14:02:18 <yushiro> #startmeeting fwaas
14:02:19 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Jun 27 14:02:18 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is yushiro. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:02:20 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:02:20 <SridarK> sure
14:02:22 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas'
14:02:32 <yushiro> #chair SridarK yushiro xgerman_
14:02:33 <openstack> Current chairs: SridarK xgerman_ yushiro
14:02:45 <yushiro> #topic Pike
14:02:54 <SridarK> i can take over at any time too
14:03:04 <SridarK> yushiro: ok pls go ahead
14:03:16 <yushiro> SridarK, sure :)
14:03:30 <yushiro> L2-support
14:03:37 <SridarK> one update from chandan - he is still out on personal leave
14:03:59 <SridarK> when he has a few mins - he will try to ping
14:04:11 <SridarK> so we can help out and pick up some things
14:04:27 <SridarK> i think we can proceed with integration with his latest PS
14:04:44 <SridarK> perhaps we can work out the kinks with integration while he is away
14:05:13 <yushiro> SridarK, sorry.  I couldn't rebase his patch last week.
14:05:35 <yushiro> SridarK, Maybe it is necessary to migrate neutron-lib for some constant value.
14:05:50 <SridarK> yushiro: no worries - i got busy this week too
14:06:03 <SridarK> yushiro: lets talk maybe tomorrow or on Wed
14:06:10 <yushiro> Yes.
14:06:39 <SridarK> we can attempt a plugin - L2Agent - Driver integration
14:06:47 <SridarK> and then add in Horizon
14:07:44 <yushiro> OK
14:08:01 <xgerman_> cool!
14:08:24 <reedip_> for neutron-lib , well, http://logs.openstack.org/16/443416/8/check/gate-networking-midonet-python27-ubuntu-xenial/ef6756c/console.html is still failing
14:08:24 <yushiro> In l2 part, sorry I couldn't work last week.
14:08:59 <yushiro> reedip_, thank you so much for working about this !!
14:09:03 <yushiro> reedip_, will take a look
14:09:21 <reedip_> yushiro : well but I am not able to get midonet working with current fwaas
14:09:42 <xgerman_> ok, so revert until we know what’s up?
14:10:09 <amotoki> is this a issue about the extension name vs the service plugin name? Not sure it is related to L2-support.
14:10:15 <reedip_> yes, that would be better
14:10:24 <amotoki> separate topic?
14:10:34 <xgerman_> can you give us the link again and I will +2 right away
14:10:37 <reedip_> amotoki : yes, extension name vs service plugin name for neutron-lib migration
14:10:55 <reedip_> https://review.openstack.org/471699
14:11:02 <yushiro> amotoki, separate topic.  it relates neutron-lib migration.
14:11:12 <reedip_> xgerman_ , SridarK ^^
14:11:23 <amotoki> so you can't break the existing implementation. if you cannot fix it soon, it looks better to revert it.
14:11:31 <reedip_> yushiro , you also please +2 it so that we can revert it for now
14:11:38 <reedip_> amotoki : agreed
14:11:39 <SridarK> reedip_: ok
14:11:41 <yushiro> reedip_, OK, +2 now
14:11:51 <yushiro> aha, reedip_ could you paste a link ?
14:11:57 <amotoki> feel free to ping once you all are fine.
14:12:02 <amotoki> i can approve it.
14:12:07 <reedip_> yushiro : Patch for review : https://review.openstack.org/471699
14:12:35 <amotoki> sorry. it is neutron-fwaas patch.
14:13:01 <yushiro> done done :)
14:13:51 <SridarK> reedip_: thanks for working thru things
14:14:04 <SridarK> reedip_: lets continue forward so we can get this back
14:14:09 <yushiro> reedip_, Yes, thank you!!
14:14:19 <reedip_> SridarK : yep
14:14:32 <reedip_> I will take it up again once the revert is merged
14:14:43 <SridarK> reedip_: lets discuss more when we are on that topic
14:14:52 <reedip_> Sure
14:15:00 <xgerman_> SridarK +1
14:15:18 <yushiro> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/425769/
14:15:56 <yushiro> Default fwg, I was got a comment from yamamoto.  I'll reflect his comment in this week.
14:16:14 <yushiro> I'll refer security group implementation.
14:16:51 <yushiro> Ok, let's move on.
14:17:02 <yushiro> Next,  Neutron-lib adoption: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/421472/   /  https://review.openstack.org/456511
14:18:56 <reedip_> you know the update
14:19:03 <reedip_> :)
14:19:08 <yushiro> yeah
14:19:12 <yushiro> So,
14:19:16 <reedip_> nothing else to add, so moving on ?
14:19:22 <yushiro> OK.
14:19:24 <yushiro> move on.
14:20:05 <yushiro> Next, Horizon support:  https://review.openstack.org/#/c/475840/
14:20:09 <SridarK> reedip_: lets set some time for debugging
14:20:26 <sarathmekala__> hi all.. I missed out to checkin one fine
14:20:27 <SridarK> perhaps we can combine some time for L2 integ and neutron-lib
14:20:34 <SridarK> Wed or later
14:20:40 <reedip_> SridarK : let me know when you , xgerman_ and yushiro are free
14:20:43 <sarathmekala__> thanks amotoki for pointing it out
14:20:44 <SridarK> sorry back to topic
14:20:45 <amotoki> it looks better to discuss horizon support as a dedicate topic
14:20:47 <reedip_> Thu seems fine from my side
14:21:04 <xgerman_> yeah, I am around most of the time
14:21:11 <SridarK> cool
14:21:37 <sarathmekala__> amotoki.. I will be checking in the api/fwaas_v2.py file now
14:21:47 <sarathmekala__> please take a look
14:22:05 <amotoki> is there any other topic on Pike other than horizon ?
14:22:15 <amotoki> i think #topic horizon is better
14:22:29 <yushiro> ah, OK, change the topic.
14:22:38 <yushiro> #topic horizon
14:22:53 <sarathmekala__> cool..
14:23:02 <yushiro> sarathmekala__, Ok, please go ahead :)
14:23:08 <amotoki> as you may know, neutron-fwaas-dashboard repo has been setup.
14:23:34 <amotoki> sarathmekala__ already proposed a patch of fwaas v2 support
14:23:39 <SridarK> amotoki: thanks
14:23:49 <amotoki> before moving on, i have several things to be announced.
14:24:02 <amotoki> the first thing is the repository setup.
14:24:15 <amotoki> the core team is neutron-fwaas-core + horizon-core at now.
14:24:38 <amotoki> second, it is now a part of neutron stadium. the governance patch was approved today.
14:24:46 <amotoki> https://governance.openstack.org/tc/reference/projects/neutron.html
14:25:01 <amotoki> you can see neutron-fwaas-dashboard here.
14:25:22 <xgerman_> Yeah!!
14:25:25 <amotoki> third, fwaas v1 dashboard split out are almost done.
14:26:20 <yushiro> thank you for telling us.  That's a good news.
14:26:25 <amotoki> as part of the initial effort, i self-approved my several patches, but I would like you all to check the final one https://review.openstack.org/476413 to confirm it works well.
14:26:43 <xgerman_> amotoki dashboard doesn’t have any tags - is that intentional?
14:26:48 <igordcard> so is this the recommended way of adding horizon support for neutron stadium projects now? use a separate repo for the project's horizon?
14:26:57 <xgerman_> yep
14:27:18 <amotoki> answering one by one
14:27:38 <amotoki> xgerman_: we can update the tag(s) once it is setup properly.
14:27:59 <amotoki> xgerman_: I intentionally added no explicit tag in the first inclusion patch.
14:28:06 <xgerman_> ok, I think we need a few of them to be considered for. a release
14:28:22 <amotoki> xgerman_: i think it is better to be discussed as a community like here.
14:29:55 <amotoki> igordcard: most horizon support for advanced services (expcet the main horizon repo) will be implemented in separate repos and it will be part of neutron stadium
14:30:20 <amotoki> we did the same thing for neutron-lbaas-dashboard (now it is under octavia though)
14:30:23 <igordcard> amotoki: thanks
14:30:39 <amotoki> features in the main neutron repo will go to the main horizon repo.
14:31:07 <amotoki> that's all from me on the dashboard repo.
14:31:18 <amotoki> sarathmekala__: now your turn :)
14:31:19 <yushiro> amotoki, thanks!!
14:31:51 <sarathmekala__> amotoki.. thanks for your comment
14:31:54 <xgerman_> we should probably keep an eye on the tags. My understanding is fuzzy but I knoew there are ramnification when it comes to releasing
14:32:09 <sarathmekala__> I have missed out that file... will add it to the review
14:32:30 <sarathmekala__> I have one question
14:32:47 <yushiro> OK
14:32:51 <amotoki> sarathmekala__: go ahead
14:32:58 <sarathmekala__> if we follow the procedure mentioned in https://review.openstack.org/#/c/476413/ it will work for V2 as well right
14:33:31 <sarathmekala__> i meant the dashboard part
14:33:50 <sarathmekala__> enable_plugin neutron-fwaas-dashboard https://git.openstack.org/openstack/neutron-fwaas-dashboard <<V2 reference here>>
14:34:11 <amotoki> sarathmekala__: you need to update devstack/plugin.sh to enable neutron-fwaas-v2-dashboard.
14:34:30 <amotoki> sarathmekala__: at now, fwaas v1 and v2 are exclusive.
14:35:00 <sarathmekala__> ok.. thanks.. I will check that code
14:35:07 <amotoki> sarathmekala__: looking at https://github.com/openstack/neutron-fwaas-dashboard/tree/master/devstack i think you can know what we need to do.
14:35:27 <amotoki> sarathmekala__: feel free to ping me if you have questions.
14:35:38 <sarathmekala__> cool.. thanks
14:36:40 <amotoki> if no more questions or topics, i think we can move on.
14:36:42 <SridarK> sarathmekala__: u can follow a similar model for v2 vs v1 as in basic devstack setup
14:37:07 <sarathmekala__> thanks SridarK, I figured out the same :)
14:37:09 <SridarK> amotoki: thx for helping out on this
14:37:35 <xgerman_> +1
14:37:44 <amotoki> you're welcome. i hope you sometimes all check -dashboard
14:37:49 <yushiro> +100
14:37:52 <amotoki> *reviews
14:38:08 <SridarK> +1
14:38:27 <sarathmekala__> Sure +1
14:38:56 <sarathmekala__> thats it from my side.. yushiro please move on
14:39:15 <yushiro> sarathmekala__, OK, thanks.
14:39:36 <yushiro> #topic Stadium Compliance
14:40:05 <yushiro> anything else to discuss?
14:40:09 <reedip_> neutron-lib needs to be re-published
14:40:36 <reedip_> and fullstack tests have been expermintally enabled but are failing because they are accessing  a wrong folder in gate. Need to relook at it
14:40:55 <reedip_> Once fullstack is done, then atleast we can check that out of the To-Do list
14:41:25 <yushiro> reedip_, thank you.
14:41:55 <reedip_> for neutron-lib, once the revert merges, I will incrementally make the same changes as done in the earlier patch and watch out for the midonet tests
14:42:14 <reedip_> I hope @yamamoto enables the tests in midonet though, they disabled them earlier
14:42:21 <SridarK> reedip_: ok hopefully with this and once we are able to fix things to undo the revert - we are all done
14:42:36 <reedip_> SridarK : Need to check the FwaaS report once
14:42:47 <SridarK> reedip_: yes and also long term - we need to be able to integrate with Midonet CI
14:42:49 <reedip_> It would have the To-Do items
14:43:13 <SridarK> unfortunately there is no easy way for us to know that we could have broken something in Midonet
14:43:24 <xgerman_> :-(
14:43:29 <yushiro> hmm, yes..
14:43:56 <SridarK> we need to work with yamamoto and fix that so we dont go thru this cycle again
14:43:58 <reedip_> Well, thats true
14:44:07 <reedip_> yes SridarK
14:44:38 <amotoki> midonet job (non-voting?) for fwaas patches? (if we really need it)
14:44:38 <SridarK> i am sure we can find some way for a solution
14:44:53 <SridarK> yes that would be a good start
14:45:16 <reedip_> amotoki : we can have that , but need to see how to enable the same in gate
14:45:41 <amotoki> i think yamamoto is glad to help you
14:46:25 <SridarK> amotoki: +1 i am sure we can find some thing quick with yamamoto's help
14:46:27 <amotoki> midonet runs their CI using openstack-ci so it is relatively simple. it can be done just by a project-config update
14:47:17 <SridarK> ok that should make things simple
14:47:37 <reedip_> hmm, lets have a look and put up a NV job if possible
14:47:53 <xgerman_> +1
14:48:01 <yushiro> Yes, it's useful for us to trigger fwaas patch with networking-midonet
14:49:13 <reedip_> shall we move on ?
14:49:14 <yamamoto> hi
14:49:25 <yushiro> OK.
14:49:29 <yushiro> #topic performance improvement
14:49:45 <yushiro> hoangcx_, anything else to mention?
14:50:11 <yamamoto> if you let me know what exactly you want to run in the nv job, i can submit a patch.
14:50:21 <xgerman_> o/
14:52:18 <yushiro> Ok
14:52:26 <yushiro> 8 minutes left.
14:52:28 <yushiro> #topic Open Discussion
14:52:37 <SridarK> yamamoto: thx
14:52:46 <yushiro> yamamoto, thank you
14:52:55 <yamamoto> np. thank you for taking care of midonet.
14:52:59 <reedip_> SridarK, yushiro, xgerman_ we can have the meeting on Thursday 0200 UTC ( same time )
14:53:15 <SridarK> yamamoto: yes will be good to see what would be the minimal set of things as u see fit so we dont break midonet in the future
14:53:35 <SridarK> at least if we see anything we can quickly check back with u
14:53:57 <yushiro> reedip_, yes, sure.
14:54:10 <SridarK> reedip_: thx that works, 24 hrs before is also fine
14:54:20 <amotoki> are you changing the meeting time?
14:54:42 <SridarK> amotoki: not for this mtg - we were just setting a time to debug some things
14:54:46 <reedip_> amotoki : no, we are setting up a time for some of the open issues to be handled
14:54:57 <amotoki> SridarK: reedip_: i see, thanks
14:54:59 <yushiro> reedip_, in #openstack-fwaas is OK?
14:55:06 <SridarK> yes
14:55:06 <reedip_> meeting point will be neutron-fwaas, as always
14:55:13 <reedip_> yushiro : yes
14:55:20 <yushiro> OK
14:56:04 <amotoki> btw, i am planning to setup gerrit bot which post comments to #-fwaas when a fwaas or fwaas-dashboard patch is posted.
14:56:18 <amotoki> does it sounds good for you or sound annoying?
14:56:23 <reedip_> amotoki : yes, that works ... we generally miss the patches otherwise
14:56:28 <yushiro> amotoki,  +1
14:56:39 <yushiro> it is useful for us.
14:56:50 <reedip_> but I would like the cores to vote on that :)
14:57:13 <sarathmekala__> +1
14:57:14 <SridarK> agreed
14:57:41 <amotoki> thanks. I will propose a project-config change and add the cores to reviews
14:58:02 <yushiro> +1
14:58:09 <reedip_> btw igordcard wanted to mention that the Common Classifier Framework has merged : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/333993/
14:58:27 <igordcard> yep, thanks reedip_ !
14:58:33 <reedip_> igordcard : if you have anything to add, go ahead
14:58:40 <yushiro> wow, congrats!! igordcard
14:58:58 <igordcard> the spec merged 10 days ago, I believe we've reached a good enough consensus there
14:59:06 <igordcard> a first batch of code will be submitted before pike-3
14:59:23 <igordcard> to the neutron-classifier repo: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/project:openstack/neutron-classifier
14:59:24 <reedip_> +1 igordcard
14:59:33 <amotoki> igordcard: is it targeted for Queen release?
14:59:57 <amotoki> igordcard: anyway it will be helpful to start relevant reviews!
15:00:04 <igordcard> and consuming services, potentially fwaas can start to look at how to consume the CCF after that initial batch of code
15:00:14 <reedip_> times up guys :)
15:00:21 <yushiro> wow, 0:00
15:00:30 <yushiro> #endmeeting