14:01:41 <yushiro> #startmeeting fwaas
14:01:42 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Dec 21 14:01:41 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is yushiro. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:01:43 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:01:45 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas'
14:01:52 <yushiro> #chair SridarK yushiro xgerman_
14:01:52 <openstack> Current chairs: SridarK xgerman_ yushiro
14:01:57 <reedip_> we could always check the Meetings logs of last meeting :P
14:01:58 <SridarK> We had a quikc mtg last week
14:02:02 <SridarK> *quick
14:02:14 <yushiro> #topic Announcement
14:02:14 <xgerman_> ok, couple of announcements:
14:02:20 <SridarK> things slow due to holidays
14:02:29 <yushiro> xgerman_, go ahead :)
14:02:31 <xgerman_> OpenStack is planning 1 year cycles
14:02:51 <reedip_> but thats still in planning phase ...
14:03:15 <xgerman_> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2017-December/125688.html
14:03:18 <yushiro> yeah,  they are discussing in ML.
14:03:53 <reedip_> Good news .. more budget for travel ... bad news : More people for travel :P
14:04:21 <yushiro> OTOH, I remember that some people has suggested to 3 month per release.. not sure for now..
14:04:49 <xgerman_> yeah, I feel two PTG/One summit would be good but…
14:05:07 <reedip_> its opposite .. one PTG/2 summits ( isnt it ? 0
14:05:12 <xgerman_> yep
14:05:27 <SridarK> xgerman_: travel 4 times a year is a bit challenging
14:05:40 <yushiro> SridarK, +1  yes..
14:05:44 <xgerman_> +1
14:06:06 <xgerman_> next: Freenode changed the way it works and in order to DM you might need to sign up
14:06:40 <xgerman_> #link http://freenode.net/kb/answer/registration
14:06:57 <xgerman_> I ran into that the other day when I got a weird error DMing someone
14:07:50 <reedip_> sent registration :P
14:08:06 <xgerman_> :-)
14:08:10 <yushiro> Thanks for your info.
14:08:29 <reedip_> yeah, that was an interesting piece of info
14:09:11 <xgerman_> ok, those were the two things I had
14:09:18 <SridarK> ok one more
14:09:22 <yushiro> Thanks xgerman_
14:09:32 <SridarK> i think i will cancel the mtg next week
14:09:50 <SridarK> and we can still meet week after - even if it is a quick sync up
14:09:52 <xgerman_> +1
14:09:53 <reedip_> Yeah ... I second it, I would be driving  :D
14:10:00 <SridarK> What do folks think
14:10:00 <yushiro> +1  All of people take holiday I think :)
14:10:13 <SridarK> ok cool - i will send out an email
14:10:24 <SridarK> i think just next week is good
14:10:33 <SridarK> week after is likely to be slow too
14:10:35 <SarathMekala> +1
14:10:41 <SridarK> but we can meet who ever is around
14:10:44 <SridarK> and make it quick
14:10:57 <reedip_> I guess every team would be doing it next week ( they should declare it an Openstack Vacation )
14:11:05 <SridarK> :-)
14:11:23 <xgerman_> +1
14:11:28 <annp> +1
14:11:30 <yushiro> :)
14:11:31 <annp> :)
14:12:15 <yushiro> Thanks SridarK for an announcement.
14:12:41 <SridarK> yushiro: np pls go ahead thats all i wanted to confirm
14:12:49 <yushiro> SridarK, OK
14:13:00 <yushiro> OK, let's move on next topic.
14:13:04 <yushiro> #topic Queens
14:13:59 <xgerman_> Q-3 is 1/22 which is in 4 weeks or so
14:14:00 <yushiro> FYI: Queens-3 is 22th-26th Jan.  https://releases.openstack.org/queens/schedule.html
14:14:05 <xgerman_> +1
14:14:06 <yushiro> :)
14:14:16 <reedip_> make it 3 as next week is ... well Vacation
14:14:38 <yushiro> reedip_, +1  Yes.
14:14:38 <xgerman_> +1
14:15:08 <yushiro> So, we should focus on remaining patches --
14:15:18 <reedip_> yep
14:15:26 <yushiro> 1st: co-existing patch
14:15:26 <annp> +1
14:15:40 <yushiro> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/515368/
14:15:51 <yushiro> annp, Plz go ahead
14:16:43 <annp> yes, I'm waiting feedback from folks. :)
14:17:04 <xgerman_> ok, will install and test then ;-)
14:17:08 <SridarK> I am mostly ok on review - but i want to test some
14:17:15 <yushiro> annp, I WILL review :)
14:17:20 <annp> From my point of view, I think this patch almost fine. :)
14:17:29 <SridarK> annp: +1
14:17:31 <xgerman_> sweet
14:17:57 <annp> So lets test and review it.
14:18:26 <annp> Hopefully we can merged this patch in next week, then I can continue with remote group :)
14:18:46 <xgerman_> that would be awesome
14:18:55 <SridarK> annp: ok - i am out for a few days now but by mid next week - i can get some testing done
14:19:31 <annp> Sridark, xgerman, yushiro, Thanks in advance.
14:19:31 <xgerman_> I am out next week but will test before I take off…
14:19:31 <yushiro> annp, OK,
14:19:57 <annp> reedip, Can you give us a hand? :)
14:20:04 <annp> reedip, Can you help us a hand? :)
14:20:23 <SridarK> annp: pls populate our l2 test etherpad with any info we will need
14:20:55 <SridarK> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/fwaas-v2-l2
14:21:01 <yushiro> SridarK, +1
14:21:45 <SridarK> I think there is some info already
14:21:56 <xgerman_> +1
14:22:01 <annp> SridarK, +1.
14:22:03 <yushiro> In addition, could you help me some grammar check for https://review.openstack.org/#/c/515368/15/releasenotes/notes/coexistence-between-sg-and-fwg-1f77a755539a9463.yaml ?
14:22:16 <SridarK> yushiro: ok
14:22:20 <annp> yushiro: :)
14:22:36 <yushiro> I'm not good at reviewing about grammar :)
14:22:42 <yushiro> Thanks
14:23:14 <SridarK> yushiro: no worries i will check it
14:23:26 <reedip_> where ???
14:23:39 <reedip_> I can try to test, for sure
14:24:09 <yushiro> reedip_, https://review.openstack.org/515368
14:24:09 <xgerman_> yeah, let’s get some coverage…
14:24:11 <reedip_> I can review the reno , if required
14:24:18 <yushiro> reedip_, +1
14:24:28 <yushiro> OK, next
14:24:39 <annp> reedip, thanks.
14:24:45 <yushiro> Add configurable option for default_fwg association: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/475183/
14:25:08 <yushiro> I'll update this patch with annp's comment.
14:25:36 <yushiro> by using callback functionality.
14:25:40 <annp> yushiro, +1
14:26:13 <yushiro> So, we can implement it in plugin layer.
14:27:31 <xgerman_> neat
14:27:50 <yushiro> :)
14:28:11 <annp> :)
14:28:46 <yushiro> OK, that 2 patches need to be merged ASAP.
14:28:54 <SridarK> +1
14:29:00 <xgerman_> +1
14:29:13 <xgerman_> ASAP=before the holodays?
14:29:34 <SridarK> I can do the testing next week
14:29:47 <SridarK> so maybe if we can target by end of next week ?
14:29:54 <yushiro> xgerman_, Yes, I hope.  I and annp and hoangcx can work on 28th.
14:30:17 <yushiro> Therefore, those 2 patches should be merged until next week.
14:30:22 <yushiro> SridarK, +1
14:30:25 <SridarK> ok
14:30:28 <annp> +1
14:30:44 <reedip_> +!
14:30:50 <xgerman_> yeah, you can ping me if you need me during next week
14:31:24 <yushiro> xgerman_, Ok, thanks.  At first, I'll ping you "merry x'mas" :)
14:31:24 <annp> xgerman_, +1
14:31:57 <xgerman_> :-)
14:32:17 <SridarK> xgerman_: i can send u a text if needed
14:32:33 <xgerman_> I have irc on my phone ;-)
14:32:42 <SridarK> xgerman_: oh boy
14:32:45 <SridarK> :-)
14:32:49 <annp> =))
14:33:09 <yushiro> So, after next year, I think we will focus on 'remote_fwg' and doude's patch.
14:33:17 <SridarK> +1
14:33:21 <xgerman_> +1
14:33:33 <yushiro> fwaas logging is bump to Rocky.
14:33:46 <annp> How about netlink conntrack for fwaas v2?
14:33:59 <SridarK> i think other things would be to get some testing done and hopefully some tempest
14:34:03 <yushiro> annp, Ah, yes.  it is.
14:34:05 <SridarK> and Horizon updates
14:34:12 <yushiro> yes.
14:34:31 <annp> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/527044/
14:34:37 <SridarK> +1
14:34:54 <annp> But I think it not urgent :)
14:35:03 <reedip_> fullstack as well :P
14:35:14 <yushiro> remote_fwg, doude's one, horizon, tempest, netlink, fullstack.
14:35:33 <xgerman_> sounds good
14:35:39 <SridarK> its a bit of a tall order - but lets make a push
14:35:59 <xgerman_> especially if the next release is a 1 year one
14:36:06 <yushiro> SridarK, indeed, it is challenge..
14:36:21 <annp> xgerman, +1 :)
14:37:03 <yushiro> and sorry I couldn't review SPEC.  I'll also review.  Sorry for late review, bzhao.
14:37:37 <yushiro> Currently, I have to join some training for my company so much...
14:37:39 <SridarK> oh yes
14:38:37 <reedip_> kk
14:38:37 <yushiro> OK, I'll write down in our weekly etherpad for our target.
14:38:43 <SridarK> +1
14:38:44 <xgerman_> +!
14:38:45 <xgerman_> +1
14:38:53 <yushiro> OK, next topic
14:39:01 <yushiro> #topic Horizon support
14:39:03 <xgerman_> I also think at this point it doesn’t make sense to start new features
14:39:21 <SarathMekala> Updated list of enhancements for Horinzon @ https://docs.google.com/document/d/1yKreFzwHsp-TMhB1xDH-EhGHBTGawFAaG1x6ukGJUK4/edit#heading=h.qbs4js7vw5tv
14:39:35 <yushiro> xgerman_, +1
14:39:45 <SarathMekala> please review and give me your inputs
14:40:25 <SridarK> SarathMekala: ok
14:40:27 <yushiro> SarathMekala, +100
14:40:27 <SarathMekala> some enhancements are straight forward and can be taken up for Queens-3
14:40:43 <SridarK> ok
14:40:43 <yushiro> SarathMekala, is it OK to put comment on google doc ?
14:40:49 <reedip_> ok
14:41:04 <SarathMekala> yes.. please update it if you want
14:41:52 <SarathMekala> A few enhancements require using angular framework.. we can take them up later
14:42:25 <yushiro> SarathMekala, OK.
14:43:19 <SarathMekala> i did not get a cxhance to monitor bugs on horizon
14:43:30 <SarathMekala> will do it during next week
14:44:17 <yushiro> SarathMekala, OK.  I'll also check some existing bug about 'drag&drop' selection.
14:44:57 <SarathMekala> sure Yushiro..
14:45:09 <yushiro> SarathMekala, anything else about dashboard ?
14:45:24 <SarathMekala> thats it from my side
14:45:43 <yushiro> SarathMekala, OK.  Thanks for your great doc :)
14:45:47 <xgerman_> +1
14:45:52 <yushiro> #topic Stadium Compliance
14:46:50 <yushiro> is there any updates?
14:46:51 <reedip_> ok, fullstack is pending. Most of the neutron-lib migration has already been pushed
14:47:37 <yushiro> reedip_, OK
14:47:57 <reedip_> yushiro : can you provide the etherpad link for fwaas meeting ? I am not aqble to get it on the browser history
14:48:10 <yushiro> reedip_, https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/fwaas-meeting
14:48:19 <reedip_> thanks
14:49:04 <reedip_> nothing else to add for now... we can move in
14:49:08 <reedip_> on *
14:49:08 <yushiro> OK
14:49:25 <yushiro> oh, 10 minutes left
14:49:35 <yushiro> #topic Open Discussion
14:50:54 <reedip_> Well, I pushed for DSCP for FWaaS
14:51:30 <annp> reedip_, +1
14:51:31 <reedip_> was also considering pushing out ToS based filtering for FWaaS but wanted to know how the community feels
14:51:32 <yushiro> reedip_, could you paste the link ?
14:51:43 <reedip_> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1738738
14:51:44 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1738738 in neutron "[Neutron][Firewall] Extend FWaaS to provide DSCP filtering" [Undecided,New] - Assigned to Reedip (reedip-banerjee)
14:52:15 <reedip_> Now this would have an extended functionality because Neutron is allowing DSCP on the outer header of a VxLAN based packet
14:53:20 <reedip_> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1692951
14:53:21 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1692951 in neutron "[RFE] DSCP mark on the outer header" [Wishlist,In progress] - Assigned to Ali Sanhaji (ali-sanhaji)
14:54:32 <SridarK> reedip_: As a security feature - DSCP based filtering - i will need to think abt - more of a QoS feature
14:54:34 <xgerman_> this is for filtering only — so we won’t tag…
14:55:07 <yushiro> reedip_, I think it is similar to handle QoS.
14:55:07 <xgerman_> SridarK somebody might use DSCP to tag his L7 traffic
14:55:55 <xgerman_> so they don’t have to DPI everywhere… but that’s pretty exotic
14:56:05 <SridarK> xgerman_: ok yes agreed but i would think more as QoS
14:56:14 <xgerman_> +1
14:56:30 <reedip_> hmm
14:56:34 <yushiro> +q
14:56:40 <yushiro> oops
14:57:10 <annp> +1
14:57:12 <SridarK> but lets look at it
14:57:19 <reedip_> anything else to be added ???
14:57:39 <yushiro> reedip_, I'll also take a look.
14:57:46 <SridarK> There were some issues on DVR - i spoke to Swami for more details - reedip_ i think u had looked at that too
14:57:47 <yushiro> 3 minutes
14:58:28 <SridarK> more like issues on FWaaS with DVR - i am looking more as we may not be aligned with some of the latest changes on DVR
14:58:52 <SridarK> reedip_: pls add the DSCP to the fwaas meeting etherpad so we track it
14:58:53 <reedip_> sure ...
14:59:00 <reedip_> anmyways Merry Christmas guys :)
14:59:04 <yushiro> +1
14:59:15 <xgerman_> +1
14:59:16 <reedip_> I did but not concluded my findings
14:59:21 <SridarK> oh Yes Merry Xmas, Happy Holidays all
14:59:25 <reedip_> need soome time ( and I lack it right now )
14:59:28 <yushiro> Yes, folks Merry  X'mas
14:59:41 <SridarK> reedip_: no issues i will sync with u later as i find somethibng
14:59:45 <SridarK> *something
14:59:52 <reedip_> good night folks... and a happy new year in case we dont meet earlier
15:00:00 <SridarK> Bye all Thanks for attending
15:00:03 <yushiro> BTW, thanks SridarK for last weekly meeting :)
15:00:04 <reedip_> sure SridarK, I will be here :)
15:00:09 <SridarK> yushiro: np
15:00:12 <SarathMekala> Bye all O/
15:00:16 <yushiro> OK, see you guys !
15:00:20 <yushiro> #endmeetnig
15:00:24 <xgerman_> bye
15:00:28 <yushiro> #endmeetings
15:00:34 <xgerman_> Happy NY.
15:00:40 <yushiro> oh ?
15:00:44 <yushiro> #endmeeting