15:00:12 #startmeeting ironic 15:00:13 o/ 15:00:13 Meeting started Mon Sep 24 15:00:12 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is TheJulia. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:14 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:17 The meeting name has been set to 'ironic' 15:00:17 \o 15:00:18 o/ 15:00:25 o/ 15:00:28 o/ 15:00:40 o/ 15:00:47 o/ 15:00:48 I hope everyone has been able to rest after the PTG and their travels! 15:00:50 o/ 15:00:55 o/ 15:00:58 o/ 15:00:58 \o 15:01:21 Our agenda, as always is on the wiki. 15:01:26 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic#Agenda_for_next_meeting 15:01:43 It appears we don't have anything out of the ordinary normal agenda there, so hopefully this meeting will go quickly :) 15:01:53 #topic Announcements/Reminders 15:02:56 #info The proposed priorities for the cycle were posted last week, please review so we can set our direction for this next cycle. 15:02:59 #link https://review.openstack.org/603161 15:03:00 patch 603161 - ironic-specs - Stein priorites - 3 patch sets 15:04:16 As an aside note, this week I'm catching up from two weeks of travel, and will be intermittently away tomorrow. If you need something ASAP, please let me know. 15:04:33 Anyone else have any reminders or announcements today? 15:04:35 \o 15:05:38 I guess we can proceed then! 15:05:55 ++ 15:06:35 Last week we had no action items 15:07:03 #topic Review subteam status reports 15:07:46 #info Since the priorities for the cycle have not been agreed upon (https://review.openstack.org/603161), there are no priorities to review at this time. 15:07:47 patch 603161 - ironic-specs - Stein priorites - 3 patch sets 15:07:47 no priorities, not subteams :) 15:07:53 yup! 15:08:01 NOTHING TO DO! :D 15:08:04 #info Please review the stein cycle priorities. 15:08:08 ^^^ :) 15:08:12 #link https://review.openstack.org/603161 15:08:13 patch 603161 - ironic-specs - Stein priorites - 3 patch sets 15:08:17 Moving on! 15:08:33 #topic Deciding on priorities for the coming week 15:08:58 I started creating a new section for stein this morning, including a fix for the docs in the ironic-specs repository, and some doc/cleanup changes that make sense to continue to work on. 15:09:03 priorities are a priority :) 15:09:42 And they are.... just #2 on the list since the docs don't pass testing right now :( 15:09:44 https://review.openstack.org/604797 15:09:45 patch 604797 - ironic-specs - Fix ironic-specs repo doc builds - 1 patch set 15:09:57 Does anyone have anything to add to this list? 15:10:22 re python 3 jobs: 15:10:28 I'd prefer we moved to zuul v3 first 15:10:35 otherwise we increase the amount of copy-paste 15:10:47 i have a question about one of the ci-cleanup patches: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/591675/. should i wait for open discussion? 15:10:48 patch 591675 - ironic - Remove ironic experimental jobs - 2 patch sets 15:10:48 derekh: do you plan to do other projects as well? 15:10:55 dtantsur: I concur 15:11:25 dtantsur: yup, one more test to finsh, then I'll move to other repos (excluding grenade jobs) 15:11:33 rloo: It is on the list by virtue of the tag 15:11:35 derekh++ you're awesome! 15:11:40 derekh: thanks! 15:11:58 np 15:12:11 TheJulia: the question is about that particular patch. it is removing functional, dsvm-parallel, and dsvm-pxe_ipa-full. which is fine. for now. but do we want those jobs in the future? 15:12:14 I noticed derekh was already heading in the direction that seemed to have consensus naming wise as well, so I think it will just be a background effort this cycle. 15:12:36 rloo: I don't know, to be honest. functional - maybe, the others - meh, I don't care. 15:12:48 \o (sorry I'm late) 15:12:57 rloo: I feel like we already have the coverage elsewhere, but I'd have to look at each individual case 15:13:10 dtantsur: ok, fine with me. but we put those there so i thought someone would remember why/if we wanted them :) 15:13:12 o/ jroll 15:13:26 is it worth opening a story about functional tests (we may have one, dunno) 15:13:32 rloo: well.. I think both full and parallel came from the times when we merged our virt driver into nova 15:13:35 I didn't look at the coverage of the jobs themselves, just that they don't work and they seem to have been experimental for a long time 15:13:44 Anyway, just wanted to bring those up here, in case others have thoughts about them :) 15:13:49 rloo: I think back at the times nova folks did not like that we cannot run tempest-full with ironic backend 15:13:58 we've wanted those for years but nobody has prioritized them 15:14:00 and we tried, but it was taking 6+ hours to finish :) 15:14:31 and we have problems with parallel execution because nodes are scarce resource 15:14:37 derekh: that is a good argument to remove them regardless :) 15:14:56 Only way to do that is on the multinode jobs really 15:15:04 i'm totally fine with removing them now (I approved it). Just want to make sure/check if we want them in the future. 15:15:50 if somebody wanted to invest time into CI, I'd encourage them to work on covering more ironic features, not exercising nova more 15:16:24 I cleaned up the list some 15:16:33 on the etherpad 15:17:04 ++ 15:17:09 With that, are we good to move on? 15:17:18 * dtantsur is 15:17:20 Does anyone have anything to add that requires visibility this week? 15:17:33 * dtantsur forgot to announce metalsmith moving under our governance 15:17:53 congrats :) 15:17:57 dtantsur++ 15:18:17 ++ 15:18:24 ++ 15:18:28 ++ 15:18:51 Moving to Open Discussion as we have no explicit topics or RFEs listed that require review today. 15:18:56 #topic Open Discussion 15:19:06 Does anyone have anything they would like to talk about? 15:19:08 (just to recap, if anyone thinks those deleted experimental jobs would be useful in the future, please open stories to track) 15:19:21 rloo: ++ 15:20:09 jroll: thank you for sending out a summary. I'll read and likely refer to it in anything I write up (if necessary). 15:20:30 you're welcome :) 15:20:32 I've got a mountain of expenses and emails to get through this week. 15:22:38 Well, I guess we can call this meeting done if there is nothing else anyone wishes to bring up. 15:23:03 ++ 15:23:08 \o/ 15:23:20 CRICKETS 15:23:54 Well everyone, have a wonderful week! 15:24:42 Thanks! 15:24:45 #endmeeting