17:00:00 <jroll> #startmeeting ironic
17:00:01 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Jun  6 17:00:00 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is jroll. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:02 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:05 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'ironic'
17:00:06 <jroll> ohai everyone
17:00:10 <milan> o/
17:00:10 <mat128> o/
17:00:19 <rama_y> o/
17:00:22 <rpioso> \o
17:00:27 <alineb> o/
17:00:36 <TheJulia> o/
17:00:37 * jroll is hungry so will try to keep this short
17:00:46 <dtantsur> o/
17:00:49 <krtaylor> o/
17:00:52 <jroll> agenda is here:
17:00:54 <jroll> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic#Agenda_for_next_meeting
17:00:55 <vdrok> o/
17:00:57 <jroll> #chair devananda NobodyCam
17:00:58 <openstack> Current chairs: NobodyCam devananda jroll
17:01:02 <rloo> o/
17:01:02 <mjturek1> o/
17:01:03 * TheJulia thanks jroll in advance for the same reason
17:01:06 <jroll> #topic Announcements and reminders
17:01:10 <jlvillal> o/
17:01:20 <devananda> o/
17:01:29 <NobodyCam> o/
17:01:37 <sambetts> o/
17:01:39 <jroll> so, as I emailed about last week, I made a trello board to try to get us organized
17:01:41 <jroll> #link https://trello.com/b/ROTxmGIc/ironic-newton-priorities
17:02:03 <rloo> thx jroll!
17:02:05 <jroll> I also made an etherpad for midcycle topics:
17:02:06 <jroll> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/ironic-newton-midcycle
17:02:23 <jroll> I'll flesh that out with times/etc soon
17:02:27 <jroll> anyone have other announcements or reminders?
17:03:04 <vsaienko1> o/
17:03:04 <krtaylor> yes
17:03:14 <jroll> krtaylor: shoot
17:03:20 <krtaylor> here's a link to the ironic social pics
17:03:23 <krtaylor> http://www.kurttaylor.com/blog/2016/05/austin-summit-ironic-social/
17:03:35 <jroll> nice! :)
17:03:35 <mat128> #link http://www.kurttaylor.com/blog/2016/05/austin-summit-ironic-social/
17:03:38 <krtaylor> thought ya'll might want to see
17:03:41 <mjturek1> cool :)
17:03:44 <devananda> krtaylor: nice! thanks
17:03:52 <rloo> thx krtaylor!
17:03:58 <rloo> (and victoria)
17:04:15 <krtaylor> you're welcome, it was fun!
17:04:17 <dtantsur> cool!
17:04:37 <NobodyCam> awesome thank you krtaylor
17:05:17 <krtaylor> click the thumbnails for larger pics
17:05:26 * jroll moves on
17:05:28 <krtaylor> anyway, that's it for now
17:05:28 <jroll> #topic subteam status reports
17:05:33 <xavierr> \o
17:05:39 <jroll> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard
17:05:44 <jroll> beginning at line 75 this week
17:06:06 * jroll gives folks a few minutes to peruse
17:06:10 <jlvillal> FYI: Grenade is down to six patches remaining to be merged. Two of which are Ironic patches.
17:06:37 <vsaienko1> jlvillal what do you mean grenade is down?
17:06:52 <mat128> vsaienko1: "down to six patches"
17:07:01 <mat128> vsaienko1: only 6 left
17:07:07 <jlvillal> vsaienko1: Sorry I meant. Grenade work is only needing six patches to complete.
17:07:38 <jlvillal> vsaienko1: Down as in decreasing.  We are were at 12 patches and now we are down to six patches. As an example.
17:07:38 <jroll> so, as a note, we might consider replacing this with the trello board, for the priorities things at least
17:07:42 <jroll> something to think about
17:08:09 <rloo> jroll: replacing 'this' -- what is 'this'? the meeting?
17:08:13 <jroll> \o/ for inspector dropping the bash ramdisk
17:08:18 <jroll> rloo: this topic, the subteam updates
17:08:31 <jlvillal> jroll: Add a link to the Trello board in the whiteboard?
17:08:32 <rloo> jroll: i thought of that but not all subteams are in trello
17:08:57 <jroll> rloo: right, I'm publicizing your idea, just something to think about for now. hence the "at least for priorities things"
17:09:00 <jlvillal> jroll: At the top of the whiteboard.  A thought.
17:09:14 <rloo> jlvillal: i was thinking of adding the trello card links to the subteams.
17:09:18 <jroll> jlvillal: you can edit etherpad too :)
17:09:19 <jroll> rloo++
17:09:21 <rloo> jlvillal: where appropriate
17:09:22 <sambetts> jlvillal: done in the Dashboards section
17:09:33 <jroll> sambetts++
17:09:36 <jlvillal> rloo: Sounds good.
17:09:49 <rloo> jlvillal: will do later when i generate the report
17:10:19 <jroll> thanks rloo :)
17:10:21 <jroll> any questions/comments on what's in the subteam updates this week?
17:10:58 <rloo> wrt the network isolation. any one tested those with grenade?
17:11:17 <vdrok> rloo, I think we did not
17:11:20 <vsaienko1> rloo probably nope
17:11:22 <jroll> not that I know of, that would be good
17:11:43 <rloo> yeah, once i know it has been tested (and passes) grenade, i'll start reviewing again
17:11:46 <dtantsur> a usual reminder to review the driver composition spec :)
17:11:58 <dtantsur> a couple of folks did it, but I'd love more opinions
17:12:08 <dtantsur> link: https://review.openstack.org/188370
17:12:16 <jroll> #link https://review.openstack.org/188370
17:12:46 <jroll> anything else?
17:13:08 <jroll> nothing in the main topics, so
17:13:12 <jroll> #topic open discussion
17:13:21 <jroll> hshiina asks "Could we get nova BPs depending on ironic approved as spec-less BPs like serial console one?"
17:13:58 <rloo> doesn't it depend on the nova BP?
17:14:10 <jroll> hshiina: you'll need to ask nova folks about that one; I suspect soft power off would be spec-less, not sure about the other two (NMI is a new feature in nova, right? and boot from volume idk what all is involved)
17:14:33 <jroll> rloo: yeah, it's case by case
17:14:38 <hshiina> yes.
17:14:49 <jroll> hshiina: the process is to add it to the nova meeting agenda, and be there to discuss
17:15:05 <jroll> hshiina: though, you should wait until ironic approves those to do so
17:15:11 <TheJulia> hshiina: my understanding is boot from volume also had a spec proposed in nova, but it makes little sense to push until we've landed support for it
17:15:43 <rloo> right, cuz that will be one of the first questions from nova folks; is the ironic-side approved :)
17:15:45 <hshiina> i asked once last nova meeting.
17:15:54 <hshiina> then not approved.
17:15:57 <jroll> hshiina: what did they say?
17:16:09 <rloo> hshiina: what did you ask?
17:16:47 <hshiina> jroll, it is necceccary that ironic specs are merged.
17:17:05 <rloo> and speaking of nova, i noticed they have a 'history' section at the bottom of their specs. something we might want to add in ironic specs?
17:17:26 <jroll> hshiina: reading the logs, mriedem said that the BP should be updated to show the dependency, and the ironic spec merged, and then he will approve
17:17:37 <jroll> hshiina: so, once those are done, just talk to mriedem
17:17:49 <jroll> most (all?) of us here can't approve nova BPs :)
17:18:11 <hshiina> serial console spec was approved though ironic spec is still ongoing.
17:18:31 <jroll> sounds like a mistake
17:18:38 <hshiina> s/console spec/console bp/
17:18:51 <jroll> anyway, nothing we can do about it in this meeting
17:19:07 <jroll> (and let's get the console spec done ASAP so that mistake is no longer there)
17:19:59 <hshiina> ok. i also hope console spec will be done soon.
17:20:20 <jroll> agree
17:20:24 <jroll> anything else for open discussion?
17:20:29 <hshiina> thanks.
17:20:36 <jroll> hshiina: you're welcome :)
17:20:41 <jroll> thanks for bringing it up
17:22:05 <jroll> okay, seems like there's nothing more to discuss, thanks all for the quick meeting :)
17:22:15 <NobodyCam> I could ask for a review on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/272658/
17:22:19 <NobodyCam> :p
17:22:40 <jroll> heh
17:22:43 <NobodyCam> Thanks every one ... good meeting
17:22:47 <jroll> #endmeeting