15:01:36 <matrohon> #startmeeting bgpvpn
15:01:37 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Apr 19 15:01:36 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is matrohon. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:01:38 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:01:41 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'bgpvpn'
15:01:50 <matrohon> hi all
15:02:22 <matrohon> hi timirnich, pcarver_ tmorin
15:02:23 <tmorin> hi everyone
15:03:06 <timirnich> hi all
15:03:26 <timirnich> enikher: are u on?
15:03:44 <matrohon> let's wait few minutes more
15:03:56 <matrohon> timirnich, enikher is supposed to attend?
15:04:14 <timirnich> tmorin, just checking - not necessarily
15:04:28 <timirnich> matrohon, sorry for the name confusion ;-)
15:04:54 <timirnich> folks I have to multiplex between here and the OPNFV release call - ping if delayed response
15:05:07 <matrohon> timirnich, fine
15:05:13 <matrohon> ihrachys, hi
15:05:24 <ihrachys> matrohon: hi. what's up.
15:05:50 <matrohon> #topic release management with reno
15:06:23 <matrohon> ihrachys, we want to use reno as our release note generation tool
15:06:47 <matrohon> ihrachys, I saw your comment on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/307140/
15:06:55 <ihrachys> sure. but in liberty, you don't have anything with those notes?
15:07:27 <matrohon> ihrachys, actually I think we should add the material to have notes for liberty too
15:07:54 <matrohon> ihrachys, and I followed what happened in other projects :
15:07:57 <ihrachys> matrohon: ok, and another question is why it's a liberty only patch.
15:08:59 <matrohon> ihrachys, well, because this patch only introduces a note to say that we are starting to use reno in liberty
15:09:15 <ihrachys> matrohon: there was no such patch in mitaka?
15:09:31 <matrohon> ihrachys, then we are going to backport https://review.openstack.org/#/c/307150/
15:09:43 <matrohon> ihrachys, ^ the patch for mitaka
15:10:18 <matrohon> and in a third step, we will add notes of what has been done in liberty, in stable liberty
15:11:03 <ihrachys> ok, I don't really mind as long as you plan to extend it.
15:11:08 <ihrachys> I will merge it.
15:11:42 <matrohon> ihrachys, thanks, I dumbly follow the way reno has been introduce for neutron and others
15:12:26 <matrohon> ok let's sum up what we are talking about now :)
15:13:08 <matrohon> as timirnich asked last meeting, we need to release the bgpvpn project along with release notes
15:13:40 <matrohon> reno is here to help us, and a lot of openstack project are using it now
15:14:10 <tmorin> tmorin: yes, it looks like useful, a clean way to manage release notes
15:14:20 <matrohon> so I introduced the reno tool in bgpvpn here : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/307046/
15:15:01 <tmorin> matrohon: good -- what is missing now ? only a bit of real content, right ?
15:15:32 <matrohon> now if we want to add release notes, we just have to use reno to generate a file that we add to networking-bgpvpn/releasenotes/
15:15:41 <matrohon> tmorin
15:15:44 <matrohon> tmorin yep
15:16:05 <matrohon> tmorin we need to produce releasenotes for liberty first
15:16:37 <matrohon> so that documentation will be uptodate on docs.openstack.com
15:17:08 <matrohon> then add releasenotes files for mitaka
15:17:15 <tmorin> where are the releasenotes exactly published ?
15:17:40 <tmorin> is the note added in https://review.openstack.org/#/c/307140 enough to have something published ?
15:18:24 <matrohon> on the openstack web site for example http://docs.openstack.org/releasenotes/neutron/mitaka.html
15:19:16 <matrohon> tmorin, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/307140 is not enough, we need a gate job to publish on the web sites
15:19:41 <matrohon> which is the role of https://review.openstack.org/#/c/307150/
15:20:28 <matrohon> and of course backporting https://review.openstack.org/#/c/307046/
15:21:32 <matrohon> maybe the releaseteam needs to explictly trigger some tools, especially to publish our future liberty notes
15:21:52 <tmorin> yes, yes, but in net-bgpvpn we already have what is needed for a bootstrap
15:22:00 <tmorin> ah yes,
15:22:08 <tmorin> we need to backport 307046 first
15:22:11 <tmorin> let's do it now!
15:22:14 * tmorin doing that
15:22:21 <matrohon> yep
15:23:02 <tmorin> --> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/307871/
15:23:42 <matrohon> tmorin, thanks
15:24:23 <matrohon> the gate job has been merged too : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/307150/
15:24:27 <tmorin> good!
15:24:39 <matrohon> so now the only missing parts are the notes !
15:24:42 <matrohon> :)
15:25:20 * tmorin away for 5-10 minutes
15:25:37 <matrohon> the idea is to add them along with patches that need it
15:26:16 <matrohon> but we will add them for liberty and mitake in dedicated patches
15:26:47 <matrohon> tmorin, tell me when you'll be back, I don't want to discuss with myself :)
15:47:25 <matrohon> tmorin : back?
15:47:37 <matrohon> ok let's move on, only 13 min left
15:47:55 <matrohon> #topic : mitaka release
15:48:21 <matrohon> we need two patches to be able to release
15:48:28 <matrohon> first : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/296289/
15:48:53 <matrohon> the code looks fine now, we will merge it without UTs
15:49:04 <matrohon> and backport UTs when possible
15:49:26 <matrohon> second : the release note patch taht we talked about earlier
15:50:29 <matrohon> we'd like to ask for a release before the end of the week, some experimental jobs starts to fails with neutron/master
15:51:03 <matrohon> #topic newton summit
15:51:28 <matrohon> we are going to have a round table on friday (at least I have to ask for it :)
15:51:54 <matrohon> but we can have f2f meeting earlier in the week
15:53:00 <tmorin> I'm back
15:53:06 <tmorin> these were long minutes :-(
15:53:19 <matrohon> at least, during the friday's round table, we should have a good idea of what we are going to work on for newton, and we should be able to prioritize those items
15:53:33 <tmorin> yes, it will be good to have a f2f earlier in the week
15:53:42 <tmorin> yes
15:53:58 <tmorin> doodle to find a slot suitable for most people
15:54:47 <tmorin> who will be there by the way: matrohon, myself, enikher, pcarver_ (?)
15:55:01 <tmorin> timirnich: will jan be there as well ?
15:57:47 <tmorin> ok, let's broadcast a doodle to see who will be there, with a few tentative slots
15:58:51 <matrohon> tmorin, fine
15:59:44 <matrohon> ok let's close this meeting
15:59:55 <matrohon> #endmeeting