15:00:40 #startmeeting ironic 15:00:41 Meeting started Mon Oct 15 15:00:40 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is TheJulia. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:42 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:43 o/ 15:00:44 The meeting name has been set to 'ironic' 15:00:47 \o 15:00:47 o/ 15:00:49 \o 15:00:54 o/ 15:00:56 #chair dtantsur 15:00:56 Current chairs: TheJulia dtantsur 15:01:04 o/ 15:01:05 o/ 15:01:07 (Just in case I get disconnected, my connectivity has been flaky today) 15:01:09 o/ 15:01:15 o/ 15:01:33 Greetings everyone! Welcome to another meeting full of irony... oh I mean about ironic. :) 15:01:44 Our agenda can be found on the wiki. 15:01:46 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic#Agenda_for_next_meeting 15:02:10 \o 15:02:14 #topic Announcements / Reminder 15:03:39 First off today, I want to thank sambetts|afk for all of his work in the community. As many may or may not know, Sam has chosen to step down from ironic-core. 15:04:05 sambetts|afk: Thanks everyone for being awesome :D 15:04:39 he's already descended into insanity, pinging himself. we must bring him back immediately. :) 15:04:52 sambetts|afk: thanks again for all the fish! 15:04:54 thank you sambetts|afk!!! 15:05:11 I guess this ultimately means we will be looking for new individuals interested in becoming core reviewers. If anyone is interested, please feel free to reach out to any cores or myself and we can mentor and help you along that path. 15:05:18 Ah, thank you sambetts|afk 15:05:31 sambetts|afk++ 15:05:58 Another piece of awesome news this morning, and the congratulations goes to jiapei. The xclarity CI has started reporting. While it is not fully up, they are making great progress. \o/ 15:06:23 woo 15:06:52 yes, the xclarity CI can deploy devstack instance and config molteniron now, we're trying to integrating xclarity driver testing playbook to it this week 15:06:53 sambetts|afk: Just so you know, we've secretly super glued your shoes to the IRC channel floor. :) 15:07:17 thank you, sambetts|afk! hope to continue seeing you around conferences & the community 15:07:26 Does anyone have anything else they want to announce or remind of this week? 15:07:38 s/remind of/remind us of/ 15:08:33 I guess that is a no, so we can carry on. 15:08:51 #topic Review action items from previous meeting 15:08:54 haha, I don't intend to disappear :) 15:08:59 #info No action items from last week 15:09:13 #topic Review subteam status reports 15:09:44 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:09:49 Starting at line 162 15:10:36 errr 15:10:38 #undo 15:10:38 Removing item from minutes: #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:10:46 err 15:10:52 * TheJulia glares at irccloud 15:10:58 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:11:13 Anyway, jroll! do you feel you need additional ironic eyes on that nova spec? 15:11:31 TheJulia: it could use at least one set of eyes :) 15:11:41 but it's all fairly obvious 15:11:50 FYI - We have a vendor priority on line 130 15:12:14 sambetts|afk: It's been great working with you, and I hope to do more of the same. 15:12:41 * TheJulia adds it to the list 15:12:45 jroll: I figured as much 15:13:11 cdearborn: noted 15:14:04 Has anyone heard from or seen Chandra on IRC recently? 15:14:57 Looks like kaifeng is holding off on the ironic side of improving checksum verification until after we have glance v1 ripped out 15:15:08 So we should definitely try and get some more eyes on that this week. 15:15:42 ++ 15:16:23 jroll: I've added the no agent to conductor communication spec to the list to review this week 15:16:35 ++ thanks 15:18:29 #info As a reminder, lease remember to update the status information on the ironic whiteboard with a date so we can identify when entries need additional investigation or visibility. 15:18:38 I'm ready to move on, if everyone else is as well? 15:18:59 yep 15:19:06 totes 15:19:30 #topic Priorities for this next week 15:19:38 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:19:49 Starting around line 93 15:19:54 * TheJulia removes the merged items 15:21:32 I'm not aware of any housekeeping items necessary this week, but this has been a hectic morning and I've not had a chance to look. 15:21:39 Is anyone aware of any? 15:21:49 let's add anything that improves the ironic-inspector grenade situation /cc hjensas 15:21:49 Additionally, is there anything that anyone feels should be on the list? 15:21:59 ++ 15:22:57 hjensas: Can you add the relevant links to the whiteboard? 15:23:10 hjensas: line 117 15:24:30 TheJulia: will add. 15:24:56 Thanks 15:25:00 o/ kaifeng 15:25:05 o/ 15:25:18 well, I'm good with the priorities for the week if nobody has anything else to add 15:25:38 Everyone else? 15:25:44 * jroll is also fine 15:26:25 lgtm 15:26:33 #topic Open Discussion 15:26:45 Anyone have anything to discuss this week? 15:27:59 etingof: have youhad a chance to ponder threading/locking besides the ipmitool killing thoughts? 15:28:57 TheJulia, well, the other thought I have is to wrap libipmi in an async python wrapper 15:29:40 to get rid of execs / make libipmi more native to gevent 15:29:44 Harald Jensås proposed openstack/ironic-python-agent master: Raise udevadm settle timeout from 5 to 20 seconds https://review.openstack.org/609769 15:29:46 hmmmmmmmmm 15:29:49 etingof: intruiging 15:30:06 is that really any different than improving pyghmi, in the end? 15:30:46 my feeling is that pyghmi is not as compatible with BMCs as ipmitool hopefully is 15:31:08 Harald Jensås proposed openstack/ironic-python-agent stable/rocky: Raise udevadm settle timeout from 5 to 20 seconds https://review.openstack.org/610148 15:31:22 That is a good question, I don't have an answer to that question 15:31:26 Worth researh 15:31:27 well, that would be the improvement to pyghmi, yes 15:31:28 and pyghmi might never catch up because vendors (supposedly) test their BMCs with ipmitool/openipmi/freeipmi 15:31:36 fair 15:32:47 also, I am not sure if we are willing to support all IPMI edge-cases in pyghmi 15:33:16 etingof: have you discussed with Josh about this 15:33:17 ? 15:33:19 I wonder how much it's going to take the world to move to redfish.. 15:33:41 TheJulia, no, but I will approach him 15:33:50 josh? 15:34:37 jjohnson 15:34:43 the pgyhmi maintainer 15:34:44 jarrod :) 15:34:49 oh, right! 15:34:59 he is actually Jarrod 15:35:08 I got excited thinking we had a second person working on it :) 15:35:17 * TheJulia knows multiple jjohnsons 15:35:18 Okay, so I feel bad now 15:35:18 Anyway! 15:35:18 Is there anyone else that has things to discuss? 15:36:43 Okay, well, I have another meeting to be on 15:39:46 * iurygregory wonder if TheJulia forgot the #endmeeting 15:39:54 indeed! 15:40:00 Thanks everyone! 15:40:00 Just to say Good Morning Ironic'ers 15:40:04 #endmeeting