18:00:11 <bh526r_> #startmeeting gluon 18:00:12 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Apr 12 18:00:11 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is bh526r_. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 18:00:13 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 18:00:15 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'gluon' 18:00:24 <bh526r_> #topic Roll Call 18:00:30 <bh526r_> #info Bin Hu 18:01:29 <krenczewski> #info Kamil Renczewski 18:01:41 <bh526r_> Hi Kamil 18:01:43 <jinli> Hi everyone 18:01:45 <georgk> #info Georg Kunz 18:01:47 <krenczewski> Hi Bin 18:01:47 <jinli> #info JinLi 18:01:55 <bh526r_> Hi Georg and Jin 18:02:16 <bh526r_> #topic Admin Update 18:02:29 <bh526r_> #info Our submission to Forum: 18:02:39 <georgk> hi all 18:02:49 <bh526r_> #link http://forumtopics.openstack.org/cfp/details/47 18:02:56 <bh526r_> #info was rejected 18:03:12 <bh526r_> #info details of reason can be found in above link 18:03:47 <bh526r_> #topic Status Update of PoC in OpenStack Summit 18:04:32 <bh526r_> #info 1. PoC Scenario Description was agreed a few weeks ago, and it stays the same 18:05:00 <bh526r_> #info But we need a documented demo script. Bin will draft it for everyone to review 18:05:21 <bh526r_> #action Bin draft demo script for PoC in OpenStack Summit 18:05:47 <bh526r_> #info 2. Lab in Germany - running stably 18:06:18 <bh526r_> georgk, do you want to add something more? 18:06:42 <georgk> yes, the Nova issues have been resolved 18:07:09 <bh526r_> #info Nova issue was resolved, and VM can be booted 18:07:09 <georgk> we had problems due to re-installing some OpenStack packages with pip while the services were running 18:07:18 <georgk> restarting the services solved the issue 18:07:41 <bh526r_> #info There were problems due to re-installing some OpenStack packages with pip while the services were running 18:07:51 <bh526r_> #info restarting the services solved the issue 18:08:18 <bh526r_> The dependency is always a headache 18:08:56 <bh526r_> #info 3. Contrail Status 18:09:35 <krenczewski> I was able to run Contrail 18:09:58 <bh526r_> #info Kamil was able to run Contrail 18:10:05 <krenczewski> and authenticate with keystone on 192.168.0.6 node 18:10:24 <bh526r_> #info and authenticate with keystone on 192.168.0.6 node 18:10:40 <bh526r_> So can Mechanism Driver work with Contrail now? 18:10:48 <krenczewski> problem was that one of interfaces was up without IP affress and zookeeper couldn't handle this 18:11:15 <krenczewski> Still need to resolve issue with Service Monitor service 18:11:26 <bh526r_> I see 18:11:30 <krenczewski> then I'll deploy mechanism driver 18:11:44 <bh526r_> #info Problem was that one of interfaces was up without IP affress and zookeeper couldn't handle this 18:12:01 <bh526r_> #info So still need to resolve issue with Service Monitor service 18:12:14 <bh526r_> #info Then Kamil will deploy Mechanism Driver 18:12:26 <bh526r_> Good progress, Kamil 18:12:30 <krenczewski> I don't want to do this without Contrail fully working because any issues woud be impossible to resolve 18:12:57 <bh526r_> That's right. So make sure Contrail fully working first. 18:13:18 <bh526r_> Then if there is any issue later, we can isolate the issue more easily 18:13:52 <bh526r_> Keep up your good work, Kamil. Thank you 18:14:02 <krenczewski> Thank you 18:14:26 <bh526r_> #info 4. L3VPN API - Parameter List for BGP Peering 18:14:54 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/450917/ 18:15:08 <bh526r_> #info Georg will update the patch based on Jin's comments 18:15:32 <bh526r_> #info 5. SFC YAML and API 18:15:57 <bh526r_> #info Georg is completing the draft, and under internal review 18:16:14 <bh526r_> #info Georg will submit this patch in a few days 18:16:35 <bh526r_> #info 6. P2P YAML and API 18:16:56 <bh526r_> #info Robert is working on it, and will submit the patch in a few days 18:17:12 <bh526r_> #info 7. ELAN YAML and API 18:17:36 <bh526r_> #info Eric has provided Ian with the ELAN YANG Model 18:17:56 <bh526r_> #info Bin will follow up with Ian on this subject 18:18:14 <bh526r_> #action Bin follows up with Ian on ELAN YAML and API 18:18:29 <bh526r_> #info 8. Misc 18:19:09 <bh526r_> #info There is a new patch to support all API YAML Models by default 18:19:21 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/456283/ 18:20:33 <bh526r_> #info Current code supports net-l3vpn as default. If we add new YAML model, we need to change proton.conf. If someone forgets to change proton.conf, even if new model is added, Proton Server will still only pick up net-l3vpn 18:22:15 <bh526r_> #info In order to improve usability and make adding new YAML model and API easier, this patch will support all models by default. Whenever a model is added, Proton Server will pick it up without having to change proton.conf 18:22:30 <bh526r_> #info All are encouraged to review and comment the code 18:23:04 <bh526r_> #info This will also make demo/PoC easier - only need to add/remove model, rebuild and restart proton-server without changing proton.conf 18:23:29 <bh526r_> any other thing / update for PoC? 18:24:31 <bh526r_> #topic Pike Release and Patches 18:24:52 <bh526r_> #info 1. New "Network Type" in Neutron 18:26:17 <bh526r_> #info Bin had conversation with Sukhdev yesterday. The idea that Sukhdev proposes will still lead to previous 2 RFEs, i.e. (1) optional Network and Subnet, and (2) new network characteristics attribute 18:27:31 <bh526r_> #info Sukhdev will document it, for further review and discussion. But previous 2 RFEs are needed based on conversation 18:27:52 <bh526r_> #info 2. Approved patches 18:28:14 <bh526r_> #info First is Remove unused import statements 18:28:29 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/446776/ 18:29:05 <bh526r_> #info It was approved and merged on March 22, and cherrypicked to stable/ocata (https://review.openstack.org/#/c/448775/) 18:29:25 <bh526r_> #info Second is Fixing DB test after sqlite_db config option was removed 18:29:38 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/451989/ 18:30:16 <bh526r_> #info It was approved and merged on March 31, and cherrypicked to stable/ocata (https://review.openstack.org/#/c/452268/) 18:30:35 <bh526r_> #info Third is Fixing broken import statement 18:30:49 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/451722/ 18:31:18 <bh526r_> #info It was approved and merged on March 31, and cherrypicked to stable/ocata (https://review.openstack.org/#/c/452357/) 18:31:34 <bh526r_> #info Fourth is Remove translation of log messages from gluon 18:31:54 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/453970/ 18:32:28 <bh526r_> #info It was approved and merged on April 6, and cherrypicked to stable/ocata (https://review.openstack.org/#/c/454286/) 18:34:33 <bh526r_> #info Fifth is Refined installation instructions 18:34:49 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/452980/ 18:35:28 <bh526r_> #info It was approved and merged on April 6, and cherrypicked to stable/ocata (https://review.openstack.org/#/c/454508/) 18:35:51 <bh526r_> #info Sixth is Base URI return values 18:36:03 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/453929/ 18:36:38 <bh526r_> #info It was approved and merged this morning (April 12), and cherrypicked to stable/ocata (https://review.openstack.org/#/c/456234/) 18:36:52 <bh526r_> #info 2. Outstanding Patches 18:37:06 <bh526r_> #info There are a few outstanding patches. 18:37:42 <bh526r_> #info Two were mentioned when we discussed PoC Status. Please review and comment 18:38:09 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/450917/ 18:38:28 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/456283/ 18:38:41 <bh526r_> #info Others include 18:39:03 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/453519/ 18:39:22 <bh526r_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/430446/ 18:39:42 <bh526r_> #info https://review.openstack.org/#/c/404069/ 18:40:15 <bh526r_> #info There are review comments and -1, so authors are expected to resolve the comments and update with new patches 18:40:36 <bh526r_> #topic AOB 18:40:45 <bh526r_> anything else you want to discuss? 18:41:28 <georgk> FYI: just pushed an update for the L3VPN model extension 18:41:42 <bh526r_> Great, and thank you Georg. 18:42:37 <bh526r_> I see Jin +1 18:42:43 <bh526r_> I suggest we approve it 18:44:10 <bh526r_> #info Georg updated the patch of Extending L3VPN model to configure BGP peerings. 18:44:29 <bh526r_> #info Group agreed to approve it, and Bin takes the action 18:45:02 <bh526r_> Anything else? 18:45:50 <bh526r_> If nothing else, we can adjourn the meeting and give back everyone 15 minutes 18:45:57 <bh526r_> #info Meeting adjourned 18:46:15 <bh526r_> thank you everyone, and bye all 18:46:19 <bh526r_> #endmeeting