15:00:43 <n0ano> #startmeeting gantt
15:00:44 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Mar 11 15:00:43 2014 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is n0ano. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:45 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:47 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'gantt'
15:00:55 <bauzas> \o
15:00:56 <n0ano> anyone here to talk about the scheduler?
15:01:12 <bauzas> hi
15:01:15 <lcostantino> hi
15:01:16 <PaulMurray> hi n0ano
15:02:28 <n0ano> I don't really have that much this week, we'll see what we come up with
15:02:34 <n0ano> boris-42, are you here?
15:03:26 <n0ano> looks like not much to say about the no-db scheduler this week
15:03:33 <bauzas> +1
15:03:40 <n0ano> #topic code forklift
15:04:02 <bauzas> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/icehouse-external-scheduler
15:04:14 <n0ano> I admit I haven't made much progress, I'm still working on splitting out the code (more as research) but not much progress this week
15:04:22 <bauzas> is johnthetubaguy here ?
15:04:43 * johnthetubaguy kinda half here
15:04:48 <bauzas> great
15:05:02 <bauzas> there are 2 bps for forklifting
15:05:10 <bauzas> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/remove-cast-to-schedule-run-instance
15:05:21 <bauzas> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/scheduler-lib
15:05:41 <johnthetubaguy> ah yes
15:05:51 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy: I made some comments within the 2nd bp, if you have some time to take a look, would be great
15:06:18 <johnthetubaguy> bauzas: I thought I commented on those, sorry missed the new ones!
15:06:29 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy: nah, no pb ;)
15:06:30 <johnthetubaguy> bauzas: want to chat about that now?
15:06:39 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy: if you have some time, yes :)
15:07:41 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy: as said, resource tracker is using _update() method for sending a call to the conductor
15:08:14 <PaulMurray> bauzas: resource_tracker is being updated to use objects
15:08:24 <PaulMurray> bauzas: makes a different conductor call
15:08:38 <bauzas> PaulMurray: could you please put it as dep for this bp ?
15:08:56 <johnthetubaguy1> bauzas: sorry, lost connection there, but back
15:09:04 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy1: no pbn
15:09:45 <bauzas> PaulMurray: could you please give us the bp link for use of objects within the resource tracker ?
15:09:55 <bauzas> PaulMurray: so I could put it as dependency for this one
15:10:13 <PaulMurray> bauzas - just a sec...
15:10:17 <bauzas> PaulMurray: sure
15:10:31 <PaulMurray> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/make-resource-tracker-use-objects
15:10:35 <bauzas> PaulMurray: is it FFE ?
15:10:56 <bauzas> PaulMurray: ok, adding as dep for https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/scheduler-lib
15:10:59 <PaulMurray> dauzas: didn't make it, but its part of a global move in nova
15:11:08 <PaulMurray> see also :
15:11:15 <bauzas> PaulMurray: ok, will take a look on it
15:11:33 <bauzas> PaulMurray: I'm planning to provide some draft by end of Icehouse
15:11:45 <bauzas> PaulMurray: so people could review it
15:12:26 <PaulMurray> ... was trying to find the main obects bp
15:12:35 <johnthetubaguy1> bauzas: should be bug fixing time though, might be worth waiting till Juno
15:12:37 <PaulMurray> forgot what its called - something like nova-objects
15:13:01 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy1: could you please add https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/make-resource-tracker-use-objects as dependency for https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/scheduler-lib ?
15:13:09 <n0ano> johnthetubaguy1, +1 (probably not much activity on antyhing but bugs for a while)
15:13:24 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy1: yey, I truly understand
15:13:39 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy1: but as newcomer in Nova, taking FF as opportunity for me
15:13:53 <johnthetubaguy1> bauzas: lots of bugs too ;)
15:14:20 <n0ano> johnthetubaguy1, odd, I though nova code was perfect :-)
15:14:22 <johnthetubaguy1> bauzas: updated that for you as a dep, although not totally sure if it is
15:14:44 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy1: ok thanks, will see if it is, yes
15:15:21 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy1: the thing is, if we say that resouce_tracker should use Gantt as lib for updating resource info, it should be dependent IMHO
15:16:14 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy1: unless I misunderstood :)
15:17:35 <johnthetubaguy1> bauzas: objects or db are not the nova side of the lib, so not too worried
15:18:00 <johnthetubaguy1> bauzas: key part is finding the good api, which may be what the objects work comes up with too
15:18:32 <bauzas> johnthetubaguy1: here why I need to perfectly understand your thoughts :)
15:20:00 <johnthetubaguy1> bauzas: not sure understanding my thoughts always helps, buy hey
15:20:05 <johnthetubaguy1> but^
15:20:13 <digambar> Hi, as I understand here anybody is working on above blueprint or we have planned Gantt after the IceHouse ??
15:20:29 <bauzas> digambar: this is the key thing
15:20:43 <digambar> okay
15:20:56 <bauzas> digambar: I'm planning to work on the said bp by end of Icehouse, but will only be a draft anyway
15:21:13 <digambar> okk
15:21:13 <bauzas> digambar: merges won't happen until Juno, as it's FF
15:21:29 <digambar> okk
15:21:44 <bauzas> n0ano: let's discuss btw about Gantt proposal for GSoC during #open topic
15:21:46 <n0ano> note that changes to nova code can happen whenever the tree opens, splitting out to gantt will take a little longer
15:21:53 <digambar> Is there anything I can contribute here ?
15:22:32 <n0ano> digambar, working on the BPs that we've mentioned here is always welcome
15:22:46 <digambar> cool
15:23:11 <digambar> The above blueprint right ?
15:23:41 <bauzas> digambar: atm, we're discussing about the interfaces for the above BP, that's it :)
15:23:57 <digambar> okk
15:23:59 <bauzas> digambar: please take a look at https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/icehouse-external-scheduler
15:24:11 <digambar> Thanks :)
15:24:18 <bauzas> bottom of the document
15:24:40 <bauzas> I think I'm done with my part
15:24:52 <n0ano> let's move on then
15:25:00 <n0ano> #topic icehouse BPs
15:25:17 <n0ano> Does anyone have any BPs targetted for Icehouse that we need to lobby effort for?
15:26:09 <n0ano> looks like no, moving on
15:26:12 <n0ano> #opens
15:26:21 <n0ano> bauzas, GSoC?
15:26:25 <bauzas> yup
15:26:39 <bauzas> I sent an email to -dev@
15:26:48 <bauzas> about GSoC proposals for Gantt
15:26:55 <n0ano> I thought your email layed it out well, anything to add?
15:27:07 <bauzas> I had no reply :)
15:27:18 <bauzas> so assuming it's either garbage or pure gold :)
15:27:46 <bauzas> lemme check the GSoC page
15:27:53 <bauzas> to see if Gantt is still proposed
15:27:55 <n0ano> I always assume silence mean people agree with me :-)
15:28:24 <bauzas> n0ano: sounds like it's not the case :)
15:28:26 <bauzas> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/icehouse-external-scheduler
15:28:28 <bauzas> oops
15:28:30 <bauzas> bad link
15:28:34 <bauzas> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/GSoC2014#Common_Scheduler_.28Gantt.29
15:29:01 <n0ano> I don't know who's in charge of the GSoC but you might want to find out who that is and send a specific message to him
15:29:12 <bauzas> ddutta: you there ?
15:30:45 <n0ano> looks like it'll have to be via email
15:30:51 <bauzas> n0ano: you're right, will directly send an email to the mentor
15:31:14 <bauzas> n0ano: I'm done
15:31:26 <n0ano> yeah, it's a wiki so it's easy enough to just delete that proposal but I'd clear via email first.
15:31:41 <bauzas> that's wise indeed :)
15:31:44 <n0ano> OK, any other opens for today?
15:32:50 <n0ano> hearing silence, tnx everyone and we'll talk again next week.
15:32:56 <bauzas> thanks :)
15:33:02 <n0ano> #endmeeting