17:00:03 <jlvillal> #startmeeting ironic_qa
17:00:05 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Mar  2 17:00:03 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is jlvillal. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:07 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:09 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'ironic_qa'
17:00:25 <jlvillal> Hello everyone.
17:00:32 <jlvillal> The agenda is at: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic-QA
17:00:43 <mjturek1> hey o/
17:00:47 <cdearborn> o/
17:00:57 <jlvillal> #topic Announcements
17:01:10 <jlvillal> I don't have any announcements.
17:01:14 <jlvillal> Does anyone else?
17:02:12 <jlvillal> Okay, moving on
17:02:21 <jlvillal> #topic Grenade testing
17:02:38 <jlvillal> So I made some progress since last week's meeting.
17:02:52 <mgould> o/
17:02:58 <jlvillal> Had to work around a regression issue in stable/liberty
17:03:15 <sambetts> o/
17:03:26 <jlvillal> #info There is a regression issue in stable/liberty: https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1549095  jlvillal will likely propose a work-around patch for the issue.
17:03:28 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1549095 in Ironic "devstack fails while running Ironic grenade job: init__() got an unexpected keyword argument 'token'" [Undecided,In progress] - Assigned to John L. Villalovos (happycamp)
17:04:13 <jlvillal> #info Have not come to a solution on how to make Grenade only test baremetal things. A solution that is acceptable to be pushed upstream is not yet found. Have a working local solution (jlvillal)
17:04:52 <jlvillal> #info Test harness that jlvillal developed: https://github.com/JohnVillalovos/devstack-gate-test
17:05:05 <rpioso> o/
17:05:26 <jlvillal> #info Current status is can get devstack test to pass the stable/liberty portion. It then fails when it goes to the next step in the process.
17:05:43 <jlvillal> I have not had much time so far this week to make additional progress
17:05:54 <jlvillal> I know mgould had been doing some work on it.
17:06:07 <jlvillal> mgould: Anything to add? Any ideas on cause of current failure?
17:07:02 <jlvillal> mgould: ?
17:07:21 * jlvillal knows mgould said he was attending another meeting. So he might not have our full attention :)
17:07:36 <jlvillal> I don't have anything else on Grenade testing. Any questions?
17:07:52 <mgould> sorry, just saw the notification :-)
17:08:02 <mgould> I've also been hacking on grenade, but have no progress to report
17:08:11 <jlvillal> Thanks for the update.
17:08:14 <jlvillal> Okay moving on then
17:08:20 <jlvillal> #topic Functional testing
17:08:27 <jlvillal> Any updates from anyone?
17:08:30 <mjturek1> Not much progress. we're hoping to do some work on it today, but have been a bit sidetracked unfortunately :(
17:08:32 * jlvillal looks at mjturek1 :)
17:08:36 <mjturek1> heheh
17:08:46 <mjturek1> today is our designated functional testing day though
17:08:55 <jlvillal> I unfortunately understand getting side-tracked.
17:08:59 <mjturek1> heheh
17:09:02 <jlvillal> #info No updates this week.
17:09:13 <jlvillal> Okay then moving on if nothing else
17:09:29 <jlvillal> #info 3rd Party CI
17:10:19 <jlvillal> #undo
17:10:20 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Info object at 0xaf45f90>
17:10:27 <jlvillal> #topic 3rd Party CI
17:10:36 <jlvillal> I don't see krtaylor here
17:10:52 <jlvillal> Does anyone have any 3rd Party CI updates
17:11:08 <jlvillal> I noticed that sambetts aka cisco is now commenting/voting
17:11:30 <sambetts> Cisco Ironic CI is hooked up and reponding to patches, it is returning Failed because we're still working on the jobs, but we're close :D
17:11:34 <jlvillal> Maybe it is cisco aka sambetts...
17:11:55 <jlvillal> #info Cisco Ironic CI is hooked up and reponding to patches, it is returning Failed because we're still working on the jobs, but we're close :D
17:12:08 <jlvillal> sambetts: Awesome! :)
17:12:16 <jlvillal> Anything else from anyone?
17:12:21 <sambetts> it needs some slight modification too, because we should be triggering 2 jobs per patch because we've got 2 drivers
17:12:33 <sambetts> CIMC and UCSM
17:12:47 <maurosr> jlvillal: at IBM's CI we're testing silent with upstream patches, there is just one internal network adjustment to be made and we will watch to see if jobs are stable to turn on commenting on the patches
17:13:26 <jlvillal> #info IBM's CI is testing silently with upstream patches, there is just one internal network adjustment to be made and they will watch to see if jobs are stable to turn on commenting on the patches
17:13:32 <sambetts> maurosr: Thats awesome :D
17:13:37 <jlvillal> maurosr: Thanks
17:13:44 <jlvillal> Any other updates?
17:14:00 <jlvillal> Okay, moving on then.
17:14:13 <jlvillal> #topic Open Discussion / General QA topics
17:14:26 <jlvillal> The floor is open.
17:14:35 <jlvillal> If anyone has something to discuss feel free.
17:14:51 <kcalman> I had a question
17:15:03 <kcalman> Is anyone actually testing hardware at this point?
17:15:28 <jlvillal> kcalman: That is the goal of the 3rd Party CI
17:15:55 <maurosr> I have a review request https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+branch:master+topic:bug/1546706 this 3 patches fixes #1546706 which is something we need to get our tests running
17:15:57 <jlvillal> One of the goals, I believe.
17:16:20 <kcalman> I am aware of that, I am wondering if anyone is there yet
17:16:21 <sambetts> kcalman: Our CI will be, it will be against real Cisco UCS, under control of either the Ironic UCSM Driver or Ironic CIMC Driver
17:16:46 <maurosr> kcalman: we're (IBM, report on patches will start next friday or monday hopefully)
17:16:58 <sambetts> kcalman: we're very close, and I've had manual runs working, just need to get the automation setup for the jobs
17:17:31 <jlvillal> #info Review request to get CI working: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+branch:master+topic:bug/1546706 the 3 patches fixes #1546706 which is something needed to get IBM CI tests running
17:18:02 <jlvillal> Not sure if maurosr is running on real hardware or not.
17:18:19 <maurosr> we are jlvillal
17:18:37 <maurosr> you can see a successful run here if you want http://dal05.objectstorage.softlayer.net/v1/AUTH_3d8e6ecb-f597-448c-8ec2-164e9f710dd6/c2/ibm-devstack-gate/79/579/1/check/imported:gate-tempest-dsvm-ironic-pxe_ipmitool-vivid/f329e4a/
17:18:48 <jlvillal> Thanks
17:19:09 <jlvillal> Any other questions or comments?
17:19:54 <kcalman> OK, thanks
17:20:11 <jlvillal> All right. I think we are done.
17:20:19 <jlvillal> Thanks for attending everyone!
17:20:27 <jlvillal> #endmeeting