjo> tpatil: And, thank you for reviewing the implementation. Takahara will create a new patch according to your comments.
04:23:33 <tpatil> rkmrHonjo: Let's follow-up with Sampath and get this specs merged soon
04:24:27 <tpatil> Next item: Queens Work items
04:24:39 <rkmrHonjo> tpatil: ok, I say it to samp.
04:24:56 <tpatil> rkmrHonjo: Thanks
04:24:57 <tpatil> # link: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/masakari-queens-workitems
04:25:28 <tpatil> Add ssl support to devstack
04:25:57 <tpatil> # link : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/508419/
04:25:57 <patchbot> patch 508419 - masakari - Add ssl support for masakari plugin
04:26:05 <tpatil> I have +2 on this patch
04:26:08 <tpatil> Please review
04:26:40 <rkmrHonjo> ok, I review it.
04:26:57 <tpatil> rkmrHonjo: Thanks
04:28:02 <tpatil> Anyone wants to talk about any tems from Queens work items?
04:29:14 <rkmrHonjo> no.
04:29:17 <sagara> tpatil: no
04:29:29 <Dinesh_Bhor> no
04:29:30 <tpatil> Moving to next item
04:29:47 <tpatil> BM HA (ironic+nova)
04:30:44 <tpatil> I think Sampath is working on this item, let's discuss on this topic in the next meeting
04:30:57 <tpatil> Next item: OpenStack Proposal Bot updates
04:31:24 <tpatil> I see there are several bot patches up for review
04:32:04 <tpatil> If Jenkins is passing, should we approve these patches as is?
04:32:27 <Dinesh_Bhor> I think yes,
04:33:20 <Dinesh_Bhor> If the updated lib is not breaking anything in masakari then it's safe to merge it
04:33:56 <rkmrHonjo> sorry, I left these patches. ok, I review it.
04:34:32 <tpatil> rkmrHonjo: Thanks, please review this one, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/477955/, I have already voted +2
04:34:33 <patchbot> patch 477955 - masakari - Updated from global requirements
04:34:47 <rkmrHonjo> tpatil: sure.
04:35:09 <tpatil> #topic AOB
04:35:23 <tpatil> Migrate from launchpad to Storyboard
04:36:08 <tpatil> I don't have any update about this item. Sampath should take this decision
04:37:09 <rkmrHonjo> Yeah. I think that we should research & understand storyboard, and plan to migrating.
04:39:23 <tpatil> I think this item is low priority, anyone finds time for research, please do so and update their findings in the meeting
04:39:39 <Dinesh_Bhor> sure
04:39:43 <tpatil> #topic Ansible support for Masakari
04:39:53 <rkmrHonjo> tpatil: agree.
04:41:41 <tpatil> I haven't worked on Ansible, so don't have any info at this moment
04:41:57 <Dinesh_Bhor> okay
04:42:21 <rkmrHonjo> me too.
04:43:16 <tpatil> Ansible deploys OpenStack, so it looks that we need to enhance ansible to build compute node HA setup
04:44:03 <diablo_rojo_phon> tpatil: WRT migrating to Storyboard. Here's some documentation. https://docs.openstack.org/infra/storyboard/migration.html
04:44:54 <tpatil> diablo_rojo_phon: Thanks for the pointers
04:44:55 <diablo_rojo_phon> Sorry to interrupt :) I just work on Storyboard and am helping facilitate the migration. If you have questions feel free to drop in #storyboard
04:45:08 <rkmrHonjo> diablo_rojo_phon:thanks, I'll read it.
04:45:15 <diablo_rojo_phon> tpatil: no problem :)
04:46:23 <tpatil> I will discuss with Sampath about Ansible topic and let's decide how we should go ahead about this item in the next meeting
04:46:51 <rkmrHonjo> tpatil: Sure.
04:47:53 <tpatil> That brings us to the end of this meeting, Anyone has any other topics for discussions?
04:48:00 <rkmrHonjo> no.
04:48:01 <Dinesh_Bhor> yes, I have one AOB today
04:48:15 <Dinesh_Bhor> Platform9 guys are using masakari in their production. So they are interested in the support of multinode masakari-engine.
04:48:28 <Dinesh_Bhor> For this feature there is a new etcd3 service for distributed key-value storage which we can use directly or the tooz lib which internally uses etcd3.
04:48:48 <Dinesh_Bhor> this will be a good addition to masakari
04:49:21 <Dinesh_Bhor> I started exploring etcd.
04:49:29 <tpatil> Dinesh_Bhor: use etcd3 for storing locks info used for synchronization?
04:49:38 <Dinesh_Bhor> tpatil: yes
04:49:58 <Dinesh_Bhor> The newer version tooz uses etcd
04:51:04 <tpatil> Dinesh_Bhor: Yes, definitely, let's use tooz library for multiple node installation.
04:51:24 <Dinesh_Bhor> tpatil: Okay,
04:52:58 <tpatil> Let's end the meeting
04:53:39 <sagara> thanks, bye
04:53:47 <rkmrHonjo> bye
04:53:54 <tpatil> #endmeeting