14:00:06 <xgerman> #startmeeting fwaas
14:00:07 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Mar 14 14:00:06 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is xgerman. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:08 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:11 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas'
14:00:23 <xgerman> #chair SridarK yushiro xgerman njohnston
14:00:23 <openstack> Warning: Nick not in channel: SridarK
14:00:24 <openstack> Warning: Nick not in channel: yushiro
14:00:25 <openstack> Current chairs: SridarK njohnston xgerman yushiro
14:00:45 <njohnston> o/
14:00:51 <blallau> Hi all
14:00:54 <chandanc> hello all
14:00:56 <vks1> hi all
14:01:00 <SridarK> Hi All
14:01:02 <xgerman> hi
14:01:06 <hoangcx> hi
14:01:23 <xgerman> #topic Announcements
14:01:39 <xgerman> Our FWaaS talk has been accepted in Boston!!
14:01:50 <SridarK> +1
14:01:59 <chandanc> yes :)
14:02:07 <hoangcx> +1
14:02:14 <njohnston> Congrats!  I am very happy for you and more than a little bit jealous. :-)
14:02:37 <SridarK> njohnston: understandably so and thx :-)
14:02:52 <xgerman> can’t you get there with a car? We van probably shore up an ATC code or a speaker code for you ;-)
14:03:14 <SridarK> xgerman: indeed :-)
14:04:31 <njohnston> They won't let me off work :-(
14:04:33 <d0ugal> o/
14:04:48 <xgerman> :-(
14:04:57 <xgerman> ok, moving on
14:05:06 <xgerman> #topic Pike
14:05:19 <xgerman> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/fwaas-pike Pike cycle priorities list.
14:06:45 <xgerman> Yushiro wrote to us: "Currently, I'm reaching out to Iwamoto who contributes OVS native firewall.
14:06:45 <xgerman> Second, my co-worker annp can help OVS native firewall driver because
14:06:45 <xgerman> he is working with me for logging API implementation.  He knows OVS native
14:06:45 <xgerman> field and can advise to Chandan and others.  Last week I told annp about that
14:06:45 <xgerman> and he will send e-mail to us.”
14:07:01 <xgerman> (he can’t attend today)
14:07:39 <SridarK> that is good to have some more expertise to reach out to
14:07:46 <xgerman> =1
14:07:58 <SridarK> now chandanc is back from PTO - we should get some traction
14:08:11 <xgerman> we were talking about discussion OVS deeper this meeting but I think we might need to defer again
14:08:29 <chandanc> Yes, i just started reading through the links on OVSFW driver
14:08:35 <SridarK> xgerman: yes lets do that next week so chandanc has some time to catch up
14:08:58 <xgerman> ok, sounds good.
14:09:01 <SridarK> chandanc: shall we plan to run thru a tentative task list next week and scope next week ?
14:09:25 <xgerman> I think we need to do some architecture work, too, e.g. if we want our own tables…
14:09:26 <chandanc> SridarK, xgerman thanks, i have some catch up to do but from the first look this looks much cleaner then the IPTables one
14:09:39 <xgerman> +2
14:09:40 <SridarK> xgerman: +1
14:09:57 <SridarK> chandanc: yes that seems to be the case
14:10:43 <chandanc> we have some work to do about the abstraction and to enable co existance
14:10:57 <xgerman> yep
14:11:09 <chandanc> I should be able to start discussing the details during this week
14:11:34 <SridarK> chandanc: from what little we got in discussion with Jakub we will allocate a table for FWaaS and will have a jump entry from say SG
14:11:58 <SridarK> chandanc: sounds good
14:12:14 <chandanc> Yes, i agree, but there are some differences in the way OVS handles ACCEPT rules and Connection Tracking
14:12:15 <xgerman> well, we should do the entry independent of SG for those who don’t want SG but FWaaS
14:12:26 <chandanc> anyways lets discuss that over mails
14:12:31 <xgerman> ok
14:12:57 <chandanc> I will summarize the findings in mail
14:13:01 <xgerman> +1
14:13:03 <SridarK> ok
14:13:28 <xgerman> Having njohnston here should we chat about neutron-lib adoption?
14:13:58 <vks1> chandanc, pls include me also in email
14:14:06 <xgerman> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/421472/
14:14:17 <chandanc> sure vks1
14:14:37 <vks1> thnx
14:15:19 <njohnston> yes, so reedip_ has stepped in with https://review.openstack.org/#/c/421472/ and I am very grateful
14:15:40 <njohnston> I may have a few minutes today to try and see where the error is occurring that is breaking the tests for that change
14:15:55 <xgerman> that would be great
14:16:03 <SridarK> njohnston: thx, looks like reedip_ is not on
14:19:01 <xgerman> mmh, I think #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/425769/ is ready
14:19:44 <xgerman> but let’s wait for guidance form Yushiro
14:20:13 <SridarK> xgerman: yes and we did decide that this will be only for L2
14:20:22 <xgerman> ok
14:20:48 <xgerman> same with https://review.openstack.org/#/c/424534/
14:21:27 <xgerman> still looking for somebody who loves Horizon…
14:21:48 <xgerman> and can write a plugin for us ;-)
14:22:17 <xgerman> anyhow, moving on…
14:22:23 <SridarK> xgerman: SarathMekala is to work on that
14:22:34 <xgerman> ok, cool!!
14:22:50 <xgerman> #topic FWaaS v2
14:22:51 <SridarK> chandanc: can u pls ping Sarath to see how that is looking
14:23:00 <xgerman> +1
14:23:04 <chandanc> Sure SridarK i will followup on that
14:23:08 <SridarK> thx
14:23:09 <xgerman> thanks
14:24:21 <xgerman> I think V2 hinges on the OVS firewall mostly…
14:24:37 <SridarK> xgerman: +1
14:24:53 <xgerman> #topic Stadium Compliance
14:25:25 <xgerman> I see a lot of reedip on that one…
14:26:11 <SridarK> yes, i think the obvious ones are the API moving to neutron-lib and fullstack tests
14:26:41 <xgerman> yep, I am a bit out of touch with neutron (probably need to start to attend their meetings)
14:27:14 <reedip> o.
14:27:17 <xgerman> hi
14:27:18 <reedip> o/
14:27:20 <reedip> sorry
14:27:24 <xgerman> no worries
14:27:38 <reedip> just came back from office
14:28:15 <SridarK> reedip: good timing the IRC to brain wave converter is working ... :-)
14:29:47 <reedip> hain ??? Oh .. got it ... :D
14:32:33 <reedip> SridarK : what can I update for ?
14:32:46 <xgerman> stadium compliance
14:32:52 <reedip> I dont know the last message except xgerman missing a bunch of meetings :)
14:33:13 <xgerman> ok, we were talking about stadium compliance
14:33:32 <SridarK> reedip: oh yes sorry - we were just discussing the API moving to neutron-lib and fullstack
14:33:33 <xgerman> https://review.openstack.org/394619
14:33:39 <SridarK> u were looking at both of them
14:33:40 <reedip> oh , ok . Well FWaaS OSC is all ready but as amotoki mentioned in #openstack-meeting, filtering during lists is a bit of an issue
14:33:51 <reedip> so that we may need to check and see
14:34:00 <xgerman> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron_lib_fwaas_punchlist
14:34:27 <reedip> SridarK : I pushed a couple of patches last week and following up with boden's progress in neutron-lib to push for patches where they are possible.
14:34:40 <amotoki> reedip: FWaaS OSC plugin uses neutroncleint python binding, so I think it works for FWaaS OSC commands. right?
14:34:42 <reedip> Fullstack , i will look this week
14:34:42 <SridarK> reedip: sounds good
14:35:00 <reedip> amotoki : I guess it should. We need to check :)
14:35:37 <reedip> its an action item for me and yushiro  ( if he is around and if he has some time to help me )
14:36:12 <SridarK> reedip: yushiro is out today but u can ping him tomorrow
14:36:42 <reedip> I will SridarK
14:39:05 <xgerman> thx
14:39:22 <xgerman> #topic performance improvement for v2
14:40:17 <xgerman> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/443121/
14:41:00 <hoangcx> xgerman, As i informed in last weekly meeting that my peer will investigate it
14:41:09 <xgerman> ok, cool
14:41:10 <hoangcx> xgerman, his IRC is cuongnv
14:41:22 <blallau> @german thank you
14:41:31 <hoangcx> xgerman, and tuhv is going to enjoy another trip
14:41:42 <xgerman> :-)
14:42:05 <hoangcx> xgerman, So, It would be good if the team can help to review the remaing patches on v1
14:42:24 <xgerman> ok
14:42:41 <hoangcx> xgerman, thanks :-)
14:42:46 <SridarK> blallau: on 443121 - waiting on yamamoto to make sure things are good with Midonet
14:43:37 <blallau> same issue on v2 :(
14:43:38 <hoangcx> the patches on v1 is waiting for review :-)
14:43:59 <hoangcx> s/is/are
14:44:09 <blallau> I will fix it in the following days
14:44:38 <blallau> I just waiting for v1 to be merged
14:45:02 <SridarK> blallau: yes agreed
14:46:05 <xgerman> ok
14:46:27 <xgerman> #topic bugs
14:49:25 <xgerman> #link  http://urx2.nu/C7UI
14:50:46 <SridarK> I am not sure that there is some critical issues that popped up recently
14:51:06 <SridarK> but we should clean up some of the old ones
14:52:18 <xgerman> yes, we need to do some spring cleaning - especially review the undecided
14:52:54 <xgerman> if we have something confirmed or in progress we should know the severity :-)
14:53:22 <reedip> I volunteer for some spring cleaning :)
14:53:25 <SridarK> xgerman: +1
14:53:33 <vks1> vks1, me too
14:54:02 <reedip> vks1 : hi
14:54:14 <vks1> reedip hi
14:54:29 <reedip> any more volunteers ???
14:54:34 <xgerman> great!!
14:54:39 <SridarK> reedip: i can help too
14:54:45 <xgerman> me, too
14:54:52 <xgerman> but there are “only” 27 bugs
14:54:56 <reedip> SridarK : ok, cool....
14:55:22 <reedip> xgerman : first lets find those not allocated to anyone
14:55:23 <reedip> :)
14:55:30 <SridarK> i think if we "sit together" we may be able to find that some of that may be relevant
14:55:33 <xgerman> indeed
14:55:45 <SridarK> * may not be relevant
14:56:03 <xgerman> #topic Open Discussion
14:56:10 <reedip> SridarK : same time tomorrow on neutron-fwaas channel  for Bug meeting ?
14:56:23 <xgerman> sure, will work for me
14:56:25 <SridarK> reedip: yes that should work
14:56:29 <vks1> vks1, +1
14:56:32 <vks1> +1
14:57:00 <reedip> Ok , then tomorrow same time on #neutron-fwaas channel , we would go through the bug list
14:57:13 <cuongnv> hi, I have a ps to fix a bug related to port range in filter (no launchpad ticket) https://review.openstack.org/#/c/443385/, it's great if someone can help to review
14:57:14 <SridarK> reedip: do u want to do as same time as start of the fwaas mtg ?
14:57:22 <reedip> DId anyone give any presentation in Boston ?? ( Open discussion )
14:57:23 <SridarK> i know u sometimes are driving
14:57:38 <reedip> SridarK : I am in philippines for the next one month :D
14:57:47 <SridarK> ok :-)
14:57:49 <reedip> So, I wont be driving for some time
14:58:13 <SridarK> we should really push for having some basic L2 support and Horizon done b4 Boston
14:58:23 <SridarK> will be good to show a demo in the talk
14:58:37 <SridarK> and Horizon makes it more appealing
14:58:39 <reedip> cuongnv : nice of you to push the patch. We will look at it :)
14:58:41 <chandanc> +1
14:58:55 <reedip> I may not join in boston
14:58:57 <cuongnv> thx reedip (:
14:59:10 <xgerman> SridarK +!
14:59:29 <SridarK> reedip: oh
15:00:23 <xgerman> ok, time
15:00:27 <xgerman> #endmeeting