17:00:36 <Kiall> #startmeeting Designate
17:00:39 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Feb 18 17:00:36 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is Kiall. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:40 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:43 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'designate'
17:00:47 <Kiall> Hey folks - Who's here?
17:00:49 <timsim> o/
17:00:52 <rjrjr> o?
17:00:53 <vinod1> o/
17:00:58 <paul_glass> o/
17:00:58 <mugsie> o\
17:00:59 <Kiall> rjrjr: is that a maybe? ;)
17:01:07 <timsim> Hook for a hand
17:01:17 <elarson__> o/
17:01:18 <Kiall> ah - pirate rjrjr is here!
17:01:19 <mugsie> we have a pirate in our midst ;)
17:01:40 <Kiall> So - Agenda is light  today....
17:01:51 <Kiall> #topic Action Items from last week
17:02:26 <Kiall> cores: (mugsie,Kiall,vinod1): get https://review.openstack.org/#/c/149428/ merged
17:02:26 <Kiall> I finally got to review that today, we've been in crunch mode since we got back to the office at HP..
17:02:27 <jmcbride> 0/  oye!
17:02:33 <Kiall> jmcbride: heya :)
17:02:58 <Kiall> Jim Meyer had good things to say about you last week ;)
17:03:09 <mugsie> pc just died -_- brb
17:03:18 <Kiall> vinod1 / mugsie - did you guys just get a chance to review ^?
17:03:30 <jmcbride> Ah, I know Jim! I hope he's having lots of fun there - he is a good guy.
17:03:40 <rjrjr> i'm concerned that patch will never get released.  i also don't have the time to address these problems as they come like this anymore.
17:03:51 <rjrjr> this thing has been drawn out for almost a month now.
17:04:52 <Kiall> Yea - It's taken ages :( I'm hoping we can land it soon, just having a hard time really understanding / tracing though the code - I'm guessing it's the same for the others/
17:05:22 <rjrjr> why were those concerns not brought up the first 2 or 3 times this code was reviewed though?
17:05:58 <rjrjr> i could have addressed them at once instead of one or two changes spread over 4 weeks.
17:06:26 <timsim> I believe I did on PS 4.
17:06:29 <Kiall> Things were simplier the last time I had a chance to review it (and +2 it!), but I can't speak to the others.
17:07:29 <timsim> How about we action folks to review that, and if rjrjr doesn't have time to make the changes, appoint someone to fix it up? it's gotta be close.
17:07:59 <rjrjr> i think having someone else take this one over is a great idea!  i have to move on...
17:08:03 <vinod1> rjrjr: If you are busy, I can take a look at making the changes
17:08:04 <Kiall> We asked everyone to review it last week, but I only got an oppertunity a few hours ago
17:08:30 <Kiall> Sure - I can offer up the same, but It's Monday before I have hours in the day again
17:08:47 <Kiall> (We're in the final few days pretting a release..)
17:08:51 <Kiall> prepping*
17:09:15 <rjrjr> i want to get to some of the other bugs we have outstanding.
17:09:27 <timsim> Well, vinod1 and Kiall you guys can fight that out amongst yourselves then :) and we'll all try and get it reviewed in the next couple days?
17:09:42 <Kiall> Sounds good, I also want to get the pools API stuff we started at the mid-cycle done + dusted..
17:10:09 <Kiall> So - if vinod1 want's to take up the torch on #149428, i can pick that up again come Monday :
17:10:17 <vinod1> ok Kiall
17:10:33 <vinod1> We also need to get to ekarlso's changes - They have been pending for a long time too
17:10:42 <Kiall> Yep, he hates me ;)
17:11:31 <Kiall> I've asked him to try keep them up to date till k2 was done, and the release were doing at HP was done (from our teams POV)..  We've been planning to get to them after that
17:11:59 <vinod1> ok
17:12:25 <ekarlso> still not MERGED ?
17:12:27 <ekarlso> ...
17:12:37 <Kiall> On a related note, we (all) have to get better at keeping reviews small - We've talked about it for a long time, but every large review sits in the queue for months without merge
17:13:02 <ekarlso> i tried to keep it small...
17:13:19 <ekarlso> but someone (not to mention names) wanted docs etc in the same change..
17:13:22 <Kiall> So - We really have to figure out how to make it easier to do small patches etc
17:13:29 <rjrjr> i agree.  i offered to break this one up, but timsim suggested it was okay because we were all in a room looking at this one at the time.
17:13:59 <Kiall> everyone have their pitchforks pointed at timsim? ;)
17:14:04 * timsim hides
17:14:28 <ekarlso> so when will my change get attention rly? I've rebased over 30 times..
17:14:42 <Kiall> yes - see my note above ;)
17:14:51 <rjrjr> i don't feel bad anymore.  i think i've only rebased a few times. :)
17:15:10 <Kiall> myself and mugsie are still locked up with the release, that ekarlso person decided to have a baby instead of help us with it ;)
17:15:20 <ekarlso> HAHA :P
17:15:22 <Kiall> but that should be done+dusted this week..
17:15:39 <Kiall> Anyway - Something to keep in mind, small reviews merge.. large ones takes months of review! Let's move on ;)
17:16:10 <Kiall> other action was "mugsie email -dev list about sprint" .. Was done..
17:16:11 <Kiall> #topic Kilo Release Status (kiall - recurring)
17:16:19 <Kiall> #link https://launchpad.net/designate/+milestone/kilo-3
17:16:43 <mugsie> the 2 bp's ned to be bumpeed
17:16:50 <mugsie> no way they are getting in
17:17:17 <Kiall> I have that code buried on my laptop from the first time I implemented them, just have to dig it out and refresh.
17:17:34 <Kiall> k3 is ~ 1month away, so no need top bump just yet.
17:17:48 <Kiall> (k3 is March 19th)
17:18:35 <Kiall> Re the bugs - We've lots open at the moment (more Open/In Progress than committed)
17:19:23 <Kiall> So - Thoughts on trying to whittle that list down? :)
17:19:40 <mugsie> #1411442 can be bumped
17:19:49 <mugsie> oh, no bot
17:20:00 <Kiall> bug 1411442
17:20:01 <openstack> bug 1411442 in Designate "Central Unit Tests need improvment" [Medium,Incomplete] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1411442 - Assigned to Graham Hayes (grahamhayes)
17:20:04 <Kiall> ;)
17:20:40 <Kiall> Anyway - I meant more along the lines of getting them assigned and fixed ;)
17:21:14 <Kiall> Should we concentrate on the pool reliability review first, then reevaluate the list? I think many will be fixed as part of that..
17:21:36 <mugsie> yeah, a lot of them are around that
17:21:40 <timsim> Yeah definitely. We might have some bandwidth over here to get some of those done.
17:21:51 <mugsie> timsim: cool, that would be great
17:22:58 <Kiall> Okay, let's see where we are next week after landing the PM reliability review :)
17:23:09 <timsim> Cool.
17:23:19 <Kiall> #topic Bug triage (timsim - recurring)
17:23:23 <Kiall> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/designate/+bugs?search=Search&field.status=New
17:23:30 <timsim> So there's just two bugs in need of triage
17:23:37 <timsim> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/designate/+bug/1416337
17:23:38 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1416337 in Designate "Designate server create with concurrent request is not listing all servers even after successful creation." [Undecided,New]
17:23:50 <timsim> Has anyone had a chance to try and reproduce this?
17:24:11 <mugsie> yeah, I had a quick look, and couldnt reproduce
17:24:19 <Kiall> That was filed by our QA department
17:24:24 <Kiall> Oh
17:24:24 <Kiall> No
17:24:45 <Kiall> We have the same ticket internally - lol
17:24:46 <mugsie> but I am open to it actually being a bug, but i am not sure what is happening to cause it
17:24:58 <Kiall> I was sure they filed that upstream when I saw it -_
17:25:08 <timsim> It seems possible that this person may be running Juno or something, I don't think they say.
17:25:23 <timsim> Should we mark it incomplete and ask for more information?
17:25:48 <Kiall> Yea, ideally that script they have and the version there running would be useful
17:25:58 <Kiall> If mugsie and timsim have tried + failed to reproduce, we'll need that
17:25:59 <mugsie> and the DB that is in use
17:26:17 <mugsie> if its something like SQLite, that might cause it
17:26:29 <timsim> Alright, we agreed on marking incomplete and asking for more information (DB, Designate version, script)?
17:26:38 <Kiall> Yep...
17:26:42 <timsim> Cool
17:26:45 <timsim> I'll do that
17:26:49 <timsim> https://bugs.launchpad.net/python-designateclient/+bug/1415560
17:26:50 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1415560 in python-designateclient "python-designateclient does not work against an non Keystoned designate" [High,New]
17:26:51 <rjrjr> agreed
17:27:31 <Kiall> mugsie: ^ bug was one you filed
17:27:35 <mugsie> yup
17:27:47 <mugsie> it can go to triaged, and assigned to me
17:27:48 <Kiall> I'm guessing that means "Triaged" rather than "New" then? ;)
17:28:03 <timsim> Agreed. Milestone?
17:28:04 <mugsie> i forgot the extra steps after creation
17:28:08 <mugsie> none for client
17:28:18 <Kiall> No milestones used in the client projects :)
17:28:37 <mugsie> they just get released from time to time
17:28:37 <timsim> Well there you go then
17:29:11 <Kiall> Okay - That was the lot of new ones this week? 2 isn't bad ;)
17:29:42 <Kiall> #topic Open Discussion
17:29:42 <Kiall> As I said, agenda was light today - So, open discussion. Any off agenda items?
17:30:01 <timsim> I'd like to introduce elarson_, he's new on our team, you'll be seeing a lot of him around :)
17:30:02 <jmcbride> I have one item.
17:30:08 <Kiall> jmcbride: shoot :)
17:30:14 <timsim> Haha, beat ya jmcbride
17:30:16 <jmcbride> timsim beat me to the punch!
17:30:19 * elarson_ waves
17:30:31 <mugsie> elarson_: welcome!
17:30:38 <Kiall> lol - stone jmcbride's thunder.. nice :)
17:30:42 <Kiall> and welcome elarson_ :)
17:30:47 <elarson_> thanks all!
17:31:03 <jmcbride> elarson_ wrote cachecontrol, plays bass in a band and likes long walks in the  park…
17:31:03 <Kiall> I saw your "I'm here" at the start and thought ekarlso had a new IRC nick ;)
17:31:20 <ekarlso> haha :p
17:31:42 * elarson_ also wondered if vinod1 was just a poor typist ;)
17:31:56 <Kiall> lol
17:32:09 <Kiall> elarson_: so, you started this week?
17:32:20 <elarson_> Kiall: yes, just yesterday
17:32:40 <Kiall> Ah - Give it time, timsim's really not as bad as he seems at first ;)
17:32:44 * Kiall hides
17:32:52 <mugsie> he's worse ;)
17:32:54 <Kiall> Anyway - Welcome :)
17:32:57 <elarson_> thanks :)
17:33:02 <timsim> Man I am on under the microscope today
17:33:13 <Kiall> So - Any other topics?
17:33:16 <mugsie> timsim: is happens
17:33:19 <mugsie> it*
17:33:19 <timsim> At least I still got one over on jmcbride, so it's not a total loss ;)
17:33:50 <Kiall> Oh - 1 other from me..
17:33:57 <Kiall> There's a bunch of Designate related talks at the summit
17:33:59 <Kiall> VOTE ;)
17:34:05 <timsim> OH yeah
17:34:18 <Kiall> https://openstack.org/vote-vancouver/
17:34:37 <Kiall> and - tell your friends and grandparants and so on to vote too ;)
17:35:20 <timsim> #link https://www.openstack.org/vote-vancouver/presentation/dnsaas-with-designate-in-production
17:35:21 <timsim> #link https://www.openstack.org/vote-vancouver/presentation/challenges-architecture-and-solutions-for-massive-scale-lbaas-deployment-at-ebaypayal
17:35:21 <timsim> #link https://www.openstack.org/vote-vancouver/presentation/designate-interactive-workshop-install-and-operate-2
17:35:21 <timsim> #link https://www.openstack.org/vote-vancouver/presentation/dns-for-your-cloud-openstack-designate
17:35:21 <timsim> #link https://www.openstack.org/vote-vancouver/presentation/adopting-designate-for-managing-mission-critical-ebaypaypal-dns
17:35:22 <timsim> #link https://www.openstack.org/vote-vancouver/presentation/dns-for-your-cloud-openstack-designate
17:36:05 <Kiall> Okay - If there's nothing else then, let's call it a day!
17:36:18 <Kiall> Except for the TX folks, your only starting ;)
17:36:50 <Kiall> Thanks all!
17:36:50 <Kiall> #endmeeting