18:00:21 <bh526r> #startmeeting gluon
18:00:22 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Mar 22 18:00:21 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is bh526r. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
18:00:23 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
18:00:25 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'gluon'
18:00:34 <bh526r> #topic Roll Call
18:00:44 <bh526r> #info Bin Hu
18:01:13 <pcarver> #info Paul Carver
18:01:31 <bh526r> Hi Paul
18:01:36 <pcarver> hi
18:01:51 <krenczewski> #info Kamil Renczewski
18:02:02 <bh526r> Hi Kamil
18:02:08 <krenczewski> Hi Bin
18:02:40 <bh526r> Georg is on a business trip, so he will miss the meeting today
18:02:54 <jinli> Hi everyone
18:02:58 <jinli> #info JinLi
18:03:05 <bh526r> Hi Jin
18:03:06 <robert_tao> Hi All! This is Robert
18:03:15 <bh526r> #info Admin Update
18:03:23 <bh526r> #topic Admin Update
18:03:34 <bh526r> Hi Robert
18:04:18 <bh526r> #info No update
18:04:34 <bh526r> #topic Bug Fix Patch
18:04:41 <bh526r> Let's discuss an easy one
18:05:07 <bh526r> #info Jin submitted a patch to remove unused import statements
18:05:22 <bh526r> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/446776/
18:05:35 <bh526r> Any comments?
18:06:09 <bh526r> #info Tin Lam commented, and Jin uploaded a patchset 2
18:06:45 <bh526r> Any objection to approve and mege it?
18:07:34 <bh526r> #info Team consensus is to approve and merge it
18:07:42 <bh526r> #info Bin will take the action
18:09:08 <bh526r> #topic PoC Status
18:09:34 <bh526r> #info (1) Lab Status
18:10:00 <bh526r> #info Gluon was deployed to Pharos Lab in Germany, and basic verification was done
18:10:28 <bh526r> #info Kamil is working on deploying Mechanism Driver for Contrail in the same OpenStack environment
18:11:03 <bh526r> #info to achieve the interoperability between Contrail and other SDN-Cs through Gluon
18:11:18 <bh526r> Kamil, any more update?
18:11:26 <krenczewski> I've fixed the env
18:11:37 <bh526r> great
18:11:44 <krenczewski> but Juniper node is still as deleted
18:12:13 <krenczewski> Georg suggest tu create another VM
18:12:16 <bh526r> Do you mean the Compute Node or the virt-manager node?
18:12:26 <krenczewski> I am nt sure how much resources I can assign to it
18:12:36 <krenczewski> The compute node
18:12:57 <bh526r> You can set up the virt-manager node first for Contrail
18:13:20 <krenczewski> I was trying to re-add the compute node, but Fuel complains about not able to sync time
18:13:29 <bh526r> I am sending you the spreadsheet that we discussed in December regarding resources for each SDN-C, including Contrail
18:13:37 <bh526r> I see.
18:13:40 <krenczewski> It is probably related to network config issure that I can't explain
18:13:56 <krenczewski> Thanks
18:13:59 <robert_tao> We are bringing up ONOS in the Huawei node, and will need to work with Georg on getting a BGP session with ODL
18:14:57 <krenczewski> Ok, so if Contrail is to use separate node outsize the fuel env
18:15:16 <krenczewski> then does we need its compute node?
18:17:26 <bh526r> Let me send you another architecture diagram of lab setup
18:18:49 <bh526r> Kamil, I sent you both the lab architecture diagram and sheet of resource allocation
18:19:01 <krenczewski> Got it, thank you
18:19:41 <bh526r> Under the same openstack environment, each SDN-C will run on a VM, which is managed by virt-manager
18:20:19 <bh526r> So SDN-C is outside of OpenStack environment. For example, Contrail is running separate on a VM of virt-manager
18:20:47 <bh526r> But Contrail's Mechanism Driver should be deployed in OpenStack Controller node
18:20:56 <krenczewski> correct
18:21:29 <bh526r> Then Mechanism Driver will work with Contrail that runs on a separate VM
18:22:37 <bh526r> Compute Node, which is part of OpenStack environment, will host the Guest VM, which attaches ports and networks managed by SDN-C
18:23:01 <krenczewski> Ok, got it
18:23:58 <bh526r> For example, user creates port and network via Contrail, and then boot a VM with that port and network on the Compute Node assigned to Contrail
18:24:39 <bh526r> The assignment of Compute Node is just to make sure that each participant has its resource to boot Guest VM
18:24:58 <bh526r> And not to over use others' resources
18:25:10 <krenczewski> OK
18:25:54 <bh526r> Ideally, we shouldn't care about Compute nodes. Whoever needs to boot VM, just boot it and let Nova to schedule it.
18:26:08 <bh526r> But our resources are very limited (CPU, RAM and disk)
18:27:04 <bh526r> So we have such resource allocation to make sure everyone has minimum resources to run its SDN-C and Guest VM within our very limited resource pool
18:27:50 <bh526r> Kamil, anything else do you need in order to continue and complete setup of Contrail with Gluon?
18:28:07 <krenczewski> I think that is all
18:28:11 <krenczewski> Thanks
18:28:24 <bh526r> Great, thank you Kamil. and look forward to hearing your good news
18:28:57 <bh526r> Then once Georg is back, he may help with the Compute Node issue.
18:29:35 <bh526r> #info Kamil gets necessary information to continue and complete the setup
18:29:46 <bh526r> Robert, are you still here?
18:29:58 <bh526r> How about your 2nd lab in Santa Clara?
18:31:29 <bh526r> Looks like we lost Robert
18:32:14 <bh526r> #info Status of 2nd Lab in Santa Clara is unknown. Will follow up with Robert
18:32:59 <bh526r> #info (2) L3VPN API - Parameter List for BGP Peering
18:33:22 <bh526r> #info Georg is on business trip. Will follow up with Georg once he is back to office
18:33:41 <bh526r> #info (3) SFC YAML
18:34:21 <bh526r> #info Georg mentioned in OPNFV NetReady meeting last week that someone has worked on a simple SFC YAML
18:34:35 <bh526r> #info We need more information. Need to follow up with Georg
18:34:54 <bh526r> #info (4) P2P YAML
18:36:04 <bh526r> #info Sukhdev and Ian had a very good discussion in Juniper on last Friday. Sukhdev will document the solution, which will naturally supports P2P
18:36:15 <bh526r> #info (5) Contrail Status
18:36:25 <bh526r> #info We already covered it. Thank you Kamil
18:36:43 <bh526r> #info (6) PoC Scenario Description
18:36:51 <bh526r> #info We already discussed it last week
18:37:00 <bh526r> #link http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/_gluon/2017/_gluon.2017-03-15-18.00.html
18:37:13 <bh526r> #info Bin will document it and put it on wiki
18:37:25 <Sukhdev_> Hi Folks
18:37:31 <bh526r> Hi Sukhdev
18:37:48 <Sukhdev_> Heard a ping on my laptop did not know what it was :-)
18:38:35 <bh526r> I mentioned that you and Iab had a very good discussion on last Friday, and you will document the solution.
18:38:42 <Roberttao> An update of the 2nd lab: I am putting hardware  together and will configure the topology next
18:38:59 <bh526r> I used your name "Sukhdev" in my message
18:39:18 <bh526r> perhaps it generated a "ping" in your laptop?
18:39:48 <Sukhdev_> haleyb : yes - that was it
18:39:56 <bh526r> Great, thank you Robert
18:40:02 <Sukhdev_> bh526r : If you need me, I will be around
18:40:25 <bh526r> Sure. I know you are busy, and will document it next week. So don't worry :)
18:42:00 <bh526r> #info Robert is back, and reported that he is putting hardware together for 2nd lab in Santa Clara, and will configure the topology next
18:42:55 <bh526r> OK, we have several items to follow up with Georg.
18:43:21 <bh526r> #topic Planning for Gluon Pike Release
18:43:26 <bh526r> #link Planning for Gluon Pike Release
18:43:36 <bh526r> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Gluon/Tasks-Pike
18:44:18 <bh526r> #info All please review and sign up
18:44:49 <bh526r> #topic Planning for Forum in Boston
18:45:07 <bh526r> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/BOS-UC-brainstorming-Telecom&NFV
18:45:37 <bh526r> #info Bin proposed a topic of "Containerized, Cloud Native Microservice in NFV Networking (Gluon)" there
18:45:59 <bh526r> #info Now the formal submission window is open.
18:46:12 <bh526r> #info Bin will work with Session Chair to get it submitted
18:47:06 <bh526r> #info This is an additional topic, besides a proposal of Service Modeling Method by Georg and Bin, which has been accepted for Summit
18:47:55 <bh526r> Does anyone else have new topics?
18:48:39 <ildikov> bh526r: hi
18:48:51 <bh526r> Hi ildikov
18:48:54 <ildikov> bh526r: we now opened the official submission for the Forum
18:49:04 <bh526r> Yes, that's great
18:49:07 <ildikov> bh526r: this is the form: http://forumtopics.openstack.org/cfp/create
18:49:21 <bh526r> Cool
18:49:35 <ildikov> bh526r: and here you can find guidelines and hints for proposals: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Forum
18:50:12 <bh526r> Sure. I will work with Jamey to submit it. Jamey is trying to organize the submissions
18:50:23 <ildikov> bh526r: it is important to have a moderator for the session you propose, so I wanted to reach out to you regarding the one that's on the etherpad already
18:51:00 <ildikov> bh526r: to give a heads up on the official proposal period and to ensure you are prepared to submit the session
18:51:27 <ildikov> bh526r: also one of the main purposes of the Forum is having discussions that involves both the developers and the users/operators
18:52:16 <bh526r> Thank you ildikov. Will "Telecom & NFV" be one session? Or each topic be a separate session?
18:52:43 <ildikov> bh526r: I think it will be separate
18:53:22 <bh526r> Cool. Do you have suggestion of the session chair/moderator for the session I proposed?
18:53:59 <ildikov> bh526r: so when you propose yours having the subject and goals as a standalone topic there would be the way to go
18:54:44 <ildikov> bh526r: and also try to highlight how the users will be involved in the discussion, what they will benefit and what you expect from them and what you wish to discuss
18:54:56 <ildikov> bh526r: will you or anyone from the team be there?
18:55:00 <bh526r> I see. Thank you for the hints.
18:55:09 <bh526r> Yes, I will be in Boston.
18:55:33 <ildikov> bh526r: would you be comfortable with moderating?
18:56:28 <bh526r> I should be fine. And usually it is better to have 2 moderators. Will you be able to help too if your time permits?
18:57:16 <ildikov> bh526r: yes
18:57:51 <ildikov> bh526r: I will need to look into the schedule as you pointed out, but I plan to attend the Telecom/NFV ones
18:58:11 <ildikov> bh526r: the deadline for submissions is April 2nd if I remember correctly
18:58:21 <bh526r> ildikov: great, thank you for help. So I will get it submitted as soon as possible (after talking with Jamey)
18:58:29 <ildikov> bh526r: feel free to ping me if you have any questions or need help before submitting
18:58:33 <bh526r> Yes, it is April 2nd
18:58:42 <bh526r> Sure, definitely Ildikov
18:58:45 <ildikov> bh526r: sounds great, thank you!
18:58:53 <bh526r> Thank you too
18:59:30 <bh526r> We are on top of the hours
18:59:36 <bh526r> That's all from my side
18:59:49 <bh526r> If nothing else, we can adjourn the meeting
18:59:56 <bh526r> #info Meeting adjourned
19:00:03 <bh526r> #endmeeting