15:00:18 #startmeeting ironic 15:00:19 Meeting started Mon Apr 9 15:00:18 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is TheJulia. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:21 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:23 The meeting name has been set to 'ironic' 15:00:27 \o 15:00:35 o/ 15:00:41 Good morning everyone 15:00:41 o/ 15:00:45 o/ 15:00:47 o/ 15:00:47 Time for an ironic meeting! 15:00:50 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic#Agenda_for_next_meeting 15:00:50 o/ 15:00:56 o/ 15:01:08 o/ 15:01:10 #topic Announcements / Reminder 15:01:45 I have created an etherpad to gather topics for the forum. Please add items this week. 15:01:47 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/YVR-ironic-forum-sessions 15:01:56 o/ 15:02:04 nice 15:02:50 Does anyone have any other announcements or reminders to bring up? 15:03:36 * TheJulia hears crickets 15:03:49 lol 15:04:20 Moving on! 15:04:42 #topic Review action items from our previous meeting 15:04:46 #link http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/ironic/2018/ 15:05:09 Ahh yes, to look at the bugs which was my action item. 15:05:11 o/ 15:05:34 I looked, and I think we should revise processes... or at least our view or processes. Viewing the single group in launchpad does make it VERY easy though :) 15:05:42 \o 15:06:13 Anyway, we can discuss that later 15:06:18 Onward! 15:06:37 do we want to discuss bug bash now or later? 15:06:56 #topic Review subteam status reports 15:06:58 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:07:05 rloo: during open discussion I think :) 15:07:10 TheJulia: ok 15:07:48 yolanda.robla proposed openstack/ironic master: BIOS Settings: Add DB model https://review.openstack.org/511162 15:07:48 yolanda.robla proposed openstack/ironic master: Add bios_interface db field https://review.openstack.org/528609 15:07:48 TheJulia: we fixed that critical sushy bug, right? 15:07:49 yolanda.robla proposed openstack/ironic master: BIOS Settings: Add DB API https://review.openstack.org/511402 15:07:49 yolanda.robla proposed openstack/ironic master: BIOS Settings: Add RPC object https://review.openstack.org/511714 15:07:50 yolanda.robla proposed openstack/ironic master: BIOS Settings: Add BIOSInterface https://review.openstack.org/507793 15:07:50 yolanda.robla proposed openstack/ironic master: BIOS Settings: Add BIOS caching https://review.openstack.org/512200 15:07:51 yolanda.robla proposed openstack/ironic master: WIP: Add Node BIOS support - REST API https://review.openstack.org/512579 15:07:58 So I went through and updated a few things, but I was somewhat out of touch last week attending a meeting. 15:08:31 TheJulia: ^^ wrt the sushy bug, did a release get done? 15:08:41 Looks like we did 15:08:41 this bug: https://bugs.launchpad.net/sushy/+bug/1754514 15:08:43 Launchpad bug 1754514 in sushy "Base authentication don't work" [Critical,Fix released] - Assigned to deray (debayan-ray) 15:08:45 well, release 15:08:47 hmmm 15:08:50 Dmitry was going to create them 15:08:51 checking 15:09:28 Release is still pending https://review.openstack.org/#/c/558799/ 15:09:29 patch 558799 - releases - Release sushy 1.3.2 for Queens 15:10:04 TheJulia: ok, i'll update the status of that. 15:10:12 I just did 15:10:15 TheJulia: :) 15:11:51 TheJulia: wrt storyboard migration, L235. what needs to be done there? 15:12:48 rloo: do we want to call for volunteers for sighup support in ironic-inspector and networking-baremetal? 15:13:00 jroll: oh, yeah, that'd be good. 15:13:12 * jroll added it 15:13:24 rloo: bunch of patches are pending updating docs 15:13:29 jroll: thx! (how'd he know i wasn't working on it... ? :D) 15:13:43 heh 15:13:56 Sounds good 15:14:10 TheJulia: do you have a list or is there a topic. let's just get them done. 15:14:20 ++ 15:14:25 I raced through them and didn't topic them. I can make a list 15:14:56 TheJulia: thx. 15:15:03 rloo: I'll make it after the meeting 15:15:08 rloo: i can be the victim for ironic-inspector 15:15:11 everyone done reviewing the status of all the things 15:15:15 * hjensas can look at sighup support for networking-baremetal. 15:15:17 kaifeng: sweet, thx! 15:15:27 thanks hjensas :) 15:15:27 kaifeng: hjensas: awesome, thanks! 15:15:32 o/ 15:15:38 and thanks kaifeng :) 15:15:42 \o mjturek 15:16:02 thx hjensas! 15:16:20 * rloo done with status 15:16:31 Onward to priorities for the week? 15:16:33 ditto 15:16:39 yw :) 15:17:44 #topic Priorities for the coming week 15:18:27 So it is clear we've been stalling out on the remaining of rescue. I've shuffled the text a little so we can hopefully have a little more clarity there 15:20:14 are we stalling or just disagreeing? 15:20:29 the one patch has a +2 15:20:32 Cycling slowly 15:20:40 very slowly 15:20:45 yeah 15:20:56 As for bios interface, the unit tests are failing 15:21:06 specifically ones that wont fail locally since they require the database engine 15:21:23 It impacts the entire stack of patches 15:21:36 oh fun! 15:21:46 ouch. someone looking at it, or is it 'i don't know how to fix' thing? 15:22:01 we know that it's possible to connect local tests to a db engine, right? :) 15:22:18 I looked at it earlier, I think it is the first time we've tried using json native fields 15:22:27 a new set of patches was just done during this meeting, maybe that'll fix... 15:22:30 looks like yolanda put up a new patch 15:22:32 jroll: oh it is, but most people don't have their local db setup to support that 15:22:38 jroll: oh, awesome 15:22:41 sure, but it's possible 15:22:49 ... wait, native json fields? 15:22:50 yup, 7 minutes after 15:22:55 jroll, mine is just wip, but is a long chain 15:23:17 yolanda: ah, I see 15:23:33 jroll: yeah, as in it is stored as json instead of text 15:23:58 TheJulia: yes, I know what they are, I didn't think they were in mysql until very very recently 15:24:23 though, looking at the patch I don't think they are native json fields 15:24:33 we can loop back to this later btw 15:24:43 jroll: I think a couple years, but I had a similar thought earlier 15:25:02 Anyway, does anyone have any other items for the priority list? 15:25:44 TheJulia: please add your storyboard patches to that list 15:26:00 that works 15:26:28 Okay, I'll populate the list after the meeting 15:26:40 works for me! 15:26:44 Anything else? I think we're good as long as we make progress on rescue this week 15:27:17 just looking at release schedule. rocky-1 milestone is next week. maybe we should aim to do a release *after* gtting rescue done. 15:27:17 * rpioso must leave early for a downstream group lunch 15:27:54 (I'm good with priorities) 15:28:01 * jroll leaves a comment on the bios patch indicating the problem, easy peasy :) 15:28:11 thx for reviews! 15:28:12 rloo: Possibly yeah, I guess only time will tell 15:28:28 Anyway, are we good to move on to Open Discussion at this point? 15:29:25 yes! 15:29:26 * jroll is fine 15:29:53 #topic Open Discussion 15:30:26 mjturek: bug smash? 15:30:35 yolanda.robla proposed openstack/ironic master: WIP: Add Node BIOS support - REST API https://review.openstack.org/512579 15:30:51 So lets see, replaying brain from last week. I was at a baremetal provisioning forum last week, and the thought of federated cross organization ironic came up. I have a couple building block ideas that could help there, so I'll try to toss them up this week. 15:30:54 yep! The doodle is here https://doodle.com/poll/xa999rx653pb58t6 15:31:12 think a 2 hr window will work? 15:32:03 i only see 7 people participated in doodle. that makes me sad. 15:32:17 does that mean the rest aren't going to participate at all ? 15:32:18 :( 15:32:43 mjturek: I just added myself 15:32:54 #link https://doodle.com/poll/xa999rx653pb58t6 15:33:38 I think a two hour window will work 15:34:06 Seems like we should just agree on the most common time and move on? 15:34:26 UTC 1:00 PM to 3:00 PM seems most popular 15:34:41 sold! 15:34:48 :) 15:34:52 hoorraaaay! 15:35:01 where are we going to hold this? hangouts? 15:35:12 or how we do mid-cycle? 15:35:30 it has been so long since we've had one, that i can't recall what/how we did it. 15:35:54 mjturek: I think a hangout might be ?easiest? 15:35:55 I'm fine with either - inclusivity would imply we should use infra's SIP bridge 15:36:03 do we all go through the same bugs at the same time? 15:36:06 it would, if it has been paid for recently 15:36:32 dmitry used bluejean before? or something like that. 15:36:48 yeah, I have access to a bluejeans account. We could also use that 15:36:58 I'm okay with any of the above 15:37:08 well, 6 people signed up. maybe more will join us. i think as long as the 6 can get access to whatever technology, i'm good. 15:37:37 right, we should check with them before scheduling, but I expect bluejeans would be okay 15:37:51 or just say "if you can't access this or object to it bla bla" to the email 15:38:05 I can host in bluejeans I guess 15:38:36 That will allow people to dial in easily 15:38:52 sounds good to me 15:38:59 details on the ML? 15:39:03 in that case, just as good as SIP bridge, so lets use bluejeans. 15:39:12 mjturek: yup, email please. 15:39:17 #action TheJulia to create a bluejeans meeting for the time. 15:39:30 mjturek: will you close out the poll, and I'll go ahead and create the meeting 15:39:36 perfect 15:39:38 mjturek: and then send you the details to send an email 15:39:39 will do 15:40:02 so we don't spend lots of time during bug bash, deciding how/what/process, might be good for someone mjturek? TheJulia? to propose something before hand? 15:41:00 eg will we all look at each bug at the same time, to try to deal with it. or do we split the bugs and ping each other if tehre are questions about one of them? 15:41:03 I can propose something today if that's helpful 15:41:22 mjturek: that would be awesome 15:41:28 and obviously we can have some back and forth to get a final shape of the thing 15:41:32 cool will do 15:41:34 thx mjturek! 15:41:41 np! 15:43:13 Ilya Etingof proposed openstack/sushy-tools master: OpenStack cloud driver added https://review.openstack.org/523879 15:44:07 Do we have anything else to discuss? 15:44:15 crickets... 15:46:04 Well, sounds like we're done for the day! 15:46:09 Meeting wise at least 15:46:11 Thanks everyone! 15:46:48 #endmeeting