04:00:42 #startmeeting masakari 04:00:43 Meeting started Tue Sep 26 04:00:42 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is samP. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 04:00:44 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 04:00:47 The meeting name has been set to 'masakari' 04:00:54 Hi all.. 04:01:01 o/ 04:01:06 Hi all 04:01:44 I took a week vacation after PTG...:p 04:01:56 great 04:01:59 Hope you all doing good.. 04:02:20 Let's start.. 04:02:31 #topic Bugs 04:02:42 any bugs to discuss/ 04:03:26 seems not. if any, please bring them up in AOB at end of the meeting 04:03:29 https://bugs.launchpad.net/masakari/+bug/1715486 04:03:30 Launchpad bug 1715486 in oslo.versionedobjects "py35 tests failing due to iso8601 module change" [Undecided,In progress] - Assigned to zhangyangyang (zhangyangyang) 04:03:34 Are you working on this bug? 04:04:17 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/501515/ 04:04:17 patch 501515 - masakari - iso8601.is8601.Utc No Longer Exists 04:04:32 ^^ here is the patch 04:04:44 ok 04:05:03 thanks, I'll review it after that. 04:05:11 tpatil: rkmrHonjo thanks 04:05:21 Any other items? 04:06:05 OK then, 04:06:14 #topic Discussion points 04:06:30 (1) Application for become OpenStack official project 04:07:19 voting in progress. Now we have 4 tc votes and hopefully it will be approved within week or 2 04:08:02 Other members from Suse, RedHat also gave there +1 for proposal. 04:08:21 samP: Nice work!!! 04:08:27 good news 04:08:45 In PTG, we presented the proposal to TC and had one questing about diversity of the core team 04:09:05 current core team is only from NTT. 04:09:42 So, I asked Adam (Suse), whether he can join the core team and contribute to Masakari 04:10:40 Answer was, Yes. I will propose him to core team in ML. Please cast your vote. Also, if you have any comment or objections please post them to ML 04:10:52 Sure 04:11:18 ok. 04:11:51 And, freezer-dr do some what similar things to masakari 04:12:02 #link https://github.com/openstack/freezer-dr freezer-dr 04:13:05 In PTG, me and Adam had discussion with Freezer PTL and he agree to take look at Masakari. 04:13:18 Discussion will continue.. 04:13:57 Currently, this has no effect on TC review process. 04:14:23 Both the project goals are almost similar, can both projects exists in parallel? 04:14:42 And masakari is part of self-healing SIG 04:15:34 #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2017-September/122215.html self-healing SIG 04:15:48 please read ^^ for what is self-healing SIG 04:16:10 I got it. 04:16:35 That's all form my side about TC proposal, any questions or comments? 04:17:04 Or you may ask later... 04:17:07 tpatil wrote his question. 04:17:34 rkmrHonjo: Got it..sorry 04:17:48 Can both projects (freezer-dr and masakari) exists in parallel? 04:18:43 tpatil: Thierry has discussed this with Freezer team. Still no question raised on this. 04:19:23 tpatil: However, Freezer could have similar functions to provide site to site DR 04:20:01 While Masakri maily focus on instance HA in single site. 04:20:43 We will discuss this wit Freezer team. 04:20:51 samP: Sure 04:21:42 This discussion will continue on self-healing SIG 04:21:56 I will share if any updates on this. 04:22:04 samP: Thank you 04:22:14 #topic Install guide document 04:22:17 samP: I will watch this mailing thread 04:22:24 tpatil: thanks 04:22:52 For this topic, I must apologize to abhishekk 04:23:18 samP: no problem 04:23:59 He proposed docs with official project schema, and we decide not to use it, because we are not an official project 04:24:18 However, in 1 or 2 weeks we are 04:24:48 I guess we can easily revert it back, 04:25:03 Then we are able to use official project schema 04:25:36 abhishekk: Have you made any additional changes to the docs contents other than scheme changes? 04:25:44 abhishekk: thanks. shall we wait until the TC diction? 04:25:58 tpatil: yes, whole structure has changed 04:26:13 samP: yes we can wait till then 04:26:47 abhishekk: ok 04:27:05 abhishekk: thanks 04:27:44 #topic recovery method customization 04:28:09 tpatil: abhishekk any update on this? 04:28:32 samP:abhishekk discussed this topic in PTG 04:28:37 # link : https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/mistral-ptg-queens 04:29:20 samP: Our understanding was correct. There is a need to change setup.cfg, call mistral-db populate command and restart executor nodes 04:29:52 samP: check line #72-#77 from above etherpad url 04:31:49 tpatil: Got it. but what does it mean "generate OpenStack actions based on openstacklient" ? 04:32:29 abhishekk: Any input on this point? 04:32:39 Generate action upon the request from openstack client? 04:33:12 samP: IMO, it could be about mapping methods exposed in openstackclient with the actions 04:33:39 this means, instead of calling actions of individual clients it will use openstack client 04:34:05 tpatil: correct 04:34:11 tpatil: abhishekk thanks 04:35:17 So, how does it effect to our implementation? 04:35:36 sorry for poor understanding on this. 04:35:42 samP: I think we should create a new repository to add custom actions required by Masakari 04:36:03 samP: it will be a library which should be installed on executor nodes 04:36:39 on masakari side, we will build a yaml to execute workflow 04:36:57 tpatil: now I remember.. 04:37:10 tpatil: got it.. 04:38:05 samP abhishekk has proposed the specs 04:38:08 # link : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/458023/ 04:38:08 patch 458023 - masakari-specs - Recovery method customization 04:38:26 If end user wants use masakari and mistral, then user needs to install this lib 04:38:37 we need to provide builds for this lib 04:38:55 tpatil: thanks, I will review the spec 04:39:02 samP: User means operator 04:39:07 tpatil: yes 04:39:40 Does any other project use same method? 04:40:18 Dinesh_Bhor: You have come across one project which uses same approach, correct? 04:40:24 samP: yes, tripleO, tripleO-common 04:40:35 glance_store is a library used by glance and glare 04:40:52 Dinesh_Bhor: abhishekk thanks 04:40:59 #link https://github.com/openstack/tripleo-common 04:41:06 do they maintain their own lib for this? 04:41:18 yes 04:42:13 abhishekk: Dinesh_Bhor: tpatil: thanks. I will take a look on those info 04:42:20 samP: glance_store does not use mistral but its a library and is used by two different projects 04:42:51 abhishekk: yep..got it.. 04:43:36 May be we nee to maintain the masakari driver for openstack-resource-agents also.. 04:44:01 I will update on this later.. 04:44:51 samP: I remember there was some discussion long back that openstack-resource-agents will provide a pluggable driver to send the notifications 04:44:58 samP: Are you talking about the same? 04:45:12 tpatil: yes.. same topic 04:45:19 samP: Ok 04:45:45 rkmrHonjo and I working on this with Adam 04:45:53 samP: ok 04:46:29 samP: Is the abstraction interface already defined? 04:46:54 in openstack-resource-agents to send notifications 04:47:21 tpatil: not yet. rkmrHonjo crate a PoC for this. Based on this we will discuss how to implement this feature 04:47:33 samP: Ok, I got it 04:47:37 I will share those info in ML 04:47:44 samP: thanks 04:47:46 samP: thanks. 04:48:03 #topic Find hosts without specifying segments 04:48:12 rkmrHonjo: any update on this? 04:48:17 yes. 04:48:32 Takahara and I create a BP and spec. 04:48:59 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/506986/ 04:49:00 patch 506986 - masakari-specs - Find segment by specifying host 04:49:06 Please review it. 04:49:49 rkmrHonjo: OK, I was looking in wrong place 04:49:56 its on python-masakariclient.. 04:50:19 I will approve thsi BP and review the patch set 04:50:24 rkmrHonjo: thanks 04:50:44 #topic Queens Work Items 04:51:11 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/masakari-queens-workitems 04:51:42 First, lets finish the items "Started in Pike and incomplete" 04:52:04 Didn't have much time to review all the items on the etherpad. 04:53:08 Let's discuss the priority of "items skipped to Queens" and Newly proposed items in next week IRC 04:53:21 samP: Ok 04:53:21 I will sort them before that. 04:53:48 samP: Agree. 04:53:55 #topic BM HA (ironic + nova) 04:53:57 Add ssl support to Masakari API 04:54:53 tpatil: any comments on SSL support/ 04:54:59 samP: This item is already implement in masakari, only devstack patch is pending 04:55:22 abhishekk: Can you please follow-up on the devstack patch? 04:55:35 # link : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/416009/ 04:55:35 patch 416009 - openstack-dev/devstack - Ignores ssl configuration option added in local.conf 04:55:53 tpatil: that patch is old and now we need to use tls support in devstack 04:56:16 tpatil: ok, 04:56:31 abhishekk: is that the reason you put -1 to WF? 04:56:35 yes 04:57:12 abhishekk: can you update that patch? 04:57:38 samP: need to analyse how to use tls and then i will update the patch 04:57:53 abhishekk: sure 04:58:09 I add a note in therpad on this. 04:58:44 to original topic: BM HA (ironic + nova) 04:59:07 We had discussion with Ironic and Nova about this feature. 04:59:26 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/ironic-queens-ptg-feature-proposals see L #128 05:00:00 This proposal is to do HA manually. 05:00:20 Please see the links for more details 05:00:24 times up 05:00:35 samP: Ok 05:00:40 Lets's discuss further in ML and next meeting 05:00:53 thank you 05:00:58 thank you all 05:00:58 no time left, lets end the meeting here 05:01:04 #endmeeting