05:00:12 <devananda> #startmeeting ironic
05:00:13 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Apr 28 05:00:12 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is devananda. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
05:00:14 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
05:00:17 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'ironic'
05:00:20 <devananda> #chair NobodyCam
05:00:21 <openstack> Current chairs: NobodyCam devananda
05:00:32 <NobodyCam> o/
05:00:39 <naohirot> o/
05:00:47 <ramineni> o/
05:00:49 <devananda> good morning/afternoon/evening/night !
05:00:57 <NobodyCam> :)
05:01:12 <devananda> our agenda for today (https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic) is surprisingly empty ...
05:01:14 <BadCub> o/
05:01:24 <NobodyCam> light agenda today!
05:01:42 <devananda> I have two topics to cover, though, which could take up the whole meeting :)
05:02:04 <devananda> #topic Kilo RC status
05:02:05 <mrda> o/
05:02:25 <devananda> #undo
05:02:25 <pshige> o/
05:02:26 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Topic object at 0x8c27510>
05:02:31 <devananda> actually - I'm going to give folks more time to show up
05:02:35 <devananda> we're really light right now
05:03:39 * NobodyCam runs to grab soda in the lull
05:03:59 <devananda> fwiw, my two topics: kilo rc statuss & release notes; summit planning
05:04:04 <rameshg87> o/
05:04:37 <devananda> rameshg87, wanyen: glad you two could make it :)
05:04:48 <wanyen> :)
05:05:04 <rameshg87> devananda: it's 10.30 am for me :)
05:05:12 * rameshg87 cannot have a reason for not attending :D
05:05:19 <devananda> heh
05:05:20 <pshige> :)
05:05:25 <devananda> it's 10pm here
05:05:34 <rameshg87> oh :(
05:05:59 <devananda> which makes it 1am for Shrews and TheJulia ... (you two should be asleep! don't answer this :) )
05:06:09 <devananda> ok - let's get started
05:06:15 <devananda> cinerama: ohhai!
05:06:21 <cinerama> devananda: hi!
05:06:38 <devananda> #topic Kilo release status
05:06:51 <devananda> first off, we've published an RC2 build last week
05:06:56 <devananda> please please go test it
05:07:42 <devananda> and if you find any huge bugs, please tag them "kilo-rc-potential" so they show up here
05:07:45 <devananda> https://bugs.launchpad.net/ironic/+bugs?field.tag=kilo-rc-potential
05:07:48 <devananda> oops
05:07:49 <devananda> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/ironic/+bugs?field.tag=kilo-rc-potential
05:08:07 <devananda> we've had two get tagged. i dont think either one is wort ha backport though
05:08:15 <devananda> https://bugs.launchpad.net/ironic/+bug/1384379
05:08:15 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1384379 in OpenStack Compute (nova) "versions resource uses host_url which may be incorrect" [High,In progress] - Assigned to shihanzhang (shihanzhang)
05:08:18 <devananda> https://bugs.launchpad.net/ironic/+bug/1448103
05:08:19 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1448103 in Ironic "disabling erase_devices clean_step in agent_ilo driver doesn't work" [Undecided,Fix committed] - Assigned to Anusha (anusha-iiitm)
05:08:52 <devananda> wanyen: I dont see anusha here, but can you speak to why that bug fix was proposed to stable/kilo?
05:08:52 <rameshg87> devananda: and i think #1 doesn't have a fix in ironic yet
05:09:06 <devananda> rameshg87: yea, I haven't seen any code up for it
05:09:20 <ramineni> devananda: anusha here :)
05:09:40 <ramineni> devananda: thought it is required for backporting
05:10:17 <devananda> ramineni: ohhai!
05:10:22 <rameshg87> devananda: because of #2 bug, disk erase cannot be disabled for agent_ilo driver if cleaning is enabled
05:10:50 <devananda> is there a case you want cleaning enabled but NOT to run disk erase step?
05:10:51 <ramineni> devananda: And as teh clean step 'erase_devcies' takes lot of time,
05:11:10 <ramineni> devananda: so, it is important to be disabled , if user doesnt want it
05:11:22 <devananda> ramineni: which "user" ?
05:11:27 <devananda> you mean operator, right?
05:11:31 <ramineni> devananda: yes
05:11:34 <rameshg87> devananda: may be a single tenant environment ? idk. may be people won't care about erasing disks
05:11:40 <rameshg87> ??
05:11:46 <devananda> ok - so there is already a flag to disable cleaning
05:11:56 <devananda> why would someone want to do cleaning but NOT do disk erase?
05:12:05 <ramineni> devananda: yes, there is
05:12:24 <wanyen> devanand, admin may want other cleaning steps but want to disable disk erase only.
05:13:02 <stendulker> devananda: Disk erase being very time-consuming, operator may not do it very frequently
05:14:27 <devananda> hm. i'm not thrilled that this is a driver-specific option, but I see the need for the fix, and it's pretty simple
05:14:45 <devananda> thanks for explaining. seems OK to me
05:14:54 <ramineni> devananda: thanks
05:15:21 <devananda> any volunteers t owork on https://bugs.launchpad.net/ironic/+bug/1384379 ?
05:15:21 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1384379 in OpenStack Compute (nova) "versions resource uses host_url which may be incorrect" [High,In progress] - Assigned to shihanzhang (shihanzhang)
05:15:41 <rameshg87> shih <tab> ???
05:15:51 <devananda> if no one's working on a fix, we shouldn't target it to kilo ...
05:16:03 <wanyen> I thought disabling disk erase is generic not ilo driver specific.
05:16:30 <devananda> wanyen: the CONF option is defined in ilo driver
05:16:48 <devananda> "if CONF.ilo.clean_priority_erase_devices is not None:"
05:16:58 <ramineni> wanyen: there is an option for agent driver and one for ilo driver
05:17:03 <wanyen> I see.  But I thought IPA allow disk erase to be disabled as well.
05:17:36 <ramineni> wanyen: yes , through agent.agent_erase_devices_priority=<None>
05:17:58 <devananda> ok, BadCub, can you track that host_url  bug ^ and if we don thave someone working on it by EOD tomorrow, let's untarget it
05:18:00 <ramineni> wanyen: have a seprate option for that as well
05:18:12 <rameshg87> devananda: i will try to see if something is possible https://bugs.launchpad.net/ironic/+bug/1384379 and will have an update when you come back tomorrow
05:18:12 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1384379 in OpenStack Compute (nova) "versions resource uses host_url which may be incorrect" [High,In progress] - Assigned to shihanzhang (shihanzhang)
05:18:28 <devananda> rameshg87: great. thanks!
05:18:29 <BadCub> devananda: got it
05:18:56 <devananda> rameshg87: pls assign bug to yourself in LP
05:19:16 <BadCub> devananda: doesn't look like it is targeted at this point
05:19:22 <devananda> any other questions re: Kilo release before I move on?
05:19:37 <devananda> BadCub: no, but it has kilo-rc-potential tag
05:19:47 * rameshg87 did it
05:19:48 <NobodyCam> shouldn't https://review.openstack.org/#/c/177213 have a conf file update too
05:19:49 <BadCub> yep, see that
05:20:20 <ramineni> NobodyCam: why?
05:20:27 <devananda> NobodyCam: nope. the option was added in previous patches. it just wasn't *used* propertly
05:20:47 <devananda> #topic Liberty summit planning
05:20:50 <devananda> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/liberty-ironic-design-summit-ideas
05:21:00 <devananda> we've gathered ideas up there ^
05:21:14 <devananda> and I've collated them into a draft of our schedule, at the top
05:21:18 <devananda> please take a look
05:21:47 <devananda> also, please discuss items inline below, and if you have other topics, you can still add them to the 'pad
05:25:43 * rameshg87 wonders if everyone is on etherpad
05:26:09 * devananda thinks so
05:26:18 <NobodyCam> yep
05:26:25 <stendulker> devananda: Have added one item :)
05:26:34 <pshige> I am on etherpad
05:26:45 * mrda thinks we've got a lot to discuss at summit
05:26:50 <devananda> stendulker: where?
05:27:14 <stendulker> devananda: in etherpad
05:27:15 <devananda> oh, got it
05:27:24 <stendulker> devananda: ok :)
05:28:06 <devananda> for the two fishbowl sessions -- these are the large ~200 person rooms
05:28:33 <devananda> my goal there is to present the most important changes & objectives, and gather feedback from the wider audience
05:29:00 <pshige> are the any special IRC meeting held where we discuss items ?
05:29:06 <devananda> I'm currently thinking that its worth discussing the driver composition & support issue in that context
05:29:25 <wanyen> devananda, cinder integration and networking will not be discussed at Ironic sessions?
05:29:27 <devananda> but open to ohter ideas, too, if someone thinks another topic is better suited to that slot
05:29:51 <devananda> wanyen: that's my hope, because each of those projects will have a session fo rus
05:30:00 <wanyen> devananda, cinder integration and networking issues will not be discussed at the ironic sessions?
05:30:07 <rameshg87> oh. that's great.
05:30:31 <NobodyCam> devananda: do we know if all 200 seats will be dev's, or will there be other folk there too ie sales, etc
05:30:54 <wanyen> devananda, I see.
05:31:00 <devananda> I've already gotten the ok from mestery re: neutron session for us to discuss ml2 gateway plugin
05:31:11 <devananda> and the track in cinder seems to be on their radar as well
05:31:23 <devananda> ditto for a nova session on clustered hypervisors
05:31:26 <devananda> oh! that's not on our 'pad
05:32:11 <NobodyCam> devananda: line 281
05:32:15 <wanyen> devananda, are there any session with operators to gather input?
05:33:53 <devananda> wanyen: yes. the ops summit is hte place for that
05:34:07 <devananda> NobodyCam: we don't really control who's in the room, but the goal is for it to be ATC's only
05:34:37 <NobodyCam> devananda: ahh ok Ty :)
05:34:39 <devananda> the smaller rooms should be "just us devs" but the 2 fishbowls will probably attract a lot of others
05:35:05 * devananda adds "HA Nova compute nodes / Clustered Hypervisor Support [discuss in Nova track]" section to the 'pad
05:35:44 <devananda> NobodyCam: oh, thta's definitely not a topic for the fishbowl
05:36:35 <devananda> only a handfull of people understand nova's code well enough to reason about how to fix it. it'll be a working session between some nova-cores and some ironic-cores
05:38:18 <devananda> pshige: not sure what you mean by "special IRC meeting"
05:38:31 <pshige> 2nd meeting of SPEC Core, or something
05:39:03 <devananda> pshige: you mean related to summit schedule?
05:39:14 <pshige> yes
05:39:24 <devananda> nothing planned, aside from this
05:39:31 <devananda> we could certainly have one
05:40:12 <devananda> anyone want a separat emeeting to discuss the schedule before next monday?
05:41:01 <NobodyCam> we could
05:41:09 * devananda wonders if everyone's asleep, or just busy reading the 'pad
05:41:18 * mrda thinks it looks pretty good already
05:41:30 <devananda> mrda: :)
05:41:32 * rameshg87 thinks one week summit is not enough
05:41:58 <mrda> rameshg87: +1
05:42:03 <devananda> rameshg87: indeed
05:42:05 <pshige> rameshg87: +1
05:42:28 <devananda> also, I'm dead after a week of this already ...
05:42:49 <rameshg87> devananda: are we into next topic ?
05:43:01 <rameshg87> devananda: i wanted to share some updates on proliant ci
05:43:04 <devananda> I think we're done with this topic
05:43:22 <devananda> rameshg87: oh! ok. I was skipping driver updates today, but if you'd like
05:43:32 <rameshg87> devananda: okay. i will just go ahead with mine
05:43:43 <devananda> #topic open discussion
05:43:44 * naohirot I'm interested in proliant ci
05:43:59 <rameshg87> devananda: we have made some changes in devstack and tempest for this - there are about 5 in devstack and 2 in tempest
05:44:14 <rameshg87> devananda: i have tested and run ilo drivers with these changes and works fine
05:44:26 <rameshg87> devananda: i triggered a sandbox review and it ran - https://review.openstack.org/#/c/176253/
05:44:41 <rameshg87> looks for "HP Proliant CI check"
05:44:51 <rameshg87> it ran the test (took about 30 mins) -
05:45:38 <devananda> rameshg87: fyi, the link to artifacts is broken - http://127.0.0.1/53/176253/1/check/iscsi-ilo-bios-ci/6c65f33
05:45:46 <devananda> that's clerly not the right IP :)
05:45:48 <rameshg87> i am just working on that
05:45:56 <devananda> but that's awesome
05:45:59 <rameshg87> it doesn't have upload logs yet - because i don't have a place to upload logs :(
05:46:06 <rameshg87> yes
05:46:08 <rameshg87> yet
05:46:15 <devananda> can you summarize the changes you had to make to devstack & tempest?
05:46:25 <rameshg87> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IloDriverGateTesting
05:46:49 <rameshg87> tempest patches are there in bottom
05:46:50 <devananda> rameshg87: I hear that your company might run a public cloud  ... :)
05:47:20 <rameshg87> devananda: yeah just checking internally regarding that :)
05:47:37 <devananda> cool. lemme know if I can help
05:47:58 <rameshg87> sure, thanks
05:48:07 <rameshg87> devananda: important thing - i need ironic folks review on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/174733/
05:48:24 <rameshg87> lib/ironic changes in devstack for enabling ilo drivers for devstack
05:49:23 <devananda> #info iLO CI system passed a sandbox test, has several patches up to enable the work
05:49:29 <NobodyCam> lol gota love this error: http://logs.openstack.org/33/174733/6/check/check-grenade-dsvm-neutron/414fa90/logs/error.txt.gz
05:49:30 <devananda> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/174733/
05:49:59 <rameshg87> NobodyCam: yeah needs a recheck ? :)
05:50:25 <NobodyCam> :)
05:50:45 <NobodyCam> * ten minutes *
05:50:50 <rameshg87> devananda: i will continue working on it. if all internal formalities are complete, we should have it pretty soon.
05:51:16 <devananda> rameshg87: fantastic!
05:51:54 <devananda> anyone have anything else?
05:52:11 <NobodyCam> not me
05:52:15 <BadCub> nope
05:52:19 <pshige> nope
05:52:30 <Haomeng> devananda: nope
05:52:32 <devananda> oki doki - I'm happy to give everyone back 7 minutes :)
05:52:40 <NobodyCam> thank you all!
05:52:42 <devananda> g'night all! thanks!
05:52:46 <lintan> bye
05:52:50 <stendulker> bye
05:52:51 <cinerama> \o
05:52:52 <naohirot> good night
05:52:54 <rameshg87> goodnight / goodday
05:52:57 <pshige> devananda: good night
05:52:57 <Haomeng> good night
05:52:59 <kan__> bye
05:53:01 <NobodyCam> and thank you devananda for all the work ont the summit planning
05:53:07 <pshige> bye
05:53:10 <devananda> #endmeeting