09:00:22 <priteau> #startmeeting blazar
09:00:24 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Jun 18 09:00:22 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is priteau. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
09:00:25 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
09:00:27 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'blazar'
09:00:29 <priteau> #topic Roll call
09:00:35 <masahito> o/
09:00:39 <priteau> Hi masahito
09:01:46 <tetsuro> o/
09:01:51 <priteau> Hi tetsuro
09:03:14 <priteau> I think Bertrand should be back from holiday today.
09:03:55 <bertys> o/
09:03:56 <priteau> Hi bertys
09:04:03 <priteau> Topics for today
09:04:05 <bertys> Hi all
09:04:05 <priteau> 1. Code review priorities
09:04:09 <priteau> 2. Floating IP reservation
09:04:21 <priteau> 3. Placement API integration
09:04:24 <priteau> 4. AOB
09:04:35 <priteau> #topic Code review priorities
09:05:50 <priteau> There's been some discussions on Asmita's patches
09:06:06 <priteau> It would be good to get more input on it, it's a fairly big change
09:06:17 <priteau> https://review.opendev.org/#/c/637140/
09:06:19 <priteau> https://review.opendev.org/#/c/655837/
09:07:56 <priteau> tetsuro: it would be nice to get your opinion in particular on the usage of the placement client in https://review.opendev.org/#/c/637140/
09:08:16 <tetsuro> Yes, will have a look, sorry for being late
09:09:11 <priteau> No problem
09:10:05 <priteau> Also, minor patch from me for fixing the gate when requirements change: https://review.opendev.org/#/c/663946/
09:10:13 <priteau> Thanks for the review tetsuro
09:11:06 <priteau> And the same change in other repos: https://review.opendev.org/#/c/663949/ and https://review.opendev.org/#/c/663950/
09:13:08 <priteau> If we can approve these requirements fixes today, we will be able to merge again patches that change requirements
09:14:46 <priteau> Thanks masahito for the review
09:15:56 <masahito> np
09:17:44 <priteau> tetsuro and bertys, could you please review these patches that don't yet have a W+1?
09:18:53 <tetsuro> Done
09:20:38 <priteau> Perfect, thanks!
09:20:44 <priteau> Let's move to the next agenda item
09:20:49 <priteau> #topic Floating IP reservation
09:22:14 <priteau> masahito: Are you able to work on the remaining action items for floating IP reservation?
09:22:49 <masahito> yes. I've working on it since yesterday.
09:25:35 <priteau> Great!
09:26:07 <priteau> On Chameleon they've been using floating IP reservation and have noticed some issues that they are fixing. I will track them and share with you.
09:26:55 <priteau> I think they're separate to what you're working on
09:27:00 <masahito> okay, thanks. Reporting a bug is useful to track it :-)
09:27:30 <priteau> Yes it will go on Launchpad
09:28:26 <priteau> Looking forward to review your patches
09:30:02 <priteau> #topic Placement API integration
09:30:46 <priteau> tetsuro: Can you share what's next for integration with placement?
09:32:50 <tetsuro> 1. instance reservation via nova (almost done, what’s left is to consider allocation_ratio)
09:32:50 <tetsuro> 2. host reservation via nova
09:32:50 <tetsuro> 3. instance(baremetal) reservation via nova + ironic
09:32:52 <tetsuro> 4. baremetal  reservation ironic stand reservation
09:33:32 <tetsuro> 4. baremetal reservation via ironic stand alone
09:33:51 <priteau> Are you planning to work on them in this order? Do you need help on a specific one?
09:34:49 <tetsuro> Well, 2 is heavy but what we get from this is just clean up
09:35:40 <tetsuro> 1 is already planned so I guess 1 -> 4 -> 3 -> 2 order is appropreate
09:36:48 <tetsuro> I'll have a time to repropose https://review.opendev.org/#/c/578641/ to the current spec repo
09:37:50 <tetsuro> which describes what is left for 1. instance reservation via nova (almost done, what’s left is to consider allocation_ratio)
09:37:55 <priteau> Does it make sense to prioritize 4 though? Ironic stand alone is not deployed widely.
09:38:34 <tetsuro> Sure, if you want I can start a spec
09:39:03 <priteau> I think host or instance reservation via Nova+Ironic would have more impact
09:39:27 <tetsuro> Oh sorry I misunderstood
09:39:47 <priteau> Also if we need changes from Nova (new request filter?) they would need to be requested soon before specs freeze
09:40:29 <tetsuro> then 1 -> 3 -> 4 => 2, at least for 1 we don't need any request filters.
09:42:02 <priteau> 2. is the current host reservation but without filter?
09:42:54 <tetsuro> If you meant "without BlazarFilter" yes, that is it.
09:43:25 <priteau> Yes, that's what I meant
09:44:32 <priteau> Sounds like a good plan then!
09:45:49 <priteau> Anything else to discuss on this topic?
09:48:05 <tetsuro> I would appreciate if I could have feedback(traceback) from someone trying Nova+Ironic reservation with *current* instance plugin
09:48:48 <tetsuro> Before I move to 3 from 1 since I'm not familiar with Ironic.
09:49:09 <tetsuro> But, meh, if you have time or if you find someone interested in.
09:49:53 <tetsuro> That's all from my side
09:49:55 <priteau> I'll ask Chameleon folks if I can get it from them. They use host reservation but they have a dev environment that could be configured with instance reservation specifically for this
09:51:14 <tetsuro> Good to know
09:51:19 <priteau> #topic AOB
09:51:40 <priteau> Anything else to share today?
09:52:32 <masahito> nothing from my side
09:53:15 <priteau> Reminder that the CFP for the Shanghai summit is open until early July
09:53:24 <priteau> #link https://www.openstack.org/summit/shanghai-2019
09:54:53 <priteau> Project updates are requested separately, closer to the summit
09:55:22 <priteau> We should start thinking about it though. Should we request a project onboarding session this time?
09:56:41 <priteau> And who's planning to be there?
09:57:39 <tetsuro> I'm coming to Shanhai
09:57:49 <bertys> priteau: need to check internally first
09:57:57 <masahito> I haven't decided to go there yet.
09:58:15 <priteau> I might be there especially since I missed the last one in Denver. I will know closer to the date.
09:58:55 <priteau> Less than 4 hours flight from Tokyo, I am jealous!
09:59:31 <masahito> haha. right. It's very closed.
09:59:54 <tetsuro> :)
09:59:56 <priteau> We're out of time for today. Have a good week everyone, thanks for joining.
10:00:01 <priteau> #endmeeting